The result was keep with consideration to be given to a merge. There was no support for these articles to be deleted. I shall set up a merge discussion so that it can be considered as a post-AfD editorial matter. TerriersFan 17:30, 21 August 2007 (UTC) reply
Trivial songs. Discussions are currently in place on
WP:MUS as to the criteria for a song's notability - neither this, nor any of the other Marvin songs meets even the most generous of the proposed criteria
[1].
Delete.
SilkTork
08:55, 14 August 2007 (UTC)
I am also nominating the following related pages:
reply
SilkTork 09:10, 14 August 2007 (UTC) reply
Keep (statement of interest: I created the article) - but even so it satisfies WP:MUS for songs on point 2 ("has been ranked on a national or significant music chart), as stated in the article, it enteredthe British charts, and probably point 3 ("has been recognized...as being significant to a noteworthy group's repertoire."), if we stretch the case so that the noteworthy people are Douglas Adams, who wrote it, and Stephen Moore, who sang it - for each it was their biggest success in music. As the new criteria for inclusion are only proposed (and where is this discussion anyway?), I think the nomination is premature - let's see what the outcome of the debate is, and re-nominate then if necessary. Totnesmartin 18:21, 14 August 2007 (UTC) reply
Keep The Mole: I consider these songs as part of the BBC's masterpiece, The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy on DVD and audio CD. Be foolish to delete them, "...but I can tell you weren't really interested!". If anything, I agree to move them here: Marvin the Paranoid Android.
Marvin, I love you! :)
Keep or Merge - The information on this page is far more important to me (and many other scifi fans) than, say, Winston Chruchills birthday or other such utter-trivia. Fictional or otherwise, Marvin The Paranoid Android (ne Stephen Moore) is an institution and his real-world achievements deserve publicly documented recognition. Whether here or at Marvin the Paranoid Android CS BlueChip 21:53, 15 August 2007 (UTC) reply
The result was keep with consideration to be given to a merge. There was no support for these articles to be deleted. I shall set up a merge discussion so that it can be considered as a post-AfD editorial matter. TerriersFan 17:30, 21 August 2007 (UTC) reply
Trivial songs. Discussions are currently in place on
WP:MUS as to the criteria for a song's notability - neither this, nor any of the other Marvin songs meets even the most generous of the proposed criteria
[1].
Delete.
SilkTork
08:55, 14 August 2007 (UTC)
I am also nominating the following related pages:
reply
SilkTork 09:10, 14 August 2007 (UTC) reply
Keep (statement of interest: I created the article) - but even so it satisfies WP:MUS for songs on point 2 ("has been ranked on a national or significant music chart), as stated in the article, it enteredthe British charts, and probably point 3 ("has been recognized...as being significant to a noteworthy group's repertoire."), if we stretch the case so that the noteworthy people are Douglas Adams, who wrote it, and Stephen Moore, who sang it - for each it was their biggest success in music. As the new criteria for inclusion are only proposed (and where is this discussion anyway?), I think the nomination is premature - let's see what the outcome of the debate is, and re-nominate then if necessary. Totnesmartin 18:21, 14 August 2007 (UTC) reply
Keep The Mole: I consider these songs as part of the BBC's masterpiece, The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy on DVD and audio CD. Be foolish to delete them, "...but I can tell you weren't really interested!". If anything, I agree to move them here: Marvin the Paranoid Android.
Marvin, I love you! :)
Keep or Merge - The information on this page is far more important to me (and many other scifi fans) than, say, Winston Chruchills birthday or other such utter-trivia. Fictional or otherwise, Marvin The Paranoid Android (ne Stephen Moore) is an institution and his real-world achievements deserve publicly documented recognition. Whether here or at Marvin the Paranoid Android CS BlueChip 21:53, 15 August 2007 (UTC) reply