The result was keep. W.marsh 18:50, 11 November 2007 (UTC) reply
There are plenty of reviews of the 2007 film Control (2007 film) that include a sentence or two on Martin Ruhe's good cinematography work on that movie. However, the collective of the references mentioning Ruhe do not provide enough biographical information on Martin Ruhe to create a Wikipedia biographical article. If Ruhe were "notable" as a biographic topic, reliable sources would have covered his life in more detail. A Wikipedia article is not an award to be won through cinematography accomplishments and there seem to be no reason to provide an exception for Martin Ruhe. Until there is more reliable sourced biographical information, the Martin Ruhe article should be deleted. Please review and discuss the reliable source material, including the material on Ruhe contained in the following: (1) The Times May 18, 2007, (2) Irish Times October 5, 2007, (3) The Guardian October 5, 2007; (4) Independent on Sunday October 7, 2007; (5) New York Daily News October 9, 2007; (6) The Village Voice October 10, 2007; (7) Canadian Press October 12, 2007; (8) Toronto Star October 26, 2007; (9) Toronto Star October 26, 2007. -- Jreferee t/ c 16:54, 27 October 2007 (UTC) reply
The result was keep. W.marsh 18:50, 11 November 2007 (UTC) reply
There are plenty of reviews of the 2007 film Control (2007 film) that include a sentence or two on Martin Ruhe's good cinematography work on that movie. However, the collective of the references mentioning Ruhe do not provide enough biographical information on Martin Ruhe to create a Wikipedia biographical article. If Ruhe were "notable" as a biographic topic, reliable sources would have covered his life in more detail. A Wikipedia article is not an award to be won through cinematography accomplishments and there seem to be no reason to provide an exception for Martin Ruhe. Until there is more reliable sourced biographical information, the Martin Ruhe article should be deleted. Please review and discuss the reliable source material, including the material on Ruhe contained in the following: (1) The Times May 18, 2007, (2) Irish Times October 5, 2007, (3) The Guardian October 5, 2007; (4) Independent on Sunday October 7, 2007; (5) New York Daily News October 9, 2007; (6) The Village Voice October 10, 2007; (7) Canadian Press October 12, 2007; (8) Toronto Star October 26, 2007; (9) Toronto Star October 26, 2007. -- Jreferee t/ c 16:54, 27 October 2007 (UTC) reply