The article was removed 07:09, 8 November 2007.
This was a nice article for the time at its promotion in early 2005. But as Wiki-standards climbed toward the heavens, this page slowly rotted into the earth. The article is no longer well-written (1a), was never well-cited (1c), and is not particularly neutral (1d) in that it contains a bizarre personal essay on symbolism of character. I would love to fix the Hemingway pages some day, but it's a massive task — consider the trainwreck that is Ernest Hemingway — and for a topic of his importance, I'd need several months to do the background reading and research, or be part of a team of contributors. In the mean time, unless a Lost Generation expert is handy, I'm afraid this article is hopeless. -- JayHenry 05:48, 28 September 2007 (UTC) reply
The article was removed 07:09, 8 November 2007.
This was a nice article for the time at its promotion in early 2005. But as Wiki-standards climbed toward the heavens, this page slowly rotted into the earth. The article is no longer well-written (1a), was never well-cited (1c), and is not particularly neutral (1d) in that it contains a bizarre personal essay on symbolism of character. I would love to fix the Hemingway pages some day, but it's a massive task — consider the trainwreck that is Ernest Hemingway — and for a topic of his importance, I'd need several months to do the background reading and research, or be part of a team of contributors. In the mean time, unless a Lost Generation expert is handy, I'm afraid this article is hopeless. -- JayHenry 05:48, 28 September 2007 (UTC) reply