The result was keep. Nom was withdrawn several days ago, but not SK-eligible due to other deletion arg. ( non-admin closure) czar · · 05:48, 12 August 2013 (UTC) reply
This article's tone requires cleanup for one thing, and though it is a sourced BLP, the reference given does not even mention his name ( WP:V) For the source listed there is a link to a "full list" which also does not mention his name. CSD withdrawn by me per reasonable article creator's request. Per WP:BEFORE, I tried to fix it, but Google News or Google Books failed to reveal any significant coverage therefore failing #3 of WP:PORNBIO and WP:SIGCOV. He obviously exists, as Google reveals numerous results coming up for him regarding his works, but nothing that can be cited (they are all sites to watch porn). According to 29th AVN Awards and 30th AVN Awards he has been nominated for four awards, but one is a scene award, therefore failing #1 of the pornbio guideline (he has to win an award, or be nominated for several - three is not several). The nominations in those articles are also not sourced. He also does not appear to satisfy #2 of pornbio, no information could be found regarding his influences/unique contributions. — kikichugirl inquire 21:58, 4 August 2013 (UTC) reply
Withdrawing nomination per arguments below and WP:SNOW. All issues addressed in my nom have been fixed enough for me, even if some improvement to the article would be nice. If this article were to just now be submitted and be seen by me as a NPP, then I wouldn't nominate it for deletion, so it is only reasonable that I withdraw now. — kikichugirl inquire 21:39, 6 August 2013 (UTC) reply
The result was keep. Nom was withdrawn several days ago, but not SK-eligible due to other deletion arg. ( non-admin closure) czar · · 05:48, 12 August 2013 (UTC) reply
This article's tone requires cleanup for one thing, and though it is a sourced BLP, the reference given does not even mention his name ( WP:V) For the source listed there is a link to a "full list" which also does not mention his name. CSD withdrawn by me per reasonable article creator's request. Per WP:BEFORE, I tried to fix it, but Google News or Google Books failed to reveal any significant coverage therefore failing #3 of WP:PORNBIO and WP:SIGCOV. He obviously exists, as Google reveals numerous results coming up for him regarding his works, but nothing that can be cited (they are all sites to watch porn). According to 29th AVN Awards and 30th AVN Awards he has been nominated for four awards, but one is a scene award, therefore failing #1 of the pornbio guideline (he has to win an award, or be nominated for several - three is not several). The nominations in those articles are also not sourced. He also does not appear to satisfy #2 of pornbio, no information could be found regarding his influences/unique contributions. — kikichugirl inquire 21:58, 4 August 2013 (UTC) reply
Withdrawing nomination per arguments below and WP:SNOW. All issues addressed in my nom have been fixed enough for me, even if some improvement to the article would be nice. If this article were to just now be submitted and be seen by me as a NPP, then I wouldn't nominate it for deletion, so it is only reasonable that I withdraw now. — kikichugirl inquire 21:39, 6 August 2013 (UTC) reply