Spurious removal of third of new article. Note
diff - "WP:BLP. Pankowski himself is FRINGE, just on the other side of the spectrum" on page of SPLC profiled far-right activist/historian. VM clearly is averse to Poland's leading expert on racism and right wing extremism - possible
WP:BLPCOI.
Note dislike of Pankowski,
[3] edit summary falsely states this is a "passing mention" whereas this is in fact a 3,439 word piece in an expert source on gaming, that is devoted to Rafał Pankowski - an expert on the Polish far right.
Arguably, the work on "neo-Stalinism" is the most widely discussed piece of writing by the subject - three academic sources devote some space to it. Arguing against rather clear writing in the source (which explicitly say social sciences).
"absurd claims reflect on the person making them, so I'd say not-RS for this info" - vs. academic journal article, NEWSORG coverage that says the same, and IWP itself -
Talk:The Institute of World Politics#CIA recruitment pool - which lists the CIA first as an organization that hires its alumni.
Restoring
WP:BLPSPS full of red flags - e.g. "Jewish-Funded"" or ""former Marxist of Jewish extraction", "crass notoriety", alleged financial scandal. The PDF itself states that it was rejected by History for publication.
Misunderstanding of the meaning of academic. Chodakiewicz in a newspaper op-ed is not academic. Worse is Sommer (not a historian), cited to se.pl tabloid, who is known as a politician and editor of
Najwyższy Czas!
False edit summary - not a blanket removal but insertion of text based on 3 academic sources. BLP vio vs
Michael Ellman, misrepresented sources, and some really poor sources (book jacket at book store, se.pl tabloid, etc.).
Reinstating sock-puppet edit,
WP:PROXYING. Whitewashing anti-Jewish violence (sourced to a source discussing CKZP) which is the most widely discussed reason for Jews fleeing Poland post-war. Re-instating content that is not supported by the cited source and is even contradicted by it.
Second sequence in 29-30 May -
[8][9]. More that a bit off-topic given this happened in the USSR whereas Western Belarus was in Poland at the time. Placement in the midst of the
Belarusian Peasants' and Workers' Union minority part in Poland - is inappropriate - The Belarusian minority in Poland had little to do with events in the USSR.
"wth is "Journal for Deradicalization"? And could we maybe get some better sources here?" - a journal article +
Deutsche Welle would seem to be fairly good sources for association football.....
VM seems to think restoring content not supported by sources in the article is "NPOV". In fact the lead portion on the Holocaust (in a non-Holocaust article) is contradicted by the cited (not so great) USHMM source in the article -
[10].
"restore sourced text" - this edit in fact removes part of what was sourced to Hagen, and removes the citation - making it appear as if Yitshaq Ben-Ami is referencing what it isn't.
WP:ASPERSIONS, TP archive does not seem to support VM's assertion, nor do sources - most do not treat this as genocide. PA - accusations of extremism -
[11].
Removed the non-reliable www.doomedsoldiers.com, however retained the entire text introduced by the sock -
combined diff (one minor name). Introduced other citations (Mostly bare-urls to google-books). Some of the introduced citations do not support the text, and others contain information other than the text - e.g. "Josek Goldberg" (Josek probably a nickname/diminutive - like Yoska/Yoske) is "Józef Goldberg" in the first reference.[1] Retained the deadlink at www.abcnet.com.pl (so verified how?) - citing a paragraph+ of text.
Challenged as "mostly added by blocked sock. A number of NPOV, MOS, V, and SYNTH issues". Restored version with
MOS:ETHNICITY issue, still full of SYNTH, POV, and bits that fail verification - e.g. "Romkowski himself taught Różański everything about torture".
Libionka is not in the cited source by Chodakiewicz. Note also
[12] - "No idea what a "former Jews" means." where VM seems to think that Jews who had converted to Catholicism remain Jews. Specifically at least
Stanisław Ostwind-Zuzga was baptized.[2]
Probably related to François Robere, MyMoloboaccount, and Piotrus who showed up together - probably off the JUST law article. Reinstating low-quality media source - wiadomosci.onet.pl - to an article mainly sourced to academic sources (other than the short paragraph on the 2017 US law).
^Nacjonalizmy różnych narodów perspektywa politologiczno-religioznawcza, Księgarnia Akademicka, book chapter by Wojciech Muszyński, page 140 in the PDF,
ISBN978-83-7638-132-9, 2012, quote: "Pochodził z częściowo spolonizowanej rodziny żydowskiej z Warszawy, jako młody ochotnik wstąpił do I Brygady Legionów Polskich, uczestniczył jako podoficer w wojnie polsko-bolszewickiej. W okresie międzywojennym przyjął chrzest i pracował jako przodownik w Policji Państwowej." ("He came partly a Polonised Jewish family from Warsaw, as a young volunteer joined the First Brigade Polish Legions, he participated as a non-commissioned officer in the Polish-Bolshevik war. In the period He was baptized in the interwar period and worked as a leader in the State Police.)
Spurious removal of third of new article. Note
diff - "WP:BLP. Pankowski himself is FRINGE, just on the other side of the spectrum" on page of SPLC profiled far-right activist/historian. VM clearly is averse to Poland's leading expert on racism and right wing extremism - possible
WP:BLPCOI.
Note dislike of Pankowski,
[3] edit summary falsely states this is a "passing mention" whereas this is in fact a 3,439 word piece in an expert source on gaming, that is devoted to Rafał Pankowski - an expert on the Polish far right.
Arguably, the work on "neo-Stalinism" is the most widely discussed piece of writing by the subject - three academic sources devote some space to it. Arguing against rather clear writing in the source (which explicitly say social sciences).
"absurd claims reflect on the person making them, so I'd say not-RS for this info" - vs. academic journal article, NEWSORG coverage that says the same, and IWP itself -
Talk:The Institute of World Politics#CIA recruitment pool - which lists the CIA first as an organization that hires its alumni.
Restoring
WP:BLPSPS full of red flags - e.g. "Jewish-Funded"" or ""former Marxist of Jewish extraction", "crass notoriety", alleged financial scandal. The PDF itself states that it was rejected by History for publication.
Misunderstanding of the meaning of academic. Chodakiewicz in a newspaper op-ed is not academic. Worse is Sommer (not a historian), cited to se.pl tabloid, who is known as a politician and editor of
Najwyższy Czas!
False edit summary - not a blanket removal but insertion of text based on 3 academic sources. BLP vio vs
Michael Ellman, misrepresented sources, and some really poor sources (book jacket at book store, se.pl tabloid, etc.).
Reinstating sock-puppet edit,
WP:PROXYING. Whitewashing anti-Jewish violence (sourced to a source discussing CKZP) which is the most widely discussed reason for Jews fleeing Poland post-war. Re-instating content that is not supported by the cited source and is even contradicted by it.
Second sequence in 29-30 May -
[8][9]. More that a bit off-topic given this happened in the USSR whereas Western Belarus was in Poland at the time. Placement in the midst of the
Belarusian Peasants' and Workers' Union minority part in Poland - is inappropriate - The Belarusian minority in Poland had little to do with events in the USSR.
"wth is "Journal for Deradicalization"? And could we maybe get some better sources here?" - a journal article +
Deutsche Welle would seem to be fairly good sources for association football.....
VM seems to think restoring content not supported by sources in the article is "NPOV". In fact the lead portion on the Holocaust (in a non-Holocaust article) is contradicted by the cited (not so great) USHMM source in the article -
[10].
"restore sourced text" - this edit in fact removes part of what was sourced to Hagen, and removes the citation - making it appear as if Yitshaq Ben-Ami is referencing what it isn't.
WP:ASPERSIONS, TP archive does not seem to support VM's assertion, nor do sources - most do not treat this as genocide. PA - accusations of extremism -
[11].
Removed the non-reliable www.doomedsoldiers.com, however retained the entire text introduced by the sock -
combined diff (one minor name). Introduced other citations (Mostly bare-urls to google-books). Some of the introduced citations do not support the text, and others contain information other than the text - e.g. "Josek Goldberg" (Josek probably a nickname/diminutive - like Yoska/Yoske) is "Józef Goldberg" in the first reference.[1] Retained the deadlink at www.abcnet.com.pl (so verified how?) - citing a paragraph+ of text.
Challenged as "mostly added by blocked sock. A number of NPOV, MOS, V, and SYNTH issues". Restored version with
MOS:ETHNICITY issue, still full of SYNTH, POV, and bits that fail verification - e.g. "Romkowski himself taught Różański everything about torture".
Libionka is not in the cited source by Chodakiewicz. Note also
[12] - "No idea what a "former Jews" means." where VM seems to think that Jews who had converted to Catholicism remain Jews. Specifically at least
Stanisław Ostwind-Zuzga was baptized.[2]
Probably related to François Robere, MyMoloboaccount, and Piotrus who showed up together - probably off the JUST law article. Reinstating low-quality media source - wiadomosci.onet.pl - to an article mainly sourced to academic sources (other than the short paragraph on the 2017 US law).
^Nacjonalizmy różnych narodów perspektywa politologiczno-religioznawcza, Księgarnia Akademicka, book chapter by Wojciech Muszyński, page 140 in the PDF,
ISBN978-83-7638-132-9, 2012, quote: "Pochodził z częściowo spolonizowanej rodziny żydowskiej z Warszawy, jako młody ochotnik wstąpił do I Brygady Legionów Polskich, uczestniczył jako podoficer w wojnie polsko-bolszewickiej. W okresie międzywojennym przyjął chrzest i pracował jako przodownik w Policji Państwowej." ("He came partly a Polonised Jewish family from Warsaw, as a young volunteer joined the First Brigade Polish Legions, he participated as a non-commissioned officer in the Polish-Bolshevik war. In the period He was baptized in the interwar period and worked as a leader in the State Police.)