The article was removed by Dana boomer 16:48, 4 October 2012 [1].
Operation Downfall ( | talk | history | protect | delete | links | watch | logs | views)
Toolbox |
---|
I am nominating this featured article for review because I posted about concerns on the article talk on 29 Aug. A few minor edits were made 29-31 Aug, but nowhere near addressing the concerns. Two users posted agreeing substantial work is needed: several page needed and citation needed tags, unsourced paragraphs, weak prose, heavy reliance on mostly just two sources, dead link on Silkett, could mention more the "intimidate-Soviets" aspect, isn't at all comprehensive, and doesn't reflect modern scholarship on this topic (especially Giangreco's book Hell to Pay, which is probably the best available book on this subject). PumpkinSky talk 15:46, 5 September 2012 (UTC) reply
Comments: Unfortunately this article now falls well short of FA standards. Some issues include:
Comments:
Originally this article met the FA standards of the day; I doubt it would pass today though without some work. In addition to the above, two further issues I'd note:
The article was removed by Dana boomer 16:48, 4 October 2012 [1].
Operation Downfall ( | talk | history | protect | delete | links | watch | logs | views)
Toolbox |
---|
I am nominating this featured article for review because I posted about concerns on the article talk on 29 Aug. A few minor edits were made 29-31 Aug, but nowhere near addressing the concerns. Two users posted agreeing substantial work is needed: several page needed and citation needed tags, unsourced paragraphs, weak prose, heavy reliance on mostly just two sources, dead link on Silkett, could mention more the "intimidate-Soviets" aspect, isn't at all comprehensive, and doesn't reflect modern scholarship on this topic (especially Giangreco's book Hell to Pay, which is probably the best available book on this subject). PumpkinSky talk 15:46, 5 September 2012 (UTC) reply
Comments: Unfortunately this article now falls well short of FA standards. Some issues include:
Comments:
Originally this article met the FA standards of the day; I doubt it would pass today though without some work. In addition to the above, two further issues I'd note: