Original - Aftermath of the
Wounded Knee Massacre, January 1891. Three weeks after the event several bodies remain in the foreground partially wrapped in blankets on the snow.
Oppose I don't see the subject well. It took me a while to distinguish the bodies, especially since it is black and white. I think I would prefer this image to be VP. Consider nominating this at Valued Pictures, which may definitly be promoted if it meets the criteria. ZooFari02:34, 28 January 2009 (UTC)reply
Support per nom. A rare image and the fact that that it may take the viewer a bit of looking to distinguish the bodies in a photograph shot in such high contrast conditions so long ago is not a problem. Images don't have to to be easy to completely interpret at a glance to be powerful and evocative.
Mfield (
talk)
17:58, 28 January 2009 (UTC)reply
Support many people have romantic visions about cowboys and indians, kids play with their toys like I did. The cruelty of how it was is captured in material like this. This shows a reality that people rather forget.
GerardM (
talk)
20:23, 28 January 2009 (UTC)reply
Click on show to view the contents of this section
For all commenters: Remember, Valued pictures now exists on Wikipedia. It is time to start realizing what Valued pictures are and Featured pictures. It may qualify for both, but the best should be chosen. ZooFari03:16, 29 January 2009 (UTC)reply
If that is the case then it would be bordering on
WP:POINT. The desires and outcomes of other projects should have no bearing here. We are voting on this image with respect to this project only.
Mfield (
talk)
17:50, 29 January 2009 (UTC)reply
Oppose per ZooFari and Sasata. As perviously stated above, it is quite difficult to distinguish the bodies in the image and I don't think such an issue should occur in a Featured Picture. Nominating this at Valued Pictures would be the best bet, I think. Cheers,
Abraham, B.S. (
talk)
08:03, 29 January 2009 (UTC)reply
Support per nom. Perhaps amending the caption to read something like: "...the bodies of several Lakota Sioux (covered by blankets)..." would make it more obvious what this is.
Spikebrennan (
talk)
20:41, 30 January 2009 (UTC)reply
Comment Is that snow that is on the ground? Just curious, and should probably be mentioned in the caption if it is, as it is not in color. ZooFari05:15, 31 January 2009 (UTC)reply
Yes, done. 07:06, 31 January 2009 (UTC)
Support - also, it's clear to me that those are bodies (in reply to Oppose #1). The "subject" is scattered all over the battlefield, and I think that's obvious.
Xavexgoem (
talk)
09:45, 2 February 2009 (UTC)reply
Original - Aftermath of the
Wounded Knee Massacre, January 1891. Three weeks after the event several bodies remain in the foreground partially wrapped in blankets on the snow.
Oppose I don't see the subject well. It took me a while to distinguish the bodies, especially since it is black and white. I think I would prefer this image to be VP. Consider nominating this at Valued Pictures, which may definitly be promoted if it meets the criteria. ZooFari02:34, 28 January 2009 (UTC)reply
Support per nom. A rare image and the fact that that it may take the viewer a bit of looking to distinguish the bodies in a photograph shot in such high contrast conditions so long ago is not a problem. Images don't have to to be easy to completely interpret at a glance to be powerful and evocative.
Mfield (
talk)
17:58, 28 January 2009 (UTC)reply
Support many people have romantic visions about cowboys and indians, kids play with their toys like I did. The cruelty of how it was is captured in material like this. This shows a reality that people rather forget.
GerardM (
talk)
20:23, 28 January 2009 (UTC)reply
Click on show to view the contents of this section
For all commenters: Remember, Valued pictures now exists on Wikipedia. It is time to start realizing what Valued pictures are and Featured pictures. It may qualify for both, but the best should be chosen. ZooFari03:16, 29 January 2009 (UTC)reply
If that is the case then it would be bordering on
WP:POINT. The desires and outcomes of other projects should have no bearing here. We are voting on this image with respect to this project only.
Mfield (
talk)
17:50, 29 January 2009 (UTC)reply
Oppose per ZooFari and Sasata. As perviously stated above, it is quite difficult to distinguish the bodies in the image and I don't think such an issue should occur in a Featured Picture. Nominating this at Valued Pictures would be the best bet, I think. Cheers,
Abraham, B.S. (
talk)
08:03, 29 January 2009 (UTC)reply
Support per nom. Perhaps amending the caption to read something like: "...the bodies of several Lakota Sioux (covered by blankets)..." would make it more obvious what this is.
Spikebrennan (
talk)
20:41, 30 January 2009 (UTC)reply
Comment Is that snow that is on the ground? Just curious, and should probably be mentioned in the caption if it is, as it is not in color. ZooFari05:15, 31 January 2009 (UTC)reply
Yes, done. 07:06, 31 January 2009 (UTC)
Support - also, it's clear to me that those are bodies (in reply to Oppose #1). The "subject" is scattered all over the battlefield, and I think that's obvious.
Xavexgoem (
talk)
09:45, 2 February 2009 (UTC)reply