The result was no consensus. Seems to be relatively equal weight and proportionality of comments for delete/merge or keep, with some significant viewpoints of value with respect to both. -- Cirt ( talk) 11:07, 4 October 2010 (UTC) reply
I prodded this under WP:NOTNEWS with the rationale:
Fails WP:NOTNEWS and WP:EVENT - no deaths, and no demonstrated historical significance. All news reports are from either the event or the day of the arrest. More Wikinews content.
An editor changed the article a little and contested the PROD but did not, IMO, address the concerns in my PROD. Article is a news story about a horrible event - but there does not seem to be anything to show an enduring notability. All sources are written from the time of the event or at the time of the arrest. To prove my point the one retrospective source, written several months after the event, mentions the incident in 2 lines.... that is not enduring notability :)
The right place for this content is some sort of list or overview article. Errant [tmorton166] ( chat!) 17:03, 26 September 2010 (UTC) reply
The result was no consensus. Seems to be relatively equal weight and proportionality of comments for delete/merge or keep, with some significant viewpoints of value with respect to both. -- Cirt ( talk) 11:07, 4 October 2010 (UTC) reply
I prodded this under WP:NOTNEWS with the rationale:
Fails WP:NOTNEWS and WP:EVENT - no deaths, and no demonstrated historical significance. All news reports are from either the event or the day of the arrest. More Wikinews content.
An editor changed the article a little and contested the PROD but did not, IMO, address the concerns in my PROD. Article is a news story about a horrible event - but there does not seem to be anything to show an enduring notability. All sources are written from the time of the event or at the time of the arrest. To prove my point the one retrospective source, written several months after the event, mentions the incident in 2 lines.... that is not enduring notability :)
The right place for this content is some sort of list or overview article. Errant [tmorton166] ( chat!) 17:03, 26 September 2010 (UTC) reply