Support new nomination, oppose delist and replace. The earlier FP has plenty of educational and technical quality by today's standards, and unlike the new nomination it shows shadows on the planet's surface from the rings. --Pine✉19:25, 10 September 2018 (UTC)reply
Oppose (revised vote) – as is. File size is 325KB, it is too small for a 4613x2233 pixel image. But conditional Support if the 30.9MB TIFF
original here is converted to jpeg (much larger file size) and uploaded to Commons.
Bammesk (
talk)
01:54, 11 September 2018 (UTC)reply
Comment – I added the image
File:Saturn from Cassini Orbiter (2004-10-06).jpg to the two articles listed above. I am for keeping it as FP if the image stays in the articles. According to JPL's description
[1], it is the highest resolution (most detailed) image of the planet-and-rings that has been produced. Also 1) it shows the very faint outer
F-ring, which is not visible in the nom image, 2) it shows the strong shadows cast on the planet by the rings (upper hemisphere).
Bammesk (
talk)
03:22, 13 September 2018 (UTC)reply
Support new nomination, oppose delist and replace. The earlier FP has plenty of educational and technical quality by today's standards, and unlike the new nomination it shows shadows on the planet's surface from the rings. --Pine✉19:25, 10 September 2018 (UTC)reply
Oppose (revised vote) – as is. File size is 325KB, it is too small for a 4613x2233 pixel image. But conditional Support if the 30.9MB TIFF
original here is converted to jpeg (much larger file size) and uploaded to Commons.
Bammesk (
talk)
01:54, 11 September 2018 (UTC)reply
Comment – I added the image
File:Saturn from Cassini Orbiter (2004-10-06).jpg to the two articles listed above. I am for keeping it as FP if the image stays in the articles. According to JPL's description
[1], it is the highest resolution (most detailed) image of the planet-and-rings that has been produced. Also 1) it shows the very faint outer
F-ring, which is not visible in the nom image, 2) it shows the strong shadows cast on the planet by the rings (upper hemisphere).
Bammesk (
talk)
03:22, 13 September 2018 (UTC)reply