The result was The result was merge and redirect to Brandeis University. I'm also closing the similar AfD on "The Hoot" with the same result and redirecting The Blowfish and The Louis Lunatic on the same reasoning. — Doug Bell talk 20:31, 14 December 2006 (UTC) reply
I placed a redirect from this namespace to Judge per WP:BOLD and per consensus that student journals (with few exceptions) are not notable. I have been challenged on the lack of transparency of my act by User:EarthPerson, and am bringing this here to AfD per his/her request. My contention is that while this journal may be known and well established within Brandeis University, it remains a non-notable student journal as far as the world at large is concerned per plenty of consensus here; sister Brandeis journal The Hoot appears to be headed that way too. I do not believe the university itself has any real claims on the word "Justice", which is universally synonymous with judges. If I named my organisation's journal The George W. Bush, that act in itself would not make my paper notable. Nor, assuming said article existed, would I be justified in claiming a redirect to the page of my organisation upon its deletion. Delete Ohconfucius 01:26, 13 December 2006 (UTC) reply
The result was The result was merge and redirect to Brandeis University. I'm also closing the similar AfD on "The Hoot" with the same result and redirecting The Blowfish and The Louis Lunatic on the same reasoning. — Doug Bell talk 20:31, 14 December 2006 (UTC) reply
I placed a redirect from this namespace to Judge per WP:BOLD and per consensus that student journals (with few exceptions) are not notable. I have been challenged on the lack of transparency of my act by User:EarthPerson, and am bringing this here to AfD per his/her request. My contention is that while this journal may be known and well established within Brandeis University, it remains a non-notable student journal as far as the world at large is concerned per plenty of consensus here; sister Brandeis journal The Hoot appears to be headed that way too. I do not believe the university itself has any real claims on the word "Justice", which is universally synonymous with judges. If I named my organisation's journal The George W. Bush, that act in itself would not make my paper notable. Nor, assuming said article existed, would I be justified in claiming a redirect to the page of my organisation upon its deletion. Delete Ohconfucius 01:26, 13 December 2006 (UTC) reply