The result was keep. Consensus is strongly on the side of keeping. Aside from that, a batch nomination was inappropriate here. If anything, these articles should be judged individually. – Juliancolton | Talk 00:49, 24 July 2009 (UTC) reply
Also nominated:
These are all articles about plot elements and events from the Star Wars series. Wikipedia is not Wookieepedia; more specifically WP:NOT#PLOT prohibits articles for plot only descriptions of works of fiction. In addition, WP:WAF establishes that articles about topics in fictional universes must be independently notable, as established by reliable, independent sources. WP:INUNIVERSE outlines some of the problems keeping articles solely devoted to plot details. NB: Great Jedi Purge has been nominated before, but community standards have changed. The main rationale of keep voters was that it was relevant to multiple works within the fictional series, not that it was notable outside the fictional series. Savidan 01:42, 17 July 2009 (UTC) reply
The result was keep. Consensus is strongly on the side of keeping. Aside from that, a batch nomination was inappropriate here. If anything, these articles should be judged individually. – Juliancolton | Talk 00:49, 24 July 2009 (UTC) reply
Also nominated:
These are all articles about plot elements and events from the Star Wars series. Wikipedia is not Wookieepedia; more specifically WP:NOT#PLOT prohibits articles for plot only descriptions of works of fiction. In addition, WP:WAF establishes that articles about topics in fictional universes must be independently notable, as established by reliable, independent sources. WP:INUNIVERSE outlines some of the problems keeping articles solely devoted to plot details. NB: Great Jedi Purge has been nominated before, but community standards have changed. The main rationale of keep voters was that it was relevant to multiple works within the fictional series, not that it was notable outside the fictional series. Savidan 01:42, 17 July 2009 (UTC) reply