Comment Could someone who speaks German please check the copyright status of this image and the others uploaded by
cele4? I'm pretty sure they're fair game, but I would appreciate someone clearing this up for me since I don't understand the
source website. I'm confused because on its
special photos page it shows a number of images that have been featured on the German wiki, but on
other photos it says that they are not to be copied. Help? ~
MDD4696(
talk •
contribs)23:35, 5 December 2005 (UTC)reply
Erm—Cele4 claims to be Marcel Burkhard and claims to have taken the image himself. The external web site you give has an impressum, where Marcel Burkhard is given as the person responsible for that website. That user also has signed up at the German Wikipedia (
Benutzer:Cele4). I see no reason to doubt his claims, and certainly he has the right to publish his images elsewhere under whatever license he pleases, including "all rights reserved". It looks like some of the images he uploaded onto Wikipedia became featured pictures over at the German WP, and he mentions that fact on his own web site. There's nothing wrong with that. Note: by uploading something onto Wikipedia, he does not give up copyright! In fact, the copyright remains with him. But if he publishes and licenses an image under a free license on Wikipedia, anybody else can copy it, too, but that doesn't mean that that "anybody" had acquired the copyright. In summary: this looks perfectly fine to me, and
User:Cele4 should be thanked for sharing his great images and making them available under a free license. Thank you, Marcel!
Lupo15:59, 6 December 2005 (UTC)reply
Support. Great pic; I don't think it's necessary to have the rest of the fish in order to illustrate the article well. Sure, it would be nice, but this pic does it well.
Flcelloguy (
A note?)
21:09, 10 December 2005 (UTC)reply
Comment Could someone who speaks German please check the copyright status of this image and the others uploaded by
cele4? I'm pretty sure they're fair game, but I would appreciate someone clearing this up for me since I don't understand the
source website. I'm confused because on its
special photos page it shows a number of images that have been featured on the German wiki, but on
other photos it says that they are not to be copied. Help? ~
MDD4696(
talk •
contribs)23:35, 5 December 2005 (UTC)reply
Erm—Cele4 claims to be Marcel Burkhard and claims to have taken the image himself. The external web site you give has an impressum, where Marcel Burkhard is given as the person responsible for that website. That user also has signed up at the German Wikipedia (
Benutzer:Cele4). I see no reason to doubt his claims, and certainly he has the right to publish his images elsewhere under whatever license he pleases, including "all rights reserved". It looks like some of the images he uploaded onto Wikipedia became featured pictures over at the German WP, and he mentions that fact on his own web site. There's nothing wrong with that. Note: by uploading something onto Wikipedia, he does not give up copyright! In fact, the copyright remains with him. But if he publishes and licenses an image under a free license on Wikipedia, anybody else can copy it, too, but that doesn't mean that that "anybody" had acquired the copyright. In summary: this looks perfectly fine to me, and
User:Cele4 should be thanked for sharing his great images and making them available under a free license. Thank you, Marcel!
Lupo15:59, 6 December 2005 (UTC)reply
Support. Great pic; I don't think it's necessary to have the rest of the fish in order to illustrate the article well. Sure, it would be nice, but this pic does it well.
Flcelloguy (
A note?)
21:09, 10 December 2005 (UTC)reply