The result was keep. Ah, after a second thought, it's better to close this and continue discussion elsewhere... Tone 22:53, 6 December 2009 (UTC) reply
![]() | Please remember to always assume good faith when participating in this discussion. This applies to both those arguing to keep the article and those who are arguing to delete the article. Discuss the reasons why you belive the article should be deleted/kept, with particular attention to relevant Wikipedia policies. Arguments based on assuming bad faith on behalf of those that do not support your argument will not be tolerated. |
This article fails WP:WEB. There are no awards and the last ref is a blog post. The first two refs are " (3) a brief summary of the nature of the content or the publication of Internet addresses and site or " which is an exception to #1 for notability of WP:WEB because it does not provide an independant review but rather a summary. The refs also do not support the sentences they are inline with. Even the 2 year old Hebrew version of the page cites the actual website and the company that owns it. There arn't even independant refs there. TParis00ap ( talk) 20:57, 28 November 2009 (UTC) reply
It was already proven that there are references supporting the importance of the website reported in article for people who like Hebrew lyrics. So actually, if we keep on this discussion, we discuss the notability of all the articles dealing with Israeli culture.
I am not trying to tease anyone. Let’s really discuss whether a large encyclopedia, written in the international language should have articles about the culture of a state that in many other aspects is important. Should we write here only about subjects related to Israel that have a chance to help anyone, all over the world to design posters for demonstration, to plan a holiday in the Mediterranean, and to check linguistic issues in holy scripts? Or should we try to write things that that are important to those who want to know about other cultures just out of curiosity? What kind of subjects should be covered in an encyclopedia on a language that maximum 13 million out of the 7 billion people on earth speak, but should not be mentioned, even in short, on an international encyclopedia?
And how objective is it to write so many articles about some subjects related to the Middle East and delete all other articles related to it? Will it make Wikipedia a tourist souvenir shop like website? Eddau ( talk) 00:54, 6 December 2009 (UTC) reply
The result was keep. Ah, after a second thought, it's better to close this and continue discussion elsewhere... Tone 22:53, 6 December 2009 (UTC) reply
![]() | Please remember to always assume good faith when participating in this discussion. This applies to both those arguing to keep the article and those who are arguing to delete the article. Discuss the reasons why you belive the article should be deleted/kept, with particular attention to relevant Wikipedia policies. Arguments based on assuming bad faith on behalf of those that do not support your argument will not be tolerated. |
This article fails WP:WEB. There are no awards and the last ref is a blog post. The first two refs are " (3) a brief summary of the nature of the content or the publication of Internet addresses and site or " which is an exception to #1 for notability of WP:WEB because it does not provide an independant review but rather a summary. The refs also do not support the sentences they are inline with. Even the 2 year old Hebrew version of the page cites the actual website and the company that owns it. There arn't even independant refs there. TParis00ap ( talk) 20:57, 28 November 2009 (UTC) reply
It was already proven that there are references supporting the importance of the website reported in article for people who like Hebrew lyrics. So actually, if we keep on this discussion, we discuss the notability of all the articles dealing with Israeli culture.
I am not trying to tease anyone. Let’s really discuss whether a large encyclopedia, written in the international language should have articles about the culture of a state that in many other aspects is important. Should we write here only about subjects related to Israel that have a chance to help anyone, all over the world to design posters for demonstration, to plan a holiday in the Mediterranean, and to check linguistic issues in holy scripts? Or should we try to write things that that are important to those who want to know about other cultures just out of curiosity? What kind of subjects should be covered in an encyclopedia on a language that maximum 13 million out of the 7 billion people on earth speak, but should not be mentioned, even in short, on an international encyclopedia?
And how objective is it to write so many articles about some subjects related to the Middle East and delete all other articles related to it? Will it make Wikipedia a tourist souvenir shop like website? Eddau ( talk) 00:54, 6 December 2009 (UTC) reply