| Category |
Decision |
Discussion_log
|
|
Category:2000s East Coast hip hop album stubs |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 25
|
|
Category:2nd-millennium establishments in the Austrian Empire |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 23
|
|
Category:5th-century German people |
Rename |
June 6
|
|
Category:7th-century Gothic people |
rename, removing
John of Gothia. Note: the Women categories are currently empty, so I will delete them, but without prejudice to them being re-created at the target names if they look useful. – |
June 26
|
|
Category:A-League National Youth League templates |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 4
|
|
Category:Access network shows |
merge (
non-admin closure) |
June 21
|
|
Category:Aegean civilizations |
Withdrawn by nominator |
June 5
|
|
Category:African comedians |
relisted, see
here (
non-admin closure) |
June 25
|
|
Category:Agrophysics institutions |
Merge |
June 9
|
|
Category:Albums produced by StreetRunner |
Delete |
June 11
|
|
Category:Alumni by university or college in the Palestinian territories |
rename. – |
June 10
|
|
Category:Ancient history of the Carpathian-Dniester area |
Merge |
June 28
|
|
Category:Ancient tribes in Moldova |
Delete |
June 28
|
|
Category:Annelids by country |
merge (
non-admin closure) |
June 12
|
|
Category:Annelids of Indonesia |
merge (
non-admin closure) |
June 4
|
|
Category:Anti-cult organizations and individuals |
Merge |
June 9
|
|
Category:Armenian Americans |
Merge to
Category:American people of Armenian descent |
June 1
|
|
Category:Armenian terrorist groups |
Merge |
June 17
|
|
Category:Armenian writers |
 Relisted at
Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 July 11#Category:Armenian writers |
June 19
|
|
Category:Association for Democracy and People's Livelihood |
Rename. Deletion is best considered separately |
June 17
|
|
Category:Austrian resistance |
Rename |
June 17
|
|
Category:Bacteria cognition |
Delete |
June 2
|
|
Category:Balochistan conflict |
Rename |
June 17
|
|
Category:Baseball in Harwich, Massachusetts |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 8
|
|
Category:Baseball teams in Harwich, Massachusetts |
merge (
non-admin closure) |
June 8
|
|
Category:Batman characters |
No consensus |
June 9
|
|
Category:Borders of Palestine |
delete and redirect (
non-admin closure) |
June 20
|
| Bplus-Class articles |
Merge to B class |
June 30
|
|
Category:Brian Smith (administrator) |
wrong venue for what's being proposed. The content in question is an article, not a category |
June 18
|
|
Category:Bronze Age Greek art |
rename to :
Category:Aegean art of the Bronze Age. (
non-admin closure) |
June 8
|
|
Category:Bronze Age palaces in Greece |
rename to
Category:Aegean palaces of the Bronze Age. (
non-admin closure) |
June 8
|
|
Category:Bronze Age sites in Greece |
keep (
non-admin closure) |
June 8
|
|
Category:Buildings and structures in Rundu |
merge (
non-admin closure) |
June 8
|
|
Category:Camelon F.C. players |
Rename |
June 10
|
|
Category:Candidates for speedy deletion as duplicating an existing topic |
Rename |
June 8
|
|
Category:Candidates for speedy deletion as having been created by blocked or banned users |
keep (
non-admin closure) |
June 8
|
|
Category:Cantons of Rojava |
Rename |
June 17
|
|
Category:Cape Verdean football club stubs |
no consensus.
(non-admin closure) |
June 21
|
|
Category:Chocolate usage |
procedural close. Category has been deleted already. (
non-admin closure) |
June 12
|
|
Category:Christopher Memminger |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 3
|
|
Category:Cleanup tagged articles with a reason field from October 2008 |
procedural close, category has been deleted already. (
non-admin closure) |
June 23
|
|
Category:Cleanup tagged articles without a reason field from August 2007 |
speedy delete |
June 24
|
|
Category:Clerici vagantes |
delete. – |
June 23
|
|
Category:Companies based in Erode |
merge, also to
Category:Erode. (
non-admin closure) |
June 3
|
|
Category:Computer companies |
keep with no prejudice against renominating as part of a broader nomination. (
non-admin closure) |
June 24
|
|
Category:County routes in Atlantic County, New Jersey |
Rename to
Category:Roads in X County, New Jersey |
June 5
|
|
Category:Crimes related to the European migrant crisis |
Delete |
June 18
|
|
Category:Cult-related books |
rename
Category:Cult-related books as nominated,
Category:Cult-related media to
Category:Media about cults. "Category:Media about Foo" is not common, but not impossible to find, either. It may be worth discussing categories using such naming conventions at a later time, but discussion leans in support of employing it here |
June 3
|
|
Category:Dan Simmons |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 8
|
|
Category:Daya |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 4
|
|
Category:Destroyed landmarks in Spain demolished during the Medieval Spain |
Delete |
June 24
|
|
Category:Disputed chemical diagrams |
keep (
non-admin closure) |
June 23
|
|
Category:Dunipace Juniors F.C. |
Rename |
June 10
|
| Early medieval French people |
No consensus |
June 22
|
|
Category:Education in Rojava |
rename (
non-admin closure) |
June 17
|
|
Category:Engravers from the Republic of Geneva |
Close and recommend a new broader nomination. This discussion is complicated by user conduct issues and other categories have been created. It's best to start from scratch on this |
June 10
|
|
Category:Establishments in the Austrian Empire by century |
merge (
non-admin closure) |
June 23
|
|
Category:Eukaryotes by year |
Merge |
June 28
|
|
Category:Exotic fruits |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 4
|
|
Category:Female generals and flag officers |
rename (
non-admin closure). @
Zanhe: Could you also nominate the subcategories by nationality for renaming? |
June 19
|
|
Category:Fictional characters convicted of hate crimes |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 3
|
|
Category:Fictional child assassins |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 3
|
|
Category:Fictional LGBT characters in radio |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 18
|
|
Category:Fictional organizations designated as hate groups |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 3
|
|
Category:Fictional organizations designated as revolutionary |
rename (
non-admin closure) |
June 4
|
|
Category:Fictional prison physicians |
merge (
non-admin closure) |
June 11
|
|
Category:Film directors from Glendale, California |
merge (
non-admin closure) |
June 13
|
|
Category:Films adapted into video games |
Kept |
June 12
|
|
Category:First-person open world games |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 18
|
|
Category:Fish of Australia subcats. |
keep (
non-admin closure) |
June 20
|
|
Category:Footballers of Armenian descent |
Delete |
June 5
|
|
Category:Footballers of Iranian descent |
Delete |
June 5
|
|
Category:Footballers' wives and girlfriends |
no consensus (
non-admin closure) |
June 5
|
|
Category:Ford video games |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 20
|
|
Category:Foreign Legion |
merge (
non-admin closure) |
June 15
|
|
Category:French women classical violinists |
merge (
non-admin closure) |
June 2
|
|
Category:Gail Godwin |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 8
|
|
Category:General Secretaries of British trade unions |
Rename |
June 13
|
|
Category:Generation ship fiction |
rename. Although no other editors have expressed support, the nomination seems valid, and the target name conforms better with sibling categories. – |
June 8
|
|
Category:Geoff Johns |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 8
|
|
Category:Glass makers and brands |
relisted, see
here. (
non-admin closure) |
June 24
|
|
Category:God Eater (series) |
rename (
non-admin closure) |
June 3
|
|
Category:Government of United Republic of Tanzania |
merge to
Category:Local government in Tanzania. (
non-admin closure) |
June 20
|
|
Category:Grain elevators in the United States |
keep (
non-admin closure) |
June 4
|
|
Category:Green Party (Colombia) |
rename the second,
WP:SOFTDELETE of the first. – |
June 17
|
|
Category:Halloween (franchise) |
Rename |
June 17
|
|
Category:Harris Flanagin |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 3
|
|
Category:High school students who committed suicide |
Not moved |
June 10
|
|
Category:History of the Republic of Italy |
rename (
non-admin closure) |
June 17
|
|
Category:Hospitality companies by city |
Delete |
June 30
|
|
Category:Hospitality companies established in the 2nd millennium |
Delete |
June 30
|
|
Category:Hotel and leisure companies |
Merge |
June 30
|
|
Category:Illyrism |
rename (
non-admin closure) |
June 17
|
|
Category:Imperial generals of the Holy Roman Empire |
Rename |
June 4
|
|
Category:Intra-Palestinian peace efforts |
no consensus (
non-admin closure) |
June 25
|
|
Category:Intra-Palestinian peace efforts |
relisted, see
here (
non-admin closure) |
June 17
|
|
Category:Iran–Saudi proxy conflict |
Rename |
June 17
|
|
Category:Jain monks by nationality |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 5
|
|
Category:James Ellroy |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 8
|
|
Category:Japanese adult animated television series |
Delete |
June 16
|
|
Category:Jedi Apprentice |
Rename |
June 17
|
|
Category:Jewish-related controversies |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 24
|
|
Category:John Barth |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 8
|
|
Category:John D. MacDonald |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 8
|
|
Category:Ken Wilber |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 8
|
|
Category:Kurdistan Workers' Party factions |
Merge |
June 17
|
|
Category:La songs |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 13
|
|
Category:Languages of medieval Macedonia |
Delete |
June 4
|
|
Category:Latin Grammy Award venues |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 6
|
|
Category:Legislature/Parliament of Nepal |
merge to
Category:Parliament of Nepal but I'll move the provincial article and subcat to
Category:Government of Nepal. (
non-admin closure) |
June 17
|
|
Category:Lists of mayors of Dodoma Municipal |
delete both (
non-admin closure) |
June 20
|
|
Category:Lords Advocate |
Rename |
June 20
|
|
Category:Ludvík Svoboda |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 18
|
|
Category:Lusitanian Integralism |
rename. (
non-admin closure) |
June 17
|
|
Category:Marine fauna of Australia |
keep without objection to creating the proposed target and populating it manually. (
non-admin closure) |
June 18
|
|
Category:Massachusetts Registered Historic Place stubs |
delete and upmerge templates |
June 18
|
|
Category:Medical equipment manufacturers |
Rename |
June 19
|
| Medieval Holy Roman Empire people |
Merge/delete |
June 2
|
|
Category:Medieval Iran |
Merge to
Category:Medieval Persia |
June 24
|
|
Category:Miami-Dade County, Florida |
keep at least until an RM has taken place about the article name. (
non-admin closure) |
June 22
|
|
Category:Military history of Rojava |
delete
Category:Rojava involvement in the Syrian Civil War. As a consequence,
Category:Wars involving Rojava becomes empty so
WP:SOFTDELETE that also. Rename the other three to
Category:Military history of the Democratic Federation of Northern Syria,
Category:Military operations of the Iraqi Civil War involving the Democratic Federation of Northern Syria and
Category:Military operations of the Syrian Civil War involving the Democratic Federation of Northern Syria. – |
June 17
|
| Military installations 2 |
Rename |
June 4
|
|
Category:Military units and formations of the Waffen-SS |
no consensus (
non-admin closure) |
June 3
|
| Misnamed portal categories |
rename/merge (
non-admin closure) |
June 6
|
|
Category:Monasteries in Scotland by order |
Delete/Merge/Rename |
June 8
|
|
Category:MonsterVerse films |
Rename |
June 17
|
|
Category:Moon in film |
no consensus. It may be helpful to create the proposed category as a sub-category of the existing one; Apollo 13 notably features the moon in film, even though it's not set on the moon (or fictional). – |
June 15
|
|
Category:Movement 2 June |
Rename |
June 17
|
|
Category:Movement for Change politicians |
rename (
non-admin closure) |
June 17
|
|
Category:Musical artists on the Voyager Golden Record |
Delete |
June 11
|
|
Category:National Academy of Sciences laureates |
No consensus to delete'; rename to
Category:Recipients of awards from the United States National Academy of Sciences |
June 30
|
|
Category:National Premier Soccer League season by team navigational boxes |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 4
|
|
Category:National romanticism |
rename (
non-admin closure) |
June 17
|
|
Category:Nationalist Party of Australia members of the Parliament of Queensland |
rename |
June 30
|
|
Category:Native American LGBT-related films |
delete without objection to creating a film category with a wider scope. For reference, these are the films that were in this category:
Big Eden,
The Business of Fancydancing and
Drunktown's Finest. (
non-admin closure) |
June 1
|
|
Category:Obscenity controversies in television |
Delete |
June 22
|
|
Category:Obscenity controversies in television |
relisted, see
here. (
non-admin closure) |
June 14
|
|
Category:Open world video games |
No consensus |
June 4
|
|
Category:Opposition to same-sex marriage |
Keep and purge of biographies then look again at the result |
June 26
|
|
Category:Pages using infobox U.S. federal court with unknown parameters |
procedural close, the category has already been deleted per
WP:G8. (
non-admin closure) |
June 29
|
| Palestinian territories |
rename (or merge). – |
June 6
|
|
Category:Peerage of the United Kingdom duke stubs |
Delete/upmerge |
June 21
|
|
Category:People associated with Charles Bukowski |
delete. – |
June 8
|
|
Category:People associated with George Washington |
Delete |
June 1
|
|
Category:People associated with Gilbert and Sullivan |
no consensus. The late suggestion by Peterkingiron to split the category might be worth a fresh discussion. – |
June 8
|
|
Category:People associated with James Joyce |
no consensus. – |
June 8
|
|
Category:People associated with Shakespeare |
keep. – |
June 8
|
|
Category:People associated with William Blake |
keep. – |
June 8
|
|
Category:People from Upper Sandusky, Ohio |
withdrawn (
non-admin closure) |
June 14
|
|
Category:People of the Merovingian period |
No consensus to delete; rename to
Category:People of the Merovingian Kingdom |
June 20
|
|
Category:People without hands |
keep (
non-admin closure) |
June 6
|
|
Category:Personal transporter manufacturers |
keep since the RM did not result in a rename of the main article either. (
non-admin closure) |
June 7
|
|
Category:Personal transporters |
withdrawn (
non-admin closure) |
June 7
|
|
Category:Philip José Farmer |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 8
|
| Polish–Lithuanian Commonwealth |
Delete all |
June 19
|
|
Category:Politicians in Tanzania |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 20
|
|
Category:Potential predatory publishers |
delete. – |
June 23
|
|
Category:Protostomes by location |
Merge/delete |
June 6
|
|
Category:Protostomes in popular culture |
merge. Participation to this particular discussion is low, but other protostomes categories have been upmerged before for the same reason. (
non-admin closure) |
June 5
|
|
Category:Railway stations served by Virgin Trains East Coast |
Rename |
June 24
|
|
Category:Redirects from Twitter usernames |
keep |
June 25
|
|
Category:Revolutionary People's Liberation Party–Front |
result |
June 17
|
|
Category:Revolutions of 1917–23 |
Rename |
June 17
|
|
Category:Rick Bonadio |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 26
|
|
Category:Saga (band) songs |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 5
|
| Scheduled monuments |
Rename/Keep at Scheduled Monuments per suggestion below |
June 7
|
|
Category:Sectarian conflict in Mandatory Palestine |
Rename |
June 17
|
|
Category:Serbian Radical Party of the Republika Srpska |
rename the second,
WP:SOFTDELETE of the first. – |
June 17
|
|
Category:Seven Wonders of Serbia |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 4
|
|
Category:Sister city and Twin city |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 26
|
|
Category:Soest |
rename (
non-admin closure) |
June 29
|
|
Category:Soil and crop science organizations |
keep. – |
June 17
|
|
Category:Songs about bridges |
delete category. For anyone who desires to create a list article (e.g |
June 8
|
|
Category:Songs about men |
Delete. Note that
Category:Songs about women has also been deleted |
June 28
|
|
Category:Songs about stars |
Delete |
June 10
|
|
Category:Songs about streets and roads |
Delete |
June 7
|
|
Category:Songs about women |
Delete |
June 28
|
|
Category:Soulcalibur (series) |
rename following outcome of RM. (
non-admin closure) |
June 12
|
|
Category:Sports clubs in South Dublin |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 16
|
|
Category:Sports in Cypress, California |
merge (
non-admin closure) |
June 8
|
|
Category:Sports in Fridley, Minnesota |
merge (
non-admin closure) |
June 8
|
|
Category:Sports in Harwich, Massachusetts |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 8
|
|
Category:Sports in Highland, California |
merge (
non-admin closure) |
June 8
|
|
Category:Sports venues in Cypress, California |
merge (
non-admin closure) |
June 8
|
| Sportspeople (Part 1) |
Not rename.
(non-admin closure) |
June 10
|
|
Category:Suicide in films |
delete. The consensus here is that this category simply categorizes films simply in which suicide occurs, which is not a defining characteristic of that film. In the cases where the film is about suicide,
Category:Films about suicide should be utilized |
June 26
|
|
Category:Sulphur mining |
No consensus |
June 20
|
|
Category:Sultan Rahi |
Delete |
June 30
|
|
Category:Taxa named by Francis Walker (entomologist) |
Merge |
June 1
|
|
Category:Teen songs |
Rename |
June 13
|
|
Category:The Mummy films |
Rename |
June 17
|
|
Category:The Purge films |
Rename |
June 17
|
|
Category:Third-person open world games |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 18
|
| Topic based anime and manga categories |
Rename |
June 16
|
|
Category:Tourist traps |
Delete |
June 4
|
|
Category:Trachinoidei |
relist, see
here. (
non-admin closure) |
June 16
|
|
Category:Trachinoidei |
Rename to
Category:Trachiniformes |
June 24
|
|
Category:Trade associations |
No consensus |
June 22
|
|
Category:Traditional clothing |
merge both to
Category:Folk costumes. (For the record, I am also manually merging the corresponding categories in Urdu Wikipedia, which may have been copied from here and are poorly populated. However, Finnish and Vietnamese have both "traditional" and "national" categories, so I am not merging the Wikidata entries.) – |
June 21
|
|
Category:Traditional clothing |
relisted, see
here (
non-admin closure) |
June 13
|
|
Category:Train operating companies |
Rename to
Category:Train operating companies in the United Kingdom |
June 18
|
|
Category:Tranent Juniors F.C. players |
Nomination withdrawn |
June 10
|
|
Category:Transformers (film) video games |
Rename |
June 17
|
|
Category:Transhumant ethnic groups |
No consensus |
June 14
|
|
Category:True crime films |
merge |
June 15
|
|
Category:Underworld (film series) |
merge (
non-admin closure) |
June 17
|
|
Category:Unitarian chapels in Nottinghamshire |
dual merge (
non-admin closure) |
June 22
|
|
Category:United Nations non-governmental organizations |
Relisted at
Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 July 18#Category:United Nations non-governmental organizations |
June 1
|
|
Category:Unitrans |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 7
|
| University of Alaska System |
no consensus on
Category:University of Alaska System and
Category:Presidents of the University of Alaska System; keep the other three. (
non-admin closure) |
June 14
|
| University of Alaska System |
relisted, see
here (
non-admin closure) |
June 6
|
|
Category:Water parks in Idaho |
relisted, see
here. (
non-admin closure) |
June 25
|
|
Category:Westworld characters |
merge (
non-admin closure) |
June 17
|
|
Category:Wikipedia articles needing reorganization from March 2010 |
procedural close, category has been deleted already. (
non-admin closure) |
June 23
|
|
Category:Wikipedia articles needing reorganization from May 2010 |
procedural close, category has been deleted already. (
non-admin closure) |
June 23
|
|
Category:Wikipedia articles needing reorganization from September 2008 |
procedural close, category has been deleted already. (
non-admin closure) |
June 23
|
|
Category:Wikipedia articles needing reorganization from September 2009 |
procedural close, category has been deleted already. (
non-admin closure) |
June 23
|
|
Category:Wikipedia articles needing time reference citations from March 2018 |
speedy delete |
June 24
|
|
Category:Wing commanders |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
June 20
|
|
Category:Wintering birds |
Delete/merge |
June 26
|
|
Category:Years in Rojava |
Withdrawn.
(non-admin closure) |
June 17
|
|
Category:Yemeni civil war (2015–present) |
Rename |
June 17
|