This is a log of all
proposed deletion tags applied or endorsed by this user using
Twinkle's PROD module since 12 January 2020 - older PRODs were not logged.
If you no longer wish to keep this log, you can turn it off using the
preferences panel, and nominate this page for speedy deletion under
CSD U1.
Reason: A
WP:BEFORE search showed no significant coverage by any RSes suggesting that the subject passes
WP:GNG. The subject's books have few citations and have not been reviewed by academics to meet
WP:NAUTHOR.
Reason: This article doesn't describe anything specific to
Hong Kong or its modern relations. This only describes historical content about the ancient
Nanyue /
Baiyue civilizations which include far more than just Hong Kong. This may also be a
WP:POVFORK for contested content that was repeatedly reverted at
Chinese New Year.
Reason: There are basically no independent reliable sources on this conjecture. The only references to this are from the authors or user-generated sources.
This is a log of all
proposed deletion tags applied or endorsed by this user using
Twinkle's PROD module since 12 January 2020 - older PRODs were not logged.
If you no longer wish to keep this log, you can turn it off using the
preferences panel, and nominate this page for speedy deletion under
CSD U1.
Reason: A
WP:BEFORE search showed no significant coverage by any RSes suggesting that the subject passes
WP:GNG. The subject's books have few citations and have not been reviewed by academics to meet
WP:NAUTHOR.
Reason: This article doesn't describe anything specific to
Hong Kong or its modern relations. This only describes historical content about the ancient
Nanyue /
Baiyue civilizations which include far more than just Hong Kong. This may also be a
WP:POVFORK for contested content that was repeatedly reverted at
Chinese New Year.
Reason: There are basically no independent reliable sources on this conjecture. The only references to this are from the authors or user-generated sources.