Lincalinca ( talk · contribs) I just want to know what you guys all think of my editing. This is kind of my "How's My Driving? Call 1800 EAT SHIT" sticker on my wiki-car. linca linca 06:14, 3 August 2007 (UTC)
Reviews
I reviewed some of your comments, particularly at Talk:Dream Days at the Hotel Existence and Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Albums. I am impressed by your familiarity with the inner workings of Wikipedia and your dedication to collaborating with other users to produce excellent articles.
I have a few pointers for you.
I wish you good luck. Shalom Hello 03:17, 5 August 2007 (UTC)
Hey Linca! Obviously, this is a very biased review (the best kind). Firstly, I agree with Shalom's edit summary comment, although you use them almost always in the mainspace, which is good. However, you use (quite frequently) summaries such as "tweak" and "add info" - useful in some contexts, but they don't always fulfill the purpose of edit summaries, which is to fully summarise your edits so we don't have to load the diff.
{{ Studio60}} is awesome - you deserved the barnstar for it, great work on that. Gah, I hate editor reviews where I don't have a shitload to say ;) Keep up the good work, and listen to Shalom, who's a much better reviewer then I am (and a bit less biased). Giggy Talk | Review 22:34, 6 August 2007 (UTC)
Comments
Questions
Lincalinca ( talk · contribs) I just want to know what you guys all think of my editing. This is kind of my "How's My Driving? Call 1800 EAT SHIT" sticker on my wiki-car. linca linca 06:14, 3 August 2007 (UTC)
Reviews
I reviewed some of your comments, particularly at Talk:Dream Days at the Hotel Existence and Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Albums. I am impressed by your familiarity with the inner workings of Wikipedia and your dedication to collaborating with other users to produce excellent articles.
I have a few pointers for you.
I wish you good luck. Shalom Hello 03:17, 5 August 2007 (UTC)
Hey Linca! Obviously, this is a very biased review (the best kind). Firstly, I agree with Shalom's edit summary comment, although you use them almost always in the mainspace, which is good. However, you use (quite frequently) summaries such as "tweak" and "add info" - useful in some contexts, but they don't always fulfill the purpose of edit summaries, which is to fully summarise your edits so we don't have to load the diff.
{{ Studio60}} is awesome - you deserved the barnstar for it, great work on that. Gah, I hate editor reviews where I don't have a shitload to say ;) Keep up the good work, and listen to Shalom, who's a much better reviewer then I am (and a bit less biased). Giggy Talk | Review 22:34, 6 August 2007 (UTC)
Comments
Questions