Identity-based Frameworks for Analyzing Islamist-based terrorism
Islamist-based fundamentalist terrorism against Western nations and the U.S. in particular, has numerous motivations [1] and takes place the larger context of a complex and tense relationship between the ‘West' and the Arab and Muslim 'world,'[2] which is highlighted in the previous section on
motivations and Islamic terrorism. Identity-based theoretical frameworks including theories of
Social Identity,
Social Categorization Theory, and
Psychodynamics are used to explain the reasons terrorism occurs [3]
Social Identity Theory
Social identity is explained by Karina Korostelina as a “feeling of belonging to a social group, as a strong connection with social category, and as an important part of our mind that affects our social perceptions and behavior” [4] This definition can be applied to the case of
Osama bin Laden, who, according to this theory, has a highly salient perception of his social identity as a Muslim, a strong connection to the social category of the Muslim
Ummah or 'community,' which affect his social perceptions and behaviors[5]. Bin Laden's ideology and interpretation of Islam [6] led to the creation of
al-Qaeda in response to perceived threats against the Muslim community by the Soviet Union, the U.S. in particular due to its troop presence in Saudi Arabia [7], and American support for Israel [8]. The Islamist terrorist group
al-Qaeda has a group identity, which includes “shared experiences, attitudes, beliefs, and interests of ingroup members,” and is “described through the achievement of a collective aim for which this group has been created,” [9] which in this case is to achieve "a complete break from the foreign influences in
Muslim countries, and the creation of a new Islamic
caliphate."[10]
Social Categorization Theory
Social categorization theory has been discussed as a three-stage process of identification, where “individuals define themselves as members of a social group, learn the stereotypes and norms of the group, and group categories influence the perception and understanding of all situations in a particular context”[11] This definition can be applied to the US
war on terror, in which conflict features such as the phenomenon of
Anti-Americanism[12] and the phenomenon of non-Arab countries like
Iran and
Afghanistan lending support to Islamist-based terrorism by funding or harboring terrorist groups such as
Hezbollah[13] and
al-Qaeda[14] against Western nations, particularly
Israel[15] and the
United States[16] are, according to social categorization theory, influenced by a three-stage process of identification. In this three-stage process of identification, the Arab and Muslim world(s)[17] are the
social group(s), their members learn
stereotypes and
norms which categorize their
social group vis-à-vis
the West.[18] This social categorization process creates feelings of high-level in-group support and allegiance among Arabs,[19] and Muslims[20] and the particular context within which members of the Arab and Muslim world(s)[21]social group(s) understand all situations that involve
the West. Social categorization theory as a framework for analysis indicates causal relationships between group identification processes and features of conflict situations.[22]
Identity-based Frameworks for Analyzing Islamist-based terrorism
Islamist-based fundamentalist terrorism against Western nations and the U.S. in particular, has numerous motivations [1] and takes place the larger context of a complex and tense relationship between the ‘West' and the Arab and Muslim 'world,'[2] which is highlighted in the previous section on
motivations and Islamic terrorism. Identity-based theoretical frameworks including theories of
Social Identity,
Social Categorization Theory, and
Psychodynamics are used to explain the reasons terrorism occurs [3]
Social Identity Theory
Social identity is explained by Karina Korostelina as a “feeling of belonging to a social group, as a strong connection with social category, and as an important part of our mind that affects our social perceptions and behavior” [4] This definition can be applied to the case of
Osama bin Laden, who, according to this theory, has a highly salient perception of his social identity as a Muslim, a strong connection to the social category of the Muslim
Ummah or 'community,' which affect his social perceptions and behaviors[5]. Bin Laden's ideology and interpretation of Islam [6] led to the creation of
al-Qaeda in response to perceived threats against the Muslim community by the Soviet Union, the U.S. in particular due to its troop presence in Saudi Arabia [7], and American support for Israel [8]. The Islamist terrorist group
al-Qaeda has a group identity, which includes “shared experiences, attitudes, beliefs, and interests of ingroup members,” and is “described through the achievement of a collective aim for which this group has been created,” [9] which in this case is to achieve "a complete break from the foreign influences in
Muslim countries, and the creation of a new Islamic
caliphate."[10]
Social Categorization Theory
Social categorization theory has been discussed as a three-stage process of identification, where “individuals define themselves as members of a social group, learn the stereotypes and norms of the group, and group categories influence the perception and understanding of all situations in a particular context”[11] This definition can be applied to the US
war on terror, in which conflict features such as the phenomenon of
Anti-Americanism[12] and the phenomenon of non-Arab countries like
Iran and
Afghanistan lending support to Islamist-based terrorism by funding or harboring terrorist groups such as
Hezbollah[13] and
al-Qaeda[14] against Western nations, particularly
Israel[15] and the
United States[16] are, according to social categorization theory, influenced by a three-stage process of identification. In this three-stage process of identification, the Arab and Muslim world(s)[17] are the
social group(s), their members learn
stereotypes and
norms which categorize their
social group vis-à-vis
the West.[18] This social categorization process creates feelings of high-level in-group support and allegiance among Arabs,[19] and Muslims[20] and the particular context within which members of the Arab and Muslim world(s)[21]social group(s) understand all situations that involve
the West. Social categorization theory as a framework for analysis indicates causal relationships between group identification processes and features of conflict situations.[22]