The result was delete. So Why 08:05, 20 June 2017 (UTC)
This is a concept promoted by Sharda Nandram, Wim Keizer (wife and husband), and Puneet Bindlish. It had previously been used in a book title by Kevin Cashman. Imho the concept isn't notable yet. Before this nomination was the nomination of an article on a book by the same creators, Understanding Integrative Intelligence (nominated in Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Understanding Integrative Intelligence). An article on Sharda Nandram is in the making. I propose removing Integrative Intelligence per WP:NEO and WP:Too soon. gidonb ( talk) 23:41, 4 June 2017 (UTC)
1. The three people Sharda et.al "authored" the book on the concept. It is indeed harsh and unfair in mentioning the word "...promoted...". (Please do not see everything as a sales pitch, but a humble contribution. There is still a difference between "Authoring" and "Promoting" in some countries). The authors come from a credible academic background with over 100+ publications in their research field in last 25 years<ref>{{cite web|url=https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=hi&q=nandram+sharda&btnG=&oq=Nandram}}</ref>, See: https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=hi&q=nandram+sharda&btnG=&oq=Nandram
2. This is not a "New Age" babble. Springer Nature has published the author(s) in a book where there is mention of this concept<ref>{{Cite book|url=http://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-319-52231-9_21|title=Managing VUCA Through Integrative Self-Management|last=Bindlish|first=Puneet K.|last2=Nandram|first2=Sharda S.|last3=Joshi|first3=Ankur|date=2017|publisher=Springer International Publishing|isbn=9783319522302|editor-last=Nandram|editor-first=Sharda S.|series=Management for Professionals|pages=321–330|language=en|doi=10.1007/978-3-319-52231-9_21|editor-last2=Bindlish|editor-first2=Puneet K.}}</ref>
Suggested way forward: Integrative Intelligence is an upcoming concept, a constructive discussion can happen over WP:Too soon. 178.84.59.83 ( talk) 11:08, 5 June 2017 (UTC)
The term "Integrative Intelligence" has been in use for last 10-15 years. Incidentally there was no wikipedia article on it. This article has just been started with latest major references (from two books - "Understanding Integrative Intelligence" and "Managing VUCA through Integrative Self Management". ). Now that the article has been started, its just the matter of time, that the references from past many years would be arranged here by other people too. Some references, which are yet to be incorporated:
1. https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=%22Integrative+Intelligence%22
2. http://www.hbs.edu/about/video.aspx?v=1_8ealyr2h
3. http://www.hbs.edu/news/releases/Pages/william-connell-donates-10million.aspx
Markivnivan ( talk) 11:36, 5 June 2017 (UTC)
Comment It looks very random to me. I'm going to reiterate what I implied in the intro. This is not a war on "integrative intelligence". I stand in this totally without prejudice. All I did is note that there is not yet (hence WP:NEO and WP:Too soon) an agreed concept of Integrative Intelligence. It is mentioned here and there, usually very differently. This does not make it into a encyclopedic concept. We mirror the scientific and media "markets" and DO NOT lead any of these, otherwise we engage in WP:OR and WP:Synthesis. Imho, for "integrative intelligence" to get in the general direction of encyclopedic we need one of the very different fields, where it has been mentioned, to include it as a concept with definition (versus an explanatory word combination using the meaning of each word separately) in an introductory textbook or scientific glossary with a major publisher. Two textbook definitions is safer but I do not see even one. This is not a high bar. To illustrate just how very problematic the current situation is, I have collected below 10 random sources that use "integrative intelligence". gidonb ( talk) 06:55, 11 June 2017 (UTC)
Source #1 Sky Above Clouds: Finding Our Way Through Creativity, Aging, and Illness
https://books.google.com/books?isbn=0199371415
Wendy L. Miller, Gene D. Cohen - 2016
"Integrative intelligence is the synthetic result of developmental intelligence—the awareness of going through a process of coming more and more into one's creative potential by using our resources, and by integrating the work it takes to move through the necessary developmental phases of inner and outer growth."
"For me, the art of synergistic relationships in integrative intelligence leads us to healing and to wholeness."
"This is integrative intelligence—a wisdom that honored the truth and vulnerability of her experience"
"We are our integrative intelligence."
Source #2 The Science of Money: How to Increase Your Income and Become Wealthy
https://books.google.com/books?isbn=1469066513
Brian Tracy - 2017
"It's called the law of integrative intelligence. All these pieces of intelligence start to integrate and form a pattern or a design or a template whereby you can see an opportunity to create or build wealth that you hadn't seen before."
Source #3 Musical processes, resources, and technologies - Page 187
https://books.google.com/books?id=TaoQAQAAMAAJ
Kay Kaufman Shelemay - 1990
"It is still a comparative rarity to come across a commercial recording of folk or ethnic music which is well-conceived as to subject matter, efficiently produced, technically satisfying, and accurately and thoroughly annotated, so that the consumer receives the impression of some kind of integrative intelligence at work."
Source #4 The Many Faces of Giftedness: Lifting the Masks - Page 121
https://books.google.com/books?isbn=0766800067
Alexinia Young Baldwin - 1999
"The data is broken into two distinct areas, Integrative Intelligence and Dispersive Intelligence. The first area, Integrative Intelligence, groups together subtests that have as their connection the "capacity to discern broad patterns and connections in visual or verbal information" (p. 45)."
"High scores on subtests included in Integrative Intelligence provide evidence that such students can think abstractly, see patterns, and make connections among ideas — all pieces of creative productivity" (p. 46).
Source #5 Universitas: The Social Restructuring of American Undergraduate Education
https://books.google.com/books?isbn=0275955842
Tom Boudreau - 1998
"As such, full-ground thinking is integrative intelligence. It provides the essential power of perspective, perception and linguistic understanding between the different parts, as well as between the parts and the whole."
Source #6 Psychology for Educators - Page 220
https://books.google.com/books?isbn=0170122123
Wilma Vialle, Pauline Lysaght, Irina Verenikina - 2005
"The central theme that permeates all these theories is that spirituality is an integrative intelligence. By this we mean that the idea of connectedness works on several levels: it involves connectedness to others, to nature, and to the wider cosmos, but it also involves connectedness within the individual, integrating mind, heart, body and soul."
Source #7 Intelligence Success and Failure: The Human Factor - Page 62
https://books.google.com/books?isbn=0199341753
Uri Bar-Joseph, Rose McDermott - 2017
"The RU was the main supplier of foreign political and military information not only to the army but also to the Politburo and to Stalin himself. It had an Information Department, that produced integrative intelligence documents and following the occupation of Poland and France it proved its value by producing excellent analyses of the German military performance in these operations. 42"
Source #8 Artificial General Intelligence - Page 119
https://books.google.com/books?isbn=3540686770
Ben Goertzel, Cassio Pennachin - 2007
"Our primary schema and predicate learning approach is to fix evolutionary programming's scaling problems using a number of integrative-intelligence-oriented tricks."
Source #9 Hope and the Future: An Introduction to the Concept of Cultural Maturity
https://books.google.com/books?isbn=0974715492
Charles Johnston - 2014
"Finally, and especially relevant to the concept of Cultural Maturity, the same more consciously integrative intelligence that we see in the “seasoning” stage of a creative act orders the unique developmental capacities—the wisdom—of a lifetime's second half."
Source #10 Intelligence Elsewhere: Spies and Espionage Outside the Anglosphere
https://books.google.com/books?isbn=1589019571
Philip H. J. Davies, Kristian C. Gustafson - 2013
"In Davies's view, the British definition of intelligence points toward an integrative intelligence culture that is prone to groupthink. The opposite American definition of intelligence would lead toward a disintegrative culture that is characterized by turf wars.44"
Comment So what is integrative intelligence? gidonb ( talk) 21:09, 11 June 2017 (UTC)
The result was delete. So Why 08:05, 20 June 2017 (UTC)
This is a concept promoted by Sharda Nandram, Wim Keizer (wife and husband), and Puneet Bindlish. It had previously been used in a book title by Kevin Cashman. Imho the concept isn't notable yet. Before this nomination was the nomination of an article on a book by the same creators, Understanding Integrative Intelligence (nominated in Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Understanding Integrative Intelligence). An article on Sharda Nandram is in the making. I propose removing Integrative Intelligence per WP:NEO and WP:Too soon. gidonb ( talk) 23:41, 4 June 2017 (UTC)
1. The three people Sharda et.al "authored" the book on the concept. It is indeed harsh and unfair in mentioning the word "...promoted...". (Please do not see everything as a sales pitch, but a humble contribution. There is still a difference between "Authoring" and "Promoting" in some countries). The authors come from a credible academic background with over 100+ publications in their research field in last 25 years<ref>{{cite web|url=https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=hi&q=nandram+sharda&btnG=&oq=Nandram}}</ref>, See: https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=hi&q=nandram+sharda&btnG=&oq=Nandram
2. This is not a "New Age" babble. Springer Nature has published the author(s) in a book where there is mention of this concept<ref>{{Cite book|url=http://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-319-52231-9_21|title=Managing VUCA Through Integrative Self-Management|last=Bindlish|first=Puneet K.|last2=Nandram|first2=Sharda S.|last3=Joshi|first3=Ankur|date=2017|publisher=Springer International Publishing|isbn=9783319522302|editor-last=Nandram|editor-first=Sharda S.|series=Management for Professionals|pages=321–330|language=en|doi=10.1007/978-3-319-52231-9_21|editor-last2=Bindlish|editor-first2=Puneet K.}}</ref>
Suggested way forward: Integrative Intelligence is an upcoming concept, a constructive discussion can happen over WP:Too soon. 178.84.59.83 ( talk) 11:08, 5 June 2017 (UTC)
The term "Integrative Intelligence" has been in use for last 10-15 years. Incidentally there was no wikipedia article on it. This article has just been started with latest major references (from two books - "Understanding Integrative Intelligence" and "Managing VUCA through Integrative Self Management". ). Now that the article has been started, its just the matter of time, that the references from past many years would be arranged here by other people too. Some references, which are yet to be incorporated:
1. https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=%22Integrative+Intelligence%22
2. http://www.hbs.edu/about/video.aspx?v=1_8ealyr2h
3. http://www.hbs.edu/news/releases/Pages/william-connell-donates-10million.aspx
Markivnivan ( talk) 11:36, 5 June 2017 (UTC)
Comment It looks very random to me. I'm going to reiterate what I implied in the intro. This is not a war on "integrative intelligence". I stand in this totally without prejudice. All I did is note that there is not yet (hence WP:NEO and WP:Too soon) an agreed concept of Integrative Intelligence. It is mentioned here and there, usually very differently. This does not make it into a encyclopedic concept. We mirror the scientific and media "markets" and DO NOT lead any of these, otherwise we engage in WP:OR and WP:Synthesis. Imho, for "integrative intelligence" to get in the general direction of encyclopedic we need one of the very different fields, where it has been mentioned, to include it as a concept with definition (versus an explanatory word combination using the meaning of each word separately) in an introductory textbook or scientific glossary with a major publisher. Two textbook definitions is safer but I do not see even one. This is not a high bar. To illustrate just how very problematic the current situation is, I have collected below 10 random sources that use "integrative intelligence". gidonb ( talk) 06:55, 11 June 2017 (UTC)
Source #1 Sky Above Clouds: Finding Our Way Through Creativity, Aging, and Illness
https://books.google.com/books?isbn=0199371415
Wendy L. Miller, Gene D. Cohen - 2016
"Integrative intelligence is the synthetic result of developmental intelligence—the awareness of going through a process of coming more and more into one's creative potential by using our resources, and by integrating the work it takes to move through the necessary developmental phases of inner and outer growth."
"For me, the art of synergistic relationships in integrative intelligence leads us to healing and to wholeness."
"This is integrative intelligence—a wisdom that honored the truth and vulnerability of her experience"
"We are our integrative intelligence."
Source #2 The Science of Money: How to Increase Your Income and Become Wealthy
https://books.google.com/books?isbn=1469066513
Brian Tracy - 2017
"It's called the law of integrative intelligence. All these pieces of intelligence start to integrate and form a pattern or a design or a template whereby you can see an opportunity to create or build wealth that you hadn't seen before."
Source #3 Musical processes, resources, and technologies - Page 187
https://books.google.com/books?id=TaoQAQAAMAAJ
Kay Kaufman Shelemay - 1990
"It is still a comparative rarity to come across a commercial recording of folk or ethnic music which is well-conceived as to subject matter, efficiently produced, technically satisfying, and accurately and thoroughly annotated, so that the consumer receives the impression of some kind of integrative intelligence at work."
Source #4 The Many Faces of Giftedness: Lifting the Masks - Page 121
https://books.google.com/books?isbn=0766800067
Alexinia Young Baldwin - 1999
"The data is broken into two distinct areas, Integrative Intelligence and Dispersive Intelligence. The first area, Integrative Intelligence, groups together subtests that have as their connection the "capacity to discern broad patterns and connections in visual or verbal information" (p. 45)."
"High scores on subtests included in Integrative Intelligence provide evidence that such students can think abstractly, see patterns, and make connections among ideas — all pieces of creative productivity" (p. 46).
Source #5 Universitas: The Social Restructuring of American Undergraduate Education
https://books.google.com/books?isbn=0275955842
Tom Boudreau - 1998
"As such, full-ground thinking is integrative intelligence. It provides the essential power of perspective, perception and linguistic understanding between the different parts, as well as between the parts and the whole."
Source #6 Psychology for Educators - Page 220
https://books.google.com/books?isbn=0170122123
Wilma Vialle, Pauline Lysaght, Irina Verenikina - 2005
"The central theme that permeates all these theories is that spirituality is an integrative intelligence. By this we mean that the idea of connectedness works on several levels: it involves connectedness to others, to nature, and to the wider cosmos, but it also involves connectedness within the individual, integrating mind, heart, body and soul."
Source #7 Intelligence Success and Failure: The Human Factor - Page 62
https://books.google.com/books?isbn=0199341753
Uri Bar-Joseph, Rose McDermott - 2017
"The RU was the main supplier of foreign political and military information not only to the army but also to the Politburo and to Stalin himself. It had an Information Department, that produced integrative intelligence documents and following the occupation of Poland and France it proved its value by producing excellent analyses of the German military performance in these operations. 42"
Source #8 Artificial General Intelligence - Page 119
https://books.google.com/books?isbn=3540686770
Ben Goertzel, Cassio Pennachin - 2007
"Our primary schema and predicate learning approach is to fix evolutionary programming's scaling problems using a number of integrative-intelligence-oriented tricks."
Source #9 Hope and the Future: An Introduction to the Concept of Cultural Maturity
https://books.google.com/books?isbn=0974715492
Charles Johnston - 2014
"Finally, and especially relevant to the concept of Cultural Maturity, the same more consciously integrative intelligence that we see in the “seasoning” stage of a creative act orders the unique developmental capacities—the wisdom—of a lifetime's second half."
Source #10 Intelligence Elsewhere: Spies and Espionage Outside the Anglosphere
https://books.google.com/books?isbn=1589019571
Philip H. J. Davies, Kristian C. Gustafson - 2013
"In Davies's view, the British definition of intelligence points toward an integrative intelligence culture that is prone to groupthink. The opposite American definition of intelligence would lead toward a disintegrative culture that is characterized by turf wars.44"
Comment So what is integrative intelligence? gidonb ( talk) 21:09, 11 June 2017 (UTC)