| Unclaimed | |
|---|---|
 Theatrical release poster | |
| Directed by | Michael Jorgensen |
| Written by | Michael Jorgensen |
| Produced by | Michael Jorgensen |
| Cinematography | Allan Leader |
| Edited by | Jonathan Mathew Nick Zacharkiw |
| Music by | Mike Shields |
Production company | Myth Merchant Films |
Release date |
|
Running time | 77 minutes |
| Country | Canada |
| Language | English |
Unclaimed is a 2013 Canadian documentary film about a man who claims to be former Special Forces Green Beret Master Sgt. John Hartley Robertson, who was declared dead after being shot down over Laos on a classified mission on 20 May 1968. The documentary is written, directed, and produced by Michael Jorgensen. It follows Tom Faunce, a veteran of the Vietnam War, in tracking down the man who claimed to be Robertson. Faunce was skeptical of Robertson's identity but eventually became convinced. He convinced Jorgensen to make a documentary about Robertson's story as a way to unite the man with his American family.
Leading up to the film's release, the validity of Robertson's identity was challenged by groups of Vietnam War veterans and groups that advocate the Vietnam War POW/MIA issue. Jean Robertson-Holley, Robertson's surviving sister, was convinced the man was her brother but initially declined DNA testing as unnecessary. Eventually she and her daughter (Robertson's niece) Gail Metcalf expressed openness to going through with testing. The documentary was screened at the Hot Docs Canadian International Documentary Festival on April 30, 2013. A day later, The Independent reported the contents of a memo from a 2009 report by the Defense Prisoner of War/Missing Personnel Office that the man who claimed to be Robertson was actually Dang Tan Ngoc, "a 76-year-old Vietnamese citizen of French origin who has a history of pretending to be US army veterans". [1]
Synopsis
Vietnam veteran Tom Faunce works as a missionary in Vietnam, where he hears of an elderly man claiming to be Robertson. Faunce's meeting with the man spurs him to try to repatriate him, against the wishes of the US government. [2]
The man claiming to be Robertson states in the film that he was kept in a bamboo cage in the jungle by the North Vietnamese and tortured for a year. Then, confused and badly injured, he was released and married a Vietnamese woman who had helped to care for him, assuming the name of her dead husband. Aged 76 as of 2013 [update], he lives in a remote village in south central Vietnam and is unable to remember his birthday or his American children's names and is now only able to speak Vietnamese. Scenes include a meeting with a veteran who was trained by Robertson back in 1960 and who recognized him on sight. [3]
Production
Unclaimed is written, directed, and produced by Michael Jorgensen. A veteran of the Vietnam War, Tom Faunce, had been on a humanitarian mission in southeast Asia in 2008 when he learned about John Hartley Robertson, a fellow soldier who was reported killed in action in the war, still alive in Vietnam. Faunce was skeptical when meeting Robertson but was eventually convinced of his identity. Faunce then contacted Jorgensen in 2012 to appeal to him to make a documentary as a way to help Robertson reunite with his family. Jorgensen was also skeptical but became convinced to make the documentary about Robertson. The filmmaker said he experienced difficulty with the U.S. military in making the documentary, such as being unable to contact Robertson's family. Jorgensen said a government source told him, "It's not that the Vietnamese won't let him (Robertson) go; it's that our government doesn't want him."
Validity of identity
Lead-up to film premiere
With the publicity of Unclaimed, the identity of the man who claimed to be Robertson was challenged. In the documentary, the Toronto Star reported the case made, "There is physical proof of Robertson's birthplace, collected in dramatic fashion onscreen; a tearful meeting in Vietnam with a soldier who was trained by Robertson in 1960 and said he knew him on sight; and a heart-wrenching reunion with his only surviving sister — 80-year-old Jean Robertson-Holly [sic]." Leading up to the film's premiere, Jorgensen said Robertson's American wife and two children had volunteered to participate in DNA testing but withdrew their intent. The filmmaker said, "Somebody suggested to me maybe that's (because) the daughters don't want to know if it's him. It's kind of like, that was an ugly war. It was a long time ago. We just want it to go away... I don't know. What would compel you not to want to know if this person is your biological father?" [3]
The film is already generating heated debate online, along with allegations the man claiming to be Robertson is a fraud.
— Toronto Star [4]
After the reunion, the Toronto Star said of the man who claimed to be Robertson, "He is back in Vietnam and has no desire to leave, having fulfilled his one wish: to see his American family once more before he dies." The sister, Robertson-Holley, said it was "not necessary" to conduct DNA testing since she confidently identifies the man as her brother. [3] Some groups of Vietnam War veterans and groups that advocate the Vietnam War POW/MIA issue questioned Robertson's identity. [4] The Toronto Star reported, "The film is already generating heated debate online, along with allegations the man claiming to be Robertson is a fraud." Robertson-Holley's daughter (Robertson's niece) Gail Metcalf said in response, "I don't blame people. I think some of the vets who say that are truly trying to protect us. They don’t want us to be scammed and their hearts are in the right place." [4] Robertson-Holley subsequently alleviated her adamant stance on DNA testing. Metcalf spoke for her mother, "We plan to do it when we can. We haven't been able to do it yet. In the beginning, mom's position was we don't care if people doubt. We're not spotlight kind of people." Expensive medical bills related to her parents' critical injuries was cited as a reason for delaying DNA testing. The Toronto Star said in April 2013 pressure would likely increase when the documentary screens at the GI Film Festival in May 2013. Metcalf said, "Of course we're more than willing. The bottom line is even if the DNA test came back negative, he’s still proven to be an American. My mother will never believe he is not her brother." [4]
Post-release
On May 1, 2013, a day after the film's premiere, The Independent reported that a memo based on a 2009 report from the Defense Prisoner of War/Missing Personnel Office (DPMO) said that the man who claimed to be Robertson was actually Dang Tan Ngoc, "a 76-year-old Vietnamese citizen of French origin who has a history of pretending to be US army veterans". The memo said Ngoc came to the attention of the U.S. military in 2006 due to his claim of being Robertson. Ngoc withdrew his claim at the time, but he made the claim once again in 2008. He was taken to the U.S. embassy in Cambodia to be fingerprinted, and his fingerprints did not match Robertson's on record. The Independent said, "Reports suggest Ngoc could have been impersonating Sgt Robertson since around 1982, with some Vietnam War veterans saying he could have possibly conned veteran groups out of thousands of pounds over the last 30 years." According to the newspaper, in 1991, Paramilitary Operations Officer Billy Waugh led an investigative team to Ngoc and was able to retrieve his DNA. [1] The Toronto Star reported members of the surviving family said they never submitted DNA samples. [5] A DPMO statement, quoted by Soldier of Fortune magazine, indicates "...mitochondrial DNA sequences from the hair samples obtained were compared to family reference samples taken from Robertson’s brother and one of his sisters." [6]
In response to the controversy, the GI Film Festival, which exhibited Unclaimed after the Toronto premier, posted a disclaimer on its site. [7]
Director's view
When Jorgensen was asked by the Toronto Star if he believed the man's identity, he replied, "It does not matter what I think. There's no doubt in the family." [3] Jorgensen did confirm to Maclean's magazine, however, he believes "the circumstantial evidence strongly indicates this man is John Hartley Robertson." [8]
Results of Robertson Family's Independent DNA test
In the wake of the controversy, the Robertson family raised funds in late 2013 to conduct their own independent DNA test. With results in hand, the family, on their funding site, GoFundMe [9] admitted the DNA of the man claiming to be Robertson did not match the DNA of Robertson's nephew.
The filmmaker Michael Jorgensen in an interview with Stars and Stripes suggested people should not focus on the failed DNA test but an isotope test conducted on Ngoc's last remaining tooth. [10] Jorgensen believes isotope test suggests Ngoc is likely an American. Stars and Stripes noted the isotope results match other areas of the world and failed to eliminate the possibility Ngoc grew up in another non-American location that matches the isotope levels measured in the tooth. In comments to the Stars and Stripes article a responder suggested the test could say nothing definitive as the filmmaker only tested one tooth. The responder suggested one needs to test two teeth that form at different times. If both teeth share similar isotope levels then one could say the person definitively grew up in a given geographic area. One cannot, by testing only one tooth, eliminate the possibility the man in the movie was moved around as a child and the isotope levels represent an "average", which just happen to correspond to some place in the U.S., an area with very diverse geography where one is likely to find a match within error bars.
Release
Michael Jorgensen sought for Unclaimed to screen in his home country of Canada first. The documentary was screened for the first time at an invitation-only patrons' screening at the Metro Cinema at the Garneau in early January 2013. [11] It then premiered at the Hot Docs Canadian International Documentary Festival on April 30, 2013. [3] The documentary had its first American screening at the GI Film Festival in Washington, D.C., on May 12, 2013. [12]
James Adams, reviewing for The Globe and Mail, gave the documentary three out of four stars and described it, "Part mystery, part forensic investigation, part journey to troubled pasts, part redemption song, Unclaimed is all heart." [13] Linda Barnard, who covered Unclaimed in the Toronto Star, [3] [4] also reviewed the documentary, "Canadian director Michael Jorgensen’s emotional story... seems unbelievable. To the filmmaker's credit, Jorgensen lets the audience decide whether or not to believe it as he follows Vietnam vet Tom Faunce’s quest to make good on a pledge to leave no man behind." [14]
Re-release
Unclaimed was re-released in May 2014, playing in New York City and Los Angeles. Martin Tsai of the LA Times notes "Michael Jorgensen...doesn't do serious investigative work to check [Ngoc's] claim that he's John Hartley Robertson". [15] The Hollywood Reporter assess the film's commercial potential as "slim for a doc that...seemingly has little interest in uncovering the truth." [16] The Village Voice calls Unclaimed "a nakedly manipulative film". [17]
References
- ^ a b Hall, John (May 1, 2013). "Revealed: Man claiming to be Vietnam veteran Sgt John Hartley Robertson who went missing and was presumed dead 44 years earlier is 'exposed as a fraud'". The Independent. Retrieved May 1, 2013.
- ^ Rogalski, Alexander. "Unclaimed". HotDocs.ca. Retrieved 26 April 2013.
- ^ a b c d e f Barnard, Linda (April 25, 2013). "Hot Docs premiere Unclaimed finds a Vietnam veteran left behind for 44 years". Toronto Star. Retrieved April 25, 2013.
- ^ a b c d e Barnard, Linda (April 30, 2013). "Hot Docs: Missing Vietnam vet's niece coming to Unclaimed world premiere". Toronto Star. Retrieved April 30, 2013.
- ^ Barnard, Linda (May 2, 2013). "Unclaimed: Controversy erupts over man claiming to be missing Vietnam veteran". Toronto Star. Retrieved May 2, 2013.
- ^ Soldier of Fortune Magazine (May 1, 2013). "DPMO Statement on Robertson/"Unclaimed"". Soldier of Fortune. Retrieved May 2, 2013.
- ^ "GI Film Festival - Unclaimed". Archived from the original on 2017-02-12.
- ^ Johnson, Brian (May 2, 2013). "Who's the 'slick fraudster'—the man claiming he's an MIA or the U.S. military?". Maclean's. Retrieved May 16, 2013.
- ^ "Bring John H Robertson Home - DNA Fund, organized by Ross Hanna".
- ^ Burke, Matthew (May 12, 2014). "DNA test proves Vietnam man is not missing Army sergeant". Stars & Stripes. Retrieved May 15, 2015.
- ^ "Blog". Archived from the original on 2013-05-01. Retrieved 2013-05-16.
- ^ Johnson, Robert (April 26, 2013). "New Documentary Says This US Soldier Is Alive In Vietnam 44 Years After Being Left Behind". Business Insider. Retrieved April 26, 2013.
- ^ Adams, James (April 25, 2013). "Unclaimed: Mystery of a lost – and found – Vietnam vet". The Globe and Mail. Retrieved April 30, 2013.
- ^ Staff (April 22, 2013). "23 Hot Docs movies reviewed". Toronto Star. Retrieved April 30, 2013.
- ^ Martin Tsai (May 1, 2014). "'Unclaimed' believes Vietnam man's claim he's an MIA American". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved May 1, 2014.
- ^ John DeFore (May 2, 2014). "A Vietnam vet tries to prove that one of the war's presumed casualties is still alive". The Hollywood Reporter. Retrieved May 2, 2014.
- ^ Chris Packham (April 30, 2014). "In Unclaimed, a U.S. Soldier KIA in Vietnam Reappears -- or Does He?". The Village Voice. Retrieved April 30, 2014.
External links
| Unclaimed | |
|---|---|
|
Theatrical release poster | |
| Directed by | Michael Jorgensen |
| Written by | Michael Jorgensen |
| Produced by | Michael Jorgensen |
| Cinematography | Allan Leader |
| Edited by | Jonathan Mathew Nick Zacharkiw |
| Music by | Mike Shields |
Production company | Myth Merchant Films |
Release date |
|
Running time | 77 minutes |
| Country | Canada |
| Language | English |
Unclaimed is a 2013 Canadian documentary film about a man who claims to be former Special Forces Green Beret Master Sgt. John Hartley Robertson, who was declared dead after being shot down over Laos on a classified mission on 20 May 1968. The documentary is written, directed, and produced by Michael Jorgensen. It follows Tom Faunce, a veteran of the Vietnam War, in tracking down the man who claimed to be Robertson. Faunce was skeptical of Robertson's identity but eventually became convinced. He convinced Jorgensen to make a documentary about Robertson's story as a way to unite the man with his American family.
Leading up to the film's release, the validity of Robertson's identity was challenged by groups of Vietnam War veterans and groups that advocate the Vietnam War POW/MIA issue. Jean Robertson-Holley, Robertson's surviving sister, was convinced the man was her brother but initially declined DNA testing as unnecessary. Eventually she and her daughter (Robertson's niece) Gail Metcalf expressed openness to going through with testing. The documentary was screened at the Hot Docs Canadian International Documentary Festival on April 30, 2013. A day later, The Independent reported the contents of a memo from a 2009 report by the Defense Prisoner of War/Missing Personnel Office that the man who claimed to be Robertson was actually Dang Tan Ngoc, "a 76-year-old Vietnamese citizen of French origin who has a history of pretending to be US army veterans". [1]
Synopsis
Vietnam veteran Tom Faunce works as a missionary in Vietnam, where he hears of an elderly man claiming to be Robertson. Faunce's meeting with the man spurs him to try to repatriate him, against the wishes of the US government. [2]
The man claiming to be Robertson states in the film that he was kept in a bamboo cage in the jungle by the North Vietnamese and tortured for a year. Then, confused and badly injured, he was released and married a Vietnamese woman who had helped to care for him, assuming the name of her dead husband. Aged 76 as of 2013 [update], he lives in a remote village in south central Vietnam and is unable to remember his birthday or his American children's names and is now only able to speak Vietnamese. Scenes include a meeting with a veteran who was trained by Robertson back in 1960 and who recognized him on sight. [3]
Production
Unclaimed is written, directed, and produced by Michael Jorgensen. A veteran of the Vietnam War, Tom Faunce, had been on a humanitarian mission in southeast Asia in 2008 when he learned about John Hartley Robertson, a fellow soldier who was reported killed in action in the war, still alive in Vietnam. Faunce was skeptical when meeting Robertson but was eventually convinced of his identity. Faunce then contacted Jorgensen in 2012 to appeal to him to make a documentary as a way to help Robertson reunite with his family. Jorgensen was also skeptical but became convinced to make the documentary about Robertson. The filmmaker said he experienced difficulty with the U.S. military in making the documentary, such as being unable to contact Robertson's family. Jorgensen said a government source told him, "It's not that the Vietnamese won't let him (Robertson) go; it's that our government doesn't want him."
Validity of identity
Lead-up to film premiere
With the publicity of Unclaimed, the identity of the man who claimed to be Robertson was challenged. In the documentary, the Toronto Star reported the case made, "There is physical proof of Robertson's birthplace, collected in dramatic fashion onscreen; a tearful meeting in Vietnam with a soldier who was trained by Robertson in 1960 and said he knew him on sight; and a heart-wrenching reunion with his only surviving sister — 80-year-old Jean Robertson-Holly [sic]." Leading up to the film's premiere, Jorgensen said Robertson's American wife and two children had volunteered to participate in DNA testing but withdrew their intent. The filmmaker said, "Somebody suggested to me maybe that's (because) the daughters don't want to know if it's him. It's kind of like, that was an ugly war. It was a long time ago. We just want it to go away... I don't know. What would compel you not to want to know if this person is your biological father?" [3]
The film is already generating heated debate online, along with allegations the man claiming to be Robertson is a fraud.
— Toronto Star [4]
After the reunion, the Toronto Star said of the man who claimed to be Robertson, "He is back in Vietnam and has no desire to leave, having fulfilled his one wish: to see his American family once more before he dies." The sister, Robertson-Holley, said it was "not necessary" to conduct DNA testing since she confidently identifies the man as her brother. [3] Some groups of Vietnam War veterans and groups that advocate the Vietnam War POW/MIA issue questioned Robertson's identity. [4] The Toronto Star reported, "The film is already generating heated debate online, along with allegations the man claiming to be Robertson is a fraud." Robertson-Holley's daughter (Robertson's niece) Gail Metcalf said in response, "I don't blame people. I think some of the vets who say that are truly trying to protect us. They don’t want us to be scammed and their hearts are in the right place." [4] Robertson-Holley subsequently alleviated her adamant stance on DNA testing. Metcalf spoke for her mother, "We plan to do it when we can. We haven't been able to do it yet. In the beginning, mom's position was we don't care if people doubt. We're not spotlight kind of people." Expensive medical bills related to her parents' critical injuries was cited as a reason for delaying DNA testing. The Toronto Star said in April 2013 pressure would likely increase when the documentary screens at the GI Film Festival in May 2013. Metcalf said, "Of course we're more than willing. The bottom line is even if the DNA test came back negative, he’s still proven to be an American. My mother will never believe he is not her brother." [4]
Post-release
On May 1, 2013, a day after the film's premiere, The Independent reported that a memo based on a 2009 report from the Defense Prisoner of War/Missing Personnel Office (DPMO) said that the man who claimed to be Robertson was actually Dang Tan Ngoc, "a 76-year-old Vietnamese citizen of French origin who has a history of pretending to be US army veterans". The memo said Ngoc came to the attention of the U.S. military in 2006 due to his claim of being Robertson. Ngoc withdrew his claim at the time, but he made the claim once again in 2008. He was taken to the U.S. embassy in Cambodia to be fingerprinted, and his fingerprints did not match Robertson's on record. The Independent said, "Reports suggest Ngoc could have been impersonating Sgt Robertson since around 1982, with some Vietnam War veterans saying he could have possibly conned veteran groups out of thousands of pounds over the last 30 years." According to the newspaper, in 1991, Paramilitary Operations Officer Billy Waugh led an investigative team to Ngoc and was able to retrieve his DNA. [1] The Toronto Star reported members of the surviving family said they never submitted DNA samples. [5] A DPMO statement, quoted by Soldier of Fortune magazine, indicates "...mitochondrial DNA sequences from the hair samples obtained were compared to family reference samples taken from Robertson’s brother and one of his sisters." [6]
In response to the controversy, the GI Film Festival, which exhibited Unclaimed after the Toronto premier, posted a disclaimer on its site. [7]
Director's view
When Jorgensen was asked by the Toronto Star if he believed the man's identity, he replied, "It does not matter what I think. There's no doubt in the family." [3] Jorgensen did confirm to Maclean's magazine, however, he believes "the circumstantial evidence strongly indicates this man is John Hartley Robertson." [8]
Results of Robertson Family's Independent DNA test
In the wake of the controversy, the Robertson family raised funds in late 2013 to conduct their own independent DNA test. With results in hand, the family, on their funding site, GoFundMe [9] admitted the DNA of the man claiming to be Robertson did not match the DNA of Robertson's nephew.
The filmmaker Michael Jorgensen in an interview with Stars and Stripes suggested people should not focus on the failed DNA test but an isotope test conducted on Ngoc's last remaining tooth. [10] Jorgensen believes isotope test suggests Ngoc is likely an American. Stars and Stripes noted the isotope results match other areas of the world and failed to eliminate the possibility Ngoc grew up in another non-American location that matches the isotope levels measured in the tooth. In comments to the Stars and Stripes article a responder suggested the test could say nothing definitive as the filmmaker only tested one tooth. The responder suggested one needs to test two teeth that form at different times. If both teeth share similar isotope levels then one could say the person definitively grew up in a given geographic area. One cannot, by testing only one tooth, eliminate the possibility the man in the movie was moved around as a child and the isotope levels represent an "average", which just happen to correspond to some place in the U.S., an area with very diverse geography where one is likely to find a match within error bars.
Release
Michael Jorgensen sought for Unclaimed to screen in his home country of Canada first. The documentary was screened for the first time at an invitation-only patrons' screening at the Metro Cinema at the Garneau in early January 2013. [11] It then premiered at the Hot Docs Canadian International Documentary Festival on April 30, 2013. [3] The documentary had its first American screening at the GI Film Festival in Washington, D.C., on May 12, 2013. [12]
James Adams, reviewing for The Globe and Mail, gave the documentary three out of four stars and described it, "Part mystery, part forensic investigation, part journey to troubled pasts, part redemption song, Unclaimed is all heart." [13] Linda Barnard, who covered Unclaimed in the Toronto Star, [3] [4] also reviewed the documentary, "Canadian director Michael Jorgensen’s emotional story... seems unbelievable. To the filmmaker's credit, Jorgensen lets the audience decide whether or not to believe it as he follows Vietnam vet Tom Faunce’s quest to make good on a pledge to leave no man behind." [14]
Re-release
Unclaimed was re-released in May 2014, playing in New York City and Los Angeles. Martin Tsai of the LA Times notes "Michael Jorgensen...doesn't do serious investigative work to check [Ngoc's] claim that he's John Hartley Robertson". [15] The Hollywood Reporter assess the film's commercial potential as "slim for a doc that...seemingly has little interest in uncovering the truth." [16] The Village Voice calls Unclaimed "a nakedly manipulative film". [17]
References
- ^ a b Hall, John (May 1, 2013). "Revealed: Man claiming to be Vietnam veteran Sgt John Hartley Robertson who went missing and was presumed dead 44 years earlier is 'exposed as a fraud'". The Independent. Retrieved May 1, 2013.
- ^ Rogalski, Alexander. "Unclaimed". HotDocs.ca. Retrieved 26 April 2013.
- ^ a b c d e f Barnard, Linda (April 25, 2013). "Hot Docs premiere Unclaimed finds a Vietnam veteran left behind for 44 years". Toronto Star. Retrieved April 25, 2013.
- ^ a b c d e Barnard, Linda (April 30, 2013). "Hot Docs: Missing Vietnam vet's niece coming to Unclaimed world premiere". Toronto Star. Retrieved April 30, 2013.
- ^ Barnard, Linda (May 2, 2013). "Unclaimed: Controversy erupts over man claiming to be missing Vietnam veteran". Toronto Star. Retrieved May 2, 2013.
- ^ Soldier of Fortune Magazine (May 1, 2013). "DPMO Statement on Robertson/"Unclaimed"". Soldier of Fortune. Retrieved May 2, 2013.
- ^ "GI Film Festival - Unclaimed". Archived from the original on 2017-02-12.
- ^ Johnson, Brian (May 2, 2013). "Who's the 'slick fraudster'—the man claiming he's an MIA or the U.S. military?". Maclean's. Retrieved May 16, 2013.
- ^ "Bring John H Robertson Home - DNA Fund, organized by Ross Hanna".
- ^ Burke, Matthew (May 12, 2014). "DNA test proves Vietnam man is not missing Army sergeant". Stars & Stripes. Retrieved May 15, 2015.
- ^ "Blog". Archived from the original on 2013-05-01. Retrieved 2013-05-16.
- ^ Johnson, Robert (April 26, 2013). "New Documentary Says This US Soldier Is Alive In Vietnam 44 Years After Being Left Behind". Business Insider. Retrieved April 26, 2013.
- ^ Adams, James (April 25, 2013). "Unclaimed: Mystery of a lost – and found – Vietnam vet". The Globe and Mail. Retrieved April 30, 2013.
- ^ Staff (April 22, 2013). "23 Hot Docs movies reviewed". Toronto Star. Retrieved April 30, 2013.
- ^ Martin Tsai (May 1, 2014). "'Unclaimed' believes Vietnam man's claim he's an MIA American". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved May 1, 2014.
- ^ John DeFore (May 2, 2014). "A Vietnam vet tries to prove that one of the war's presumed casualties is still alive". The Hollywood Reporter. Retrieved May 2, 2014.
- ^ Chris Packham (April 30, 2014). "In Unclaimed, a U.S. Soldier KIA in Vietnam Reappears -- or Does He?". The Village Voice. Retrieved April 30, 2014.