This is a log of all
proposed deletion tags applied or endorsed by this user using
Twinkle's PROD module.
If you no longer wish to keep this log, you can turn it off using the
preferences panel, and nominate this page for speedy deletion under
CSD U1.
Captains note: I have created far more prods than this, but I only started keeping the log in late Jan 2020, as I didn't realize that keeping a log was not turned on in Twinkle.
Reason: Created by serial hoaxer. While the book does seem to at least exist, I think this page was created simply to lend credence to the creating editor's other hoaxes, and warrants a
WP:TNT. Also, the sources here do not show notability, as all do not appear reliable. Regrettably I don't speak Farsi, so I couldn't find some other sources, if they even exist.
Reason: Created by serial hoaxer. The LAtimes source does not mention the song. The Farsi sources also turned up nothing, but that could also be the machine translation obfuscating things. However, the sourcing follows a pattern of the creating editor's other hoaxes.
Reason: Unsourced (since 2006!!), tagged with questionable notability, tagged as a hoax, created by a user who has "peeris" in their name. The only article that includes the name is
S. A. Peeris, who is Sri Lankan, not Indian. If a closer felt it applicable, they could redirect to that page, but I felt that inappropriate.
Reason: Created by serial hoaxer. They claim to have translated this from
[1], but thats clearly untrue; a quick reading of the article in Farsi shows that it is about an entirely different Garrison revolt, where the details have simply been changed. For instance, the Farsi page says the revolt was on July 2, discusses a General Hussein Khazaee that is not covered here, and the narrative, while similar, changes some key points.
Reason: Regardless of whether its a hoax, it certainly fails
WP:NCREATIVE, was created by an account with the same name as the subject, and is just promotional.
Reason: Created by serial hoaxer. Translated from the Farsi Wikipedia page, but doesn't use any of the same sources. Of the two sources in this article, one is dead and the other doesn't even mention Afkham beyond a half of a sentence. I also fail to see where the infobox data could have come from, as its not in the Farsi article, and the sources here or there don't seem to have it. Furthermore, this article doesn't seem to line up with the Farsi version, the details are off. Based on this user's history, I conclude that they made up the info that wasn't available and passed it off as legit. So, while this person did seem to exist, the circumstances of its creation warrant a
WP:TNT.
Reason: Created by serial hoaxer. This article does not line up with the farsi version of the article
[2]. Googling the Suadkuh rebellion turned up a whopping 7 google results, 2 of which were this page. The guy may have existed, but certainly not as is described herein. Follows the pattern of the other hoaxes by this editor.
Reason: Just an average Ottawa street. Fails
WP:GNG. BEFORE showed only routine coverage, and scant at that. I'd hoped that it might be notable from the
1900 Hull–Ottawa fire, but no such luck. I found an article with a single mention, but nothing rising to the level of significant. Unsourced since 2006.
Reason: Non-notable stub. Could only find one source that actually discussed this in any depth, and only because a friend of the owner wrote about it
[3].
This is a log of all
proposed deletion tags applied or endorsed by this user using
Twinkle's PROD module.
If you no longer wish to keep this log, you can turn it off using the
preferences panel, and nominate this page for speedy deletion under
CSD U1.
Captains note: I have created far more prods than this, but I only started keeping the log in late Jan 2020, as I didn't realize that keeping a log was not turned on in Twinkle.
Reason: Created by serial hoaxer. While the book does seem to at least exist, I think this page was created simply to lend credence to the creating editor's other hoaxes, and warrants a
WP:TNT. Also, the sources here do not show notability, as all do not appear reliable. Regrettably I don't speak Farsi, so I couldn't find some other sources, if they even exist.
Reason: Created by serial hoaxer. The LAtimes source does not mention the song. The Farsi sources also turned up nothing, but that could also be the machine translation obfuscating things. However, the sourcing follows a pattern of the creating editor's other hoaxes.
Reason: Unsourced (since 2006!!), tagged with questionable notability, tagged as a hoax, created by a user who has "peeris" in their name. The only article that includes the name is
S. A. Peeris, who is Sri Lankan, not Indian. If a closer felt it applicable, they could redirect to that page, but I felt that inappropriate.
Reason: Created by serial hoaxer. They claim to have translated this from
[1], but thats clearly untrue; a quick reading of the article in Farsi shows that it is about an entirely different Garrison revolt, where the details have simply been changed. For instance, the Farsi page says the revolt was on July 2, discusses a General Hussein Khazaee that is not covered here, and the narrative, while similar, changes some key points.
Reason: Regardless of whether its a hoax, it certainly fails
WP:NCREATIVE, was created by an account with the same name as the subject, and is just promotional.
Reason: Created by serial hoaxer. Translated from the Farsi Wikipedia page, but doesn't use any of the same sources. Of the two sources in this article, one is dead and the other doesn't even mention Afkham beyond a half of a sentence. I also fail to see where the infobox data could have come from, as its not in the Farsi article, and the sources here or there don't seem to have it. Furthermore, this article doesn't seem to line up with the Farsi version, the details are off. Based on this user's history, I conclude that they made up the info that wasn't available and passed it off as legit. So, while this person did seem to exist, the circumstances of its creation warrant a
WP:TNT.
Reason: Created by serial hoaxer. This article does not line up with the farsi version of the article
[2]. Googling the Suadkuh rebellion turned up a whopping 7 google results, 2 of which were this page. The guy may have existed, but certainly not as is described herein. Follows the pattern of the other hoaxes by this editor.
Reason: Just an average Ottawa street. Fails
WP:GNG. BEFORE showed only routine coverage, and scant at that. I'd hoped that it might be notable from the
1900 Hull–Ottawa fire, but no such luck. I found an article with a single mention, but nothing rising to the level of significant. Unsourced since 2006.
Reason: Non-notable stub. Could only find one source that actually discussed this in any depth, and only because a friend of the owner wrote about it
[3].