The result was: There is a clear consensus to categorise and delete here - but how exactly to close this AfD is a bit vexing. It's not clear that the categorisation is complete. Basically, I see two options:
I'm going with 2, especially given that no-one's objected to Dr Zak's assertion "delete, categories exist" below, despite this AfD hanging around for several extra days. -- Sam Blanning (talk) 09:01, 17 July 2006 (UTC) reply
Note: This AfD will take a while to close, and I may be interrupted before finishing - if you notice any of these lists or links to them still hanging around, please do not contact me to say "hey, you didn't delete x" until tomorrow (Tuesday 18th July). -- Sam Blanning (talk) 09:06, 17 July 2006 (UTC) reply
This list and the sublists linked from it were originally deleted after their first AfD. However, due to the absence of AfD tags on all the sublists during the course of AfD 1, a deletion review has found it necessary to undelete and relist all deleted pages.
Pages nominated for deletion are: List of bands from California, List of United States musicians, List of Alabama musicians, List of Alaska musicians, List of California musicians, List of Delaware musicians, List of Connecticut musicians, List of Florida musicians, List of Idaho musicians, List of Illinois musicians, List of Iowa musicians, List of Louisiana musicians, List of Maryland musicians, List of Massachusetts musicians, List of Michigan musicians, List of Missouri musicians, List of Nevada musicians, List of New Jersey musicians, List of New Mexico musicians, List of New York musicians, List of Pennsylvania musicians, List of Washington musicians, List of Wisconsin musicians, List of bands from Alaska, List of bands from Arizona, List of bands from Arkansas, List of bands from Connecticut, List of bands from Colorado, List of bands from Florida, List of bands from Georgia, List of bands from Hawaii, List of bands from Idaho, List of bands from Iowa, List of bands from Indiana, List of bands from Kansas, List of bands from Illinois, List of bands from Kentucky, List of bands from Louisiana, List of bands from Maryland, List of bands from Massachusetts, List of bands from Maine, List of bands from Michigan, List of bands from Minnesota, List of bands from Missouri, List of bands from Mississippi, List of bands from Montana, List of bands from Nebraska, List of bands from Nevada, List of bands from New Hampshire, List of bands from New Jersey, List of bands from New Mexico, List of bands from New York, List of bands from North Carolina, List of bands from North Dakota, List of bands from Ohio, List of bands from Oklahoma, List of bands from Oregon, List of bands from Pennsylvania, List of bands from Rhode Island, List of bands from South Carolina, List of bands from South Dakota, List of bands from Tennessee, List of bands from Utah, List of bands from Vermont, List of bands from Texas, List of bands from Virginia, List of bands from West Virginia, List of bands from Wisconsin, List of bands from Wyoming, List of bands from Washington, and List of Georgia musicians.
Procedural nomination. No opinion. The original nomination follows. -- Kimchi.sg 12:08, 9 July 2006 (UTC) reply
None of the musicians listed here are notable for being from the United States; many are not even notable. This is the beginning of an attempt to change all of these lists into categories. There are already categories for many of these lists: for example, there is a list of bands from California and a Category:California musicians. This is redundant and, since the categories are more appropriate, the lists should be deleted. -- Stellis 21:52, 20 June 2006 (UTC) reply
The result was: There is a clear consensus to categorise and delete here - but how exactly to close this AfD is a bit vexing. It's not clear that the categorisation is complete. Basically, I see two options:
I'm going with 2, especially given that no-one's objected to Dr Zak's assertion "delete, categories exist" below, despite this AfD hanging around for several extra days. -- Sam Blanning (talk) 09:01, 17 July 2006 (UTC) reply
Note: This AfD will take a while to close, and I may be interrupted before finishing - if you notice any of these lists or links to them still hanging around, please do not contact me to say "hey, you didn't delete x" until tomorrow (Tuesday 18th July). -- Sam Blanning (talk) 09:06, 17 July 2006 (UTC) reply
This list and the sublists linked from it were originally deleted after their first AfD. However, due to the absence of AfD tags on all the sublists during the course of AfD 1, a deletion review has found it necessary to undelete and relist all deleted pages.
Pages nominated for deletion are: List of bands from California, List of United States musicians, List of Alabama musicians, List of Alaska musicians, List of California musicians, List of Delaware musicians, List of Connecticut musicians, List of Florida musicians, List of Idaho musicians, List of Illinois musicians, List of Iowa musicians, List of Louisiana musicians, List of Maryland musicians, List of Massachusetts musicians, List of Michigan musicians, List of Missouri musicians, List of Nevada musicians, List of New Jersey musicians, List of New Mexico musicians, List of New York musicians, List of Pennsylvania musicians, List of Washington musicians, List of Wisconsin musicians, List of bands from Alaska, List of bands from Arizona, List of bands from Arkansas, List of bands from Connecticut, List of bands from Colorado, List of bands from Florida, List of bands from Georgia, List of bands from Hawaii, List of bands from Idaho, List of bands from Iowa, List of bands from Indiana, List of bands from Kansas, List of bands from Illinois, List of bands from Kentucky, List of bands from Louisiana, List of bands from Maryland, List of bands from Massachusetts, List of bands from Maine, List of bands from Michigan, List of bands from Minnesota, List of bands from Missouri, List of bands from Mississippi, List of bands from Montana, List of bands from Nebraska, List of bands from Nevada, List of bands from New Hampshire, List of bands from New Jersey, List of bands from New Mexico, List of bands from New York, List of bands from North Carolina, List of bands from North Dakota, List of bands from Ohio, List of bands from Oklahoma, List of bands from Oregon, List of bands from Pennsylvania, List of bands from Rhode Island, List of bands from South Carolina, List of bands from South Dakota, List of bands from Tennessee, List of bands from Utah, List of bands from Vermont, List of bands from Texas, List of bands from Virginia, List of bands from West Virginia, List of bands from Wisconsin, List of bands from Wyoming, List of bands from Washington, and List of Georgia musicians.
Procedural nomination. No opinion. The original nomination follows. -- Kimchi.sg 12:08, 9 July 2006 (UTC) reply
None of the musicians listed here are notable for being from the United States; many are not even notable. This is the beginning of an attempt to change all of these lists into categories. There are already categories for many of these lists: for example, there is a list of bands from California and a Category:California musicians. This is redundant and, since the categories are more appropriate, the lists should be deleted. -- Stellis 21:52, 20 June 2006 (UTC) reply