I think it passes the criteria, but one observation I have is that she used the Boy Toy image for the Like a Virgin album not this one.
190.233.10.154 (
talk)
16:15, 11 May 2010 (UTC)reply
I appreciate your concern, but as is clearly stated by the "
Lucky Star" article, she started using the Boy-Toy belt from that point of time. Hence it seggregates more from this era than the LAV era. The LAV era is more remembered for the Virginal bride iconography IMO.
--Legolas(talk2me)03:18, 12 May 2010 (UTC)reply
Comment: I'm confused about something. The "Lucky star" article says it was the "fifth and the last single from the album" and the "Borderline" article says it was "the fourth single[...] became Madonna's first top ten song on the Billboard Hot 100", yet the singles chronology says it was the other way around. So, which is it? --
109.166.136.53 (
talk)
10:15, 12 May 2010 (UTC)reply
It is exactly for this reason that I ommitted The Virgin Tour and Who's That Girl World Tour from this and the True Blue GTC nominations. They are more in lieu in terms of thematic, timeline wise and prmotionwise with the latter albums and hence should be clubbed together, when they are nominated (which I plan to do pretty soon). Hence I believe, these six articles are fine as themselves in the GTC.
--Legolas(talk2me)03:16, 17 May 2010 (UTC)reply
Buggie111 and myself are nominating this for a GT because we feel that we have done all the work necesary to get them all to GA's. We got the articles that deal with the battleships themselves promoted earlier today. Buggie111 is aware of this because he asked me to start the nomination himself as he is currently buisy. Thanks.--
White Shadowsyou're breaking up23:08, 30 April 2010 (UTC)reply
Comment - the Original Unaired Pilot is covered in the Pilot's article. Can you make the link in the table redirect to the appropriate paragraph there?
rst20xx (
talk)
18:22, 27 April 2010 (UTC)reply
Nomination for GT. No Tosa-class battleship was built, but Tosa was used for many ordnance experiments and Kaga was converted into an aircraft carrier. All articles are at GA or above, and Tosa is up for FAC now
here (hint, hint, go review :) This is another
WP:OMT nom. Regards, —Ed(talk •
majestic titan)07:38, 24 April 2010 (UTC)reply
Comment - please remember to include the title of the topic in a section header, or else people can't easily edit this nomination -
rst20xx (
talk)
14:29, 22 April 2010 (UTC)reply
Oppose -
Celebration: The Video Collection needs to be added, as ChrisTheDude says. It needs to be brought up to GA first of all. Also, I don't think this topic can just be called "Celebration" as there are other potential topics that could go under this name, for example one on
Celebration (band). It needs to be disambiguated -
rst20xx (
talk)
14:32, 22 April 2010 (UTC)reply
I'd say just call the topic "Celebration (Madonna album)". As there is no longer a massive GAN backlog I see no reason this nomination can't be put on hold whilst that article has a crack at GA, if you're going to work on the Video Collection right now -
rst20xx (
talk)
04:42, 23 April 2010 (UTC)reply
I think it passes the criteria, but one observation I have is that she used the Boy Toy image for the Like a Virgin album not this one.
190.233.10.154 (
talk)
16:15, 11 May 2010 (UTC)reply
I appreciate your concern, but as is clearly stated by the "
Lucky Star" article, she started using the Boy-Toy belt from that point of time. Hence it seggregates more from this era than the LAV era. The LAV era is more remembered for the Virginal bride iconography IMO.
--Legolas(talk2me)03:18, 12 May 2010 (UTC)reply
Comment: I'm confused about something. The "Lucky star" article says it was the "fifth and the last single from the album" and the "Borderline" article says it was "the fourth single[...] became Madonna's first top ten song on the Billboard Hot 100", yet the singles chronology says it was the other way around. So, which is it? --
109.166.136.53 (
talk)
10:15, 12 May 2010 (UTC)reply
It is exactly for this reason that I ommitted The Virgin Tour and Who's That Girl World Tour from this and the True Blue GTC nominations. They are more in lieu in terms of thematic, timeline wise and prmotionwise with the latter albums and hence should be clubbed together, when they are nominated (which I plan to do pretty soon). Hence I believe, these six articles are fine as themselves in the GTC.
--Legolas(talk2me)03:16, 17 May 2010 (UTC)reply
Buggie111 and myself are nominating this for a GT because we feel that we have done all the work necesary to get them all to GA's. We got the articles that deal with the battleships themselves promoted earlier today. Buggie111 is aware of this because he asked me to start the nomination himself as he is currently buisy. Thanks.--
White Shadowsyou're breaking up23:08, 30 April 2010 (UTC)reply
Comment - the Original Unaired Pilot is covered in the Pilot's article. Can you make the link in the table redirect to the appropriate paragraph there?
rst20xx (
talk)
18:22, 27 April 2010 (UTC)reply
Nomination for GT. No Tosa-class battleship was built, but Tosa was used for many ordnance experiments and Kaga was converted into an aircraft carrier. All articles are at GA or above, and Tosa is up for FAC now
here (hint, hint, go review :) This is another
WP:OMT nom. Regards, —Ed(talk •
majestic titan)07:38, 24 April 2010 (UTC)reply
Comment - please remember to include the title of the topic in a section header, or else people can't easily edit this nomination -
rst20xx (
talk)
14:29, 22 April 2010 (UTC)reply
Oppose -
Celebration: The Video Collection needs to be added, as ChrisTheDude says. It needs to be brought up to GA first of all. Also, I don't think this topic can just be called "Celebration" as there are other potential topics that could go under this name, for example one on
Celebration (band). It needs to be disambiguated -
rst20xx (
talk)
14:32, 22 April 2010 (UTC)reply
I'd say just call the topic "Celebration (Madonna album)". As there is no longer a massive GAN backlog I see no reason this nomination can't be put on hold whilst that article has a crack at GA, if you're going to work on the Video Collection right now -
rst20xx (
talk)
04:42, 23 April 2010 (UTC)reply