Matthewrbowker ( talk · contribs · count) I've been editing Wikipedia for a few months, and I want to know how I'm doing as an editor. Matthewrbowker ( talk) 20:58, 9 November 2010 (UTC)
Questions
Reviews
I can see that although you have not been here for long you are quite busy :¬)
I will not do a full review as I feel that there is not enough there yet for too many comments. I would like to say that concentrating on vandalism is a valid job but it may be better to get a general feel of policy and procedure, perhaps in more depth, as you may find this benefits you in the long run. Fior example the Blender page you have added a "main" link but that section, and the whole page, is full of html links which should not really be there.
I noticed that you made a revert here [1] with smackbot - did you notice that the addition was in fact correct information [2] and, if so, did you consider turning it into an addition rather than reverting it? I am not saying that you did anything wrong, far from it, but consider whether you could have spent a few minutes to make the addition valid and adding a ref for it ?
Also it may be that the revert would have been better as an undo - reverting is really only for vandalism, reowgfniowiefn, sh*t, c*ck sucker etc. and the warning you gave may have been a little out of place as User talk:68.39.191.247was in fact only trying to add correct information rather than vandalising the page.
Also I noticed that you assessed the Gay? article yet you are not a member of the project in question - did you follow their particular MOS or review process when you did that ?
Your interactions seem fine, apart from the one you mentioned, and you managed to keep your cool on the Talk:Code Lyoko page.
Your article contributions are pretty good as well, nice additions of refs for the Pikes Peak Library District article. Do you use the additional editing features ? they give cite templates which are pretty easy to use just above the editing window. (you should see Advanced > Special Characters > Help > Cite at the top if they are enabled)
Keep up the good work ! Chaosdruid ( talk) 01:55, 10 November 2010 (UTC)
Matthewrbowker ( talk · contribs · count) I've been editing Wikipedia for a few months, and I want to know how I'm doing as an editor. Matthewrbowker ( talk) 20:58, 9 November 2010 (UTC)
Questions
Reviews
I can see that although you have not been here for long you are quite busy :¬)
I will not do a full review as I feel that there is not enough there yet for too many comments. I would like to say that concentrating on vandalism is a valid job but it may be better to get a general feel of policy and procedure, perhaps in more depth, as you may find this benefits you in the long run. Fior example the Blender page you have added a "main" link but that section, and the whole page, is full of html links which should not really be there.
I noticed that you made a revert here [1] with smackbot - did you notice that the addition was in fact correct information [2] and, if so, did you consider turning it into an addition rather than reverting it? I am not saying that you did anything wrong, far from it, but consider whether you could have spent a few minutes to make the addition valid and adding a ref for it ?
Also it may be that the revert would have been better as an undo - reverting is really only for vandalism, reowgfniowiefn, sh*t, c*ck sucker etc. and the warning you gave may have been a little out of place as User talk:68.39.191.247was in fact only trying to add correct information rather than vandalising the page.
Also I noticed that you assessed the Gay? article yet you are not a member of the project in question - did you follow their particular MOS or review process when you did that ?
Your interactions seem fine, apart from the one you mentioned, and you managed to keep your cool on the Talk:Code Lyoko page.
Your article contributions are pretty good as well, nice additions of refs for the Pikes Peak Library District article. Do you use the additional editing features ? they give cite templates which are pretty easy to use just above the editing window. (you should see Advanced > Special Characters > Help > Cite at the top if they are enabled)
Keep up the good work ! Chaosdruid ( talk) 01:55, 10 November 2010 (UTC)