The result was keep. Following a relist for consensus 5 days ago, the main contribution has been a source assessment table. The arguments for keep cite the article meeting GNG, which the source table demonstrates. No other contributors have offered a rebuttal, and so this table adds weight to keep arguments over delete. Overall, a clear keep consensus. (non-admin closure) MaxnaCarter ( talk) 06:41, 1 June 2022 (UTC)
[Hide this box] New to Articles for deletion (AfD)? Read these primers!
WP:BLP1E case. Hence, calling for an AfD discussion. - Hatchens ( talk) 08:56, 18 May 2022 (UTC)
Relisted to generate a more thorough discussion and clearer consensus.
Please add new comments below this notice. Thanks,
Less Unless (
talk)
14:06, 26 May 2022 (UTC)
Source assessment table:
| ||||
Source | Independent? | Reliable? | Significant coverage? | Count source toward GNG? |
---|---|---|---|---|
The mystery behind why Bengaluru is covered in stickers of ‘angry Hanuman’ ( Scroll.in, 2017) | Much more than an interview, includes substantial independent content, as well as commentary from Philip Lutgendorf, Professor of Hindi and Modern Indian Studies, Girish Kumar, a taxi-driver, and Srinath, a shopkeeper who sells stickers. | Per
WP:CREATIVE#3, the work is the primary subject of this article, and is well-known, e.g. "The image, vector-style, is everywhere in Bengaluru and in several other parts of Karnataka." |
✔ Yes | |
Karan Acharya, the man behind the viral Hanuman vector, wants to copyright the image ( Hindustan Times, 2018) | More than an interview, includes substantial independent content about Acharya, the sticker, and an upcoming comic book. | Per
WP:CREATIVE#3, the work is the primary subject of this article, and is well-known, e.g. the image is "raging across the Capital, after turning into a nationwide phenomenon over the last couple of years." Also includes support for WP:BASIC notability with secondary content and context about Acharya and his career. |
✔ Yes | |
Meet Karan Acharya, the Bengaluru artist whose mythological images of common people are going viral (The Indian Express, 2020) | Much more than an interview, includes substantial independent content about Acharya and his career. | Per
WP:CREATIVE#3, the collective body of work is the primary subject of this article, and is well-known, e.g. "Karan Acharya, a graphic artist from Bengaluru, has become an internet sensation after several of his digital artworks went viral on social media." The secondary content and context also supports WP:BASIC notability and demonstrates coverage for multiple events. |
✔ Yes | |
Meet Karan Acharya, the artist who was hailed by PM Modi in Mangaluru rally ( Daijiworld, 2018) | Mostly an interview, but includes independent content about career, biographical information, political reactions to the art. | value not understood Secondary content and context supports WP:BASIC notability. | ? Unknown | |
Will Shiva blues Trump Hanuman rage? ( The New Indian Express, 2017) | Includes independent content in addition to an interview | value not understood Per
WP:CREATIVE#3, the collective body of work is the primary subject of this article, and his work is well-known, e.g. "Today, almost every other vehicle, especially cabs and private vehicles, sport the half-faced orange and black coloured Hanuman stickers." Also covers more than one event, e.g. "The man behind it — artiste Karan Acharya — is now back with a blue coloured Adi Yogi Shiva sticker [...] He has designed stickers for Jallikattu and Kambala as well." Secondary content and context supports WP:BASIC notability. |
? Unknown | |
Stoic Rama after Angry Hanuman: Artist Karan Acharya reveals what he plans next ( The Financial Express, 2018) | More than an interview, includes independent content about new art, the Hanuman t-shirt, his company, Paridhi Media Works, the copyright, and popularity of the Hanuman image. | value not understood Per
WP:CREATIVE#3, the collective body of work is the primary subject of this article, and his work is well-known, e.g. "Karan’s ‘angry Hanuman’ has become so popular that even Prime Minister Narendra Modi underscored it in an election rally". Also covers more than one event by focusing on multiple works of art and future plans. Secondary content and context supports WP:BASIC notability. |
? Unknown | |
‘Pride of Mangaluru’: PM Modi lauds artist who created viral angry Hanuman image ( The News Minute, 2018) | Includes a focus on debate/criticism of the image, as well as praise from PM Modi | Per
WP:CREATIVE#3, the work is the primary subject of this article, and is well-known, e.g. "It has been less than three years since the image was created and it has become a rage in many parts of the country including Bengaluru and New Delhi, where the image appears on the windshields of vehicles and on smartphone covers." |
✔ Yes | |
Man behind super viral Lord Hanuman poster, now comes up with PM Narendra Modi’s painting, ( The Financial Express, 2018) | Per
WP:CREATIVE#3, the collective body of work is the primary subject of this article, and his work is well-known, e.g. describing him as "probably one of the most popular graphic artists in India". Secondary content and context about reactions to his art, career, and new work supports WP:BASIC notability, and helps demonstrate coverage for more than one event. |
✔ Yes | ||
Vinay Bharadwaj to create first impression with Mundina Nildana poster ( The New Indian Express, 2019) | value not understood An announcement of a new work, demonstrating coverage of more than one event. | ? Unknown | ||
This table may not be a final or consensus view; it may summarize developing consensus, or reflect assessments of a single editor. Created using {{ source assess table}}. |
The result was keep. Following a relist for consensus 5 days ago, the main contribution has been a source assessment table. The arguments for keep cite the article meeting GNG, which the source table demonstrates. No other contributors have offered a rebuttal, and so this table adds weight to keep arguments over delete. Overall, a clear keep consensus. (non-admin closure) MaxnaCarter ( talk) 06:41, 1 June 2022 (UTC)
[Hide this box] New to Articles for deletion (AfD)? Read these primers!
WP:BLP1E case. Hence, calling for an AfD discussion. - Hatchens ( talk) 08:56, 18 May 2022 (UTC)
Relisted to generate a more thorough discussion and clearer consensus.
Please add new comments below this notice. Thanks,
Less Unless (
talk)
14:06, 26 May 2022 (UTC)
Source assessment table:
| ||||
Source | Independent? | Reliable? | Significant coverage? | Count source toward GNG? |
---|---|---|---|---|
The mystery behind why Bengaluru is covered in stickers of ‘angry Hanuman’ ( Scroll.in, 2017) | Much more than an interview, includes substantial independent content, as well as commentary from Philip Lutgendorf, Professor of Hindi and Modern Indian Studies, Girish Kumar, a taxi-driver, and Srinath, a shopkeeper who sells stickers. | Per
WP:CREATIVE#3, the work is the primary subject of this article, and is well-known, e.g. "The image, vector-style, is everywhere in Bengaluru and in several other parts of Karnataka." |
✔ Yes | |
Karan Acharya, the man behind the viral Hanuman vector, wants to copyright the image ( Hindustan Times, 2018) | More than an interview, includes substantial independent content about Acharya, the sticker, and an upcoming comic book. | Per
WP:CREATIVE#3, the work is the primary subject of this article, and is well-known, e.g. the image is "raging across the Capital, after turning into a nationwide phenomenon over the last couple of years." Also includes support for WP:BASIC notability with secondary content and context about Acharya and his career. |
✔ Yes | |
Meet Karan Acharya, the Bengaluru artist whose mythological images of common people are going viral (The Indian Express, 2020) | Much more than an interview, includes substantial independent content about Acharya and his career. | Per
WP:CREATIVE#3, the collective body of work is the primary subject of this article, and is well-known, e.g. "Karan Acharya, a graphic artist from Bengaluru, has become an internet sensation after several of his digital artworks went viral on social media." The secondary content and context also supports WP:BASIC notability and demonstrates coverage for multiple events. |
✔ Yes | |
Meet Karan Acharya, the artist who was hailed by PM Modi in Mangaluru rally ( Daijiworld, 2018) | Mostly an interview, but includes independent content about career, biographical information, political reactions to the art. | value not understood Secondary content and context supports WP:BASIC notability. | ? Unknown | |
Will Shiva blues Trump Hanuman rage? ( The New Indian Express, 2017) | Includes independent content in addition to an interview | value not understood Per
WP:CREATIVE#3, the collective body of work is the primary subject of this article, and his work is well-known, e.g. "Today, almost every other vehicle, especially cabs and private vehicles, sport the half-faced orange and black coloured Hanuman stickers." Also covers more than one event, e.g. "The man behind it — artiste Karan Acharya — is now back with a blue coloured Adi Yogi Shiva sticker [...] He has designed stickers for Jallikattu and Kambala as well." Secondary content and context supports WP:BASIC notability. |
? Unknown | |
Stoic Rama after Angry Hanuman: Artist Karan Acharya reveals what he plans next ( The Financial Express, 2018) | More than an interview, includes independent content about new art, the Hanuman t-shirt, his company, Paridhi Media Works, the copyright, and popularity of the Hanuman image. | value not understood Per
WP:CREATIVE#3, the collective body of work is the primary subject of this article, and his work is well-known, e.g. "Karan’s ‘angry Hanuman’ has become so popular that even Prime Minister Narendra Modi underscored it in an election rally". Also covers more than one event by focusing on multiple works of art and future plans. Secondary content and context supports WP:BASIC notability. |
? Unknown | |
‘Pride of Mangaluru’: PM Modi lauds artist who created viral angry Hanuman image ( The News Minute, 2018) | Includes a focus on debate/criticism of the image, as well as praise from PM Modi | Per
WP:CREATIVE#3, the work is the primary subject of this article, and is well-known, e.g. "It has been less than three years since the image was created and it has become a rage in many parts of the country including Bengaluru and New Delhi, where the image appears on the windshields of vehicles and on smartphone covers." |
✔ Yes | |
Man behind super viral Lord Hanuman poster, now comes up with PM Narendra Modi’s painting, ( The Financial Express, 2018) | Per
WP:CREATIVE#3, the collective body of work is the primary subject of this article, and his work is well-known, e.g. describing him as "probably one of the most popular graphic artists in India". Secondary content and context about reactions to his art, career, and new work supports WP:BASIC notability, and helps demonstrate coverage for more than one event. |
✔ Yes | ||
Vinay Bharadwaj to create first impression with Mundina Nildana poster ( The New Indian Express, 2019) | value not understood An announcement of a new work, demonstrating coverage of more than one event. | ? Unknown | ||
This table may not be a final or consensus view; it may summarize developing consensus, or reflect assessments of a single editor. Created using {{ source assess table}}. |