The result was merge to Cardiff. Mark Arsten ( talk) 16:02, 13 September 2013 (UTC) reply
There is no such geographical place as Cardiff North unambiguously defined by any reliable sources. This article seems to be an area based on an arbitrary line invented by the author of the article. True, there are/were political parliamentary constituencies, Cardiff North, Cardiff South, Cardiff South and Penarth and Cardiff West, but these are well defined and already have Wikipedia articles. I came across these invented areas after an editor began wikilinking them to the words "north", "south", "west" etc. in Cardiff articles. The image in is based on political allegiances (while the map in West, South and East seems to have been invented by a wiki editor). Subsequently I've noticed a discussion has taken place on Talk:Cardiff North (geographical area), including an opinion from a non-involved independent editor which makes it clear this seems to be WP:OR and innappropriate. Cardiff isn't Berlin or Jerusalem, with walls or defining internal borders - time for these invented and confused articles to go, in my view.
I am also nominating the following related pages because of similar reasons - these geographical areas are an invention and open to dispute:
Sionk ( talk) 22:22, 14 August 2013 (UTC) reply
The result was merge to Cardiff. Mark Arsten ( talk) 16:02, 13 September 2013 (UTC) reply
There is no such geographical place as Cardiff North unambiguously defined by any reliable sources. This article seems to be an area based on an arbitrary line invented by the author of the article. True, there are/were political parliamentary constituencies, Cardiff North, Cardiff South, Cardiff South and Penarth and Cardiff West, but these are well defined and already have Wikipedia articles. I came across these invented areas after an editor began wikilinking them to the words "north", "south", "west" etc. in Cardiff articles. The image in is based on political allegiances (while the map in West, South and East seems to have been invented by a wiki editor). Subsequently I've noticed a discussion has taken place on Talk:Cardiff North (geographical area), including an opinion from a non-involved independent editor which makes it clear this seems to be WP:OR and innappropriate. Cardiff isn't Berlin or Jerusalem, with walls or defining internal borders - time for these invented and confused articles to go, in my view.
I am also nominating the following related pages because of similar reasons - these geographical areas are an invention and open to dispute:
Sionk ( talk) 22:22, 14 August 2013 (UTC) reply