The result was delete. Wizardman 02:33, 20 August 2008 (UTC) reply
Unnotable, unpublished book that fails WP:BK. Failed PROD with prod removed by article creator stating "Although book was unpublished, due to popularity & interest in Judy Bolton series, article explains book that would have been printed, & gives plot as explained by late author w/ link to interview." - a single interview where the unpublished book is mentioned briefly does not give it notability nor is notability inherited from the series, presuming there is any as the main series article is basically a stub with no references at all. -- Collectonian ( talk · contribs) 01:28, 15 August 2008 (UTC) reply
Keep I am the original author of this page, and stand by it as being substantiated. There was a book by the same name published in 1929. There was also a proposed book of the same name that was * intended to be completed in 1968 by Margaret Sutton, in a very popular series of books started in 1933. Rather than put all this information in the main Judy Bolton article, I feel it is better suited for an individual page regarding the specific title, as it is a special case and may clutter up the main page. There is a source, which is more than substantial for the information contained in the article. And to assume that the series has no notability as above person claims, shows arrogance and ignorance. The series was popular from 1933 till it ended in 1967. Series' don't live that long if they aren't "notable". TrentJerome ( talk) 02:13, 15 August 2008 (UTC) reply
The result was delete. Wizardman 02:33, 20 August 2008 (UTC) reply
Unnotable, unpublished book that fails WP:BK. Failed PROD with prod removed by article creator stating "Although book was unpublished, due to popularity & interest in Judy Bolton series, article explains book that would have been printed, & gives plot as explained by late author w/ link to interview." - a single interview where the unpublished book is mentioned briefly does not give it notability nor is notability inherited from the series, presuming there is any as the main series article is basically a stub with no references at all. -- Collectonian ( talk · contribs) 01:28, 15 August 2008 (UTC) reply
Keep I am the original author of this page, and stand by it as being substantiated. There was a book by the same name published in 1929. There was also a proposed book of the same name that was * intended to be completed in 1968 by Margaret Sutton, in a very popular series of books started in 1933. Rather than put all this information in the main Judy Bolton article, I feel it is better suited for an individual page regarding the specific title, as it is a special case and may clutter up the main page. There is a source, which is more than substantial for the information contained in the article. And to assume that the series has no notability as above person claims, shows arrogance and ignorance. The series was popular from 1933 till it ended in 1967. Series' don't live that long if they aren't "notable". TrentJerome ( talk) 02:13, 15 August 2008 (UTC) reply