Olympics Template‑class | |||||||
|
@ Galatz: you reverted my change to placing Israel in Asia on the grounds that "Although in Asia they compete with Europe and are consistently listed as such in templates."
Two questions:
At the Olympics, each nation competes independently, and not as part of a continental or regional bloc. There is no "Asia" or "Europe" competitive group at the Olympics. So since Israel is, objectively, in Asia, why should it not be placed in the Asia list here?
Which other templates list Israel as part of Europe and why do they do so? Is the reason there valid here? Please bring the examples and explain. -- 22:38, 9 August 2016 (UTC)
Maybe Israel, Cyprus and European states should be listed under European Olympic Committees, rather than Europe, since they belong in EOC but not in Europe. And there only reads "Europe", without any explanation. It's the same for other years, as is mentioned above. 85.76.79.164 ( talk) 15:55, 11 December 2016 (UTC)
Olympics Template‑class | |||||||
|
@ Galatz: you reverted my change to placing Israel in Asia on the grounds that "Although in Asia they compete with Europe and are consistently listed as such in templates."
Two questions:
At the Olympics, each nation competes independently, and not as part of a continental or regional bloc. There is no "Asia" or "Europe" competitive group at the Olympics. So since Israel is, objectively, in Asia, why should it not be placed in the Asia list here?
Which other templates list Israel as part of Europe and why do they do so? Is the reason there valid here? Please bring the examples and explain. -- 22:38, 9 August 2016 (UTC)
Maybe Israel, Cyprus and European states should be listed under European Olympic Committees, rather than Europe, since they belong in EOC but not in Europe. And there only reads "Europe", without any explanation. It's the same for other years, as is mentioned above. 85.76.79.164 ( talk) 15:55, 11 December 2016 (UTC)