The result of the debate was delete. (75% delete from 30 votes, and 10 keep votes). - Mailer Diablo 01:50, 19 November 2005 (UTC) reply
non-encyclopedic listcruft with little hope of ever becoming comprehensive or maintanable → Ξxtreme Unction { yakł blah} 12:37, 13 November 2005 (UTC) reply
Just proving my point, someone (Arniep) nominated a whole "list of" Jewish. Not surprisingly, the "List of Jewish Criminals" is going down in flames, while most of the rest are "speedy keep." In fact, one person who voted against "List of Jewish Bankers" voted FOR some of the other lists. This merely proves my point that reactionary politically-correct bias is operating here...I'm sure a court of law would find that since these lists were created by the same user, who has shown an intent not of anti-Semitism but Jewish identity (being Jewish), taken as a whole the lists should be equal. Remember, DISCRIMINATION is picking out one thing and applying different standards. Ryoung122 09:36, 18 November 2005 (UTC) reply
List of Jewish American academics
List of Jewish American business figures
List of Jewish American political figures
List of Jewish American scientists
List of Jewish American show business figures
List of Jewish American sport figures
List of Jewish American writers
List of Jewish Americans
List of Jewish Fellows of the Royal Society
List of Jewish Members of the National Academy of Engineering
List of Jewish Recipients of National Medal of Technology
List of Jewish bankers
List of Jewish criminals
List of Jewish publishers
List of Jews
List of Jews in business
List of Jews in law
The result of the debate was delete. (75% delete from 30 votes, and 10 keep votes). - Mailer Diablo 01:50, 19 November 2005 (UTC) reply
non-encyclopedic listcruft with little hope of ever becoming comprehensive or maintanable → Ξxtreme Unction { yakł blah} 12:37, 13 November 2005 (UTC) reply
Just proving my point, someone (Arniep) nominated a whole "list of" Jewish. Not surprisingly, the "List of Jewish Criminals" is going down in flames, while most of the rest are "speedy keep." In fact, one person who voted against "List of Jewish Bankers" voted FOR some of the other lists. This merely proves my point that reactionary politically-correct bias is operating here...I'm sure a court of law would find that since these lists were created by the same user, who has shown an intent not of anti-Semitism but Jewish identity (being Jewish), taken as a whole the lists should be equal. Remember, DISCRIMINATION is picking out one thing and applying different standards. Ryoung122 09:36, 18 November 2005 (UTC) reply
List of Jewish American academics
List of Jewish American business figures
List of Jewish American political figures
List of Jewish American scientists
List of Jewish American show business figures
List of Jewish American sport figures
List of Jewish American writers
List of Jewish Americans
List of Jewish Fellows of the Royal Society
List of Jewish Members of the National Academy of Engineering
List of Jewish Recipients of National Medal of Technology
List of Jewish bankers
List of Jewish criminals
List of Jewish publishers
List of Jews
List of Jews in business
List of Jews in law