The following discussion comes from Wikipedia:Categories for deletion. This is an archive of the discussion only; please do not edit this page. - Kbdank71 17:35, 21 Mar 2005 (UTC)
There's a strong convention of "Bridges in Foo" for categories. Something needs to be done about Category:London River Crossings; Category:Bridges_in_London also exists. There are a small number of non-bridges in the former, though, including tunnels and a ferry. In contrast, the Holland Tunnel is under Category:Transportation in New York City and Category:Tunnels and Template:NYC Hudson River crossings. I propose putting bridges only in Category:Bridges_in_London, deleting Category:London River Crossings and putting the rest of its contents in Category:Transport_in_London. If kept, it needs to be renamed Category:London river crossings or more preferably, Category:River crossings in London. (This is a re-nomination since the first one was confused and didn't resolve.) -- Beland 06:14, 17 Jan 2005 (UTC)
See #Category:London River Crossings below. The "river crossings" category is an exact duplicate of the "bridges" category, except that it also contains tunnels. The consensus below seemed to be that "river crossings" is not very useful because not all bridges and tunnels actually cross rivers. - Aranel ("Sarah") 23:57, 6 Feb 2005 (UTC)
These should be merged, but Category:London River Crossings is confusing. I recommend Category:Bridges and tunnels in London, kicking the lone ferry to Category:Transport in London, and making the merged category also a child thereof. (Thanks to Willmcw who noticed this issue slipping through the cracks.) -- Beland 05:38, 11 Mar 2005 (UTC)
The following discussion comes from Wikipedia:Categories for deletion. This is an archive of the discussion only; please do not edit this page. - Kbdank71 17:35, 21 Mar 2005 (UTC)
There's a strong convention of "Bridges in Foo" for categories. Something needs to be done about Category:London River Crossings; Category:Bridges_in_London also exists. There are a small number of non-bridges in the former, though, including tunnels and a ferry. In contrast, the Holland Tunnel is under Category:Transportation in New York City and Category:Tunnels and Template:NYC Hudson River crossings. I propose putting bridges only in Category:Bridges_in_London, deleting Category:London River Crossings and putting the rest of its contents in Category:Transport_in_London. If kept, it needs to be renamed Category:London river crossings or more preferably, Category:River crossings in London. (This is a re-nomination since the first one was confused and didn't resolve.) -- Beland 06:14, 17 Jan 2005 (UTC)
See #Category:London River Crossings below. The "river crossings" category is an exact duplicate of the "bridges" category, except that it also contains tunnels. The consensus below seemed to be that "river crossings" is not very useful because not all bridges and tunnels actually cross rivers. - Aranel ("Sarah") 23:57, 6 Feb 2005 (UTC)
These should be merged, but Category:London River Crossings is confusing. I recommend Category:Bridges and tunnels in London, kicking the lone ferry to Category:Transport in London, and making the merged category also a child thereof. (Thanks to Willmcw who noticed this issue slipping through the cracks.) -- Beland 05:38, 11 Mar 2005 (UTC)