Television: Reality Template‑class | ||||||||||
|
Television: The X Factor Template‑class | ||||||||||
|
Okay, so why can't we keep them all in the template? If they have articles, I don't see why not.
anemone│
projectors
20:22, 25 March 2009 (UTC)
Because half of them havent done anything notable at all. If you take for example American Idol, their list has less people from more contestants. I think that either the list is cut down to those who are actually notable for something, or it should be removed alltogeter. I mean, some of the contestants have achieved notable success without being in the top 2 - eg Chico (number 1 single) whilst others have accomplished very little - I dont think Nikitta Angus to use an example has had much success since leaving the show, and shouldnt really be on this list.
I think finding a suitable criteria for inclussion on this type of list would be useful. I dont have time to come up with one at the moment, but perhaps it could be based on sales figures, as well as any other degree of notability - some contestants have had more success on stage than some have in selling records. ( 90.201.176.86 ( talk) 18:02, 26 March 2009 (UTC))
Yes i think getting rid of all those would be fair. I think there would be an argument for Cassie who apparently has a stage career going, but Daniel DeBourg has done nothing noteworthy post X-Factor - in fact, I think the only reason why he has a page is because he wrote songs before it. Ruth Lorenzo and Laura White may become notable in time, but its too soon to say, so they should also go, though I think someone else will eventully add them back anyway. Eoghan Quigg hasnt done anything notable post competition, but since he was a finalist, I think thats notable enough. ( 90.201.176.86 ( talk) 20:16, 27 March 2009 (UTC))
I removed the link to this "link of songs from British reality contestants" article. Whilst I think a page with strictly X Factor contestants would be acceptable, I dont think the one thats there now really should be here. The list is also incomplete - in fact, the only X Factor content on it is Leona - none of the others are there. —Preceding unsigned comment added by Kyleofark ( talk • contribs) 18:15, 22 May 2009 (UTC)
Geri Halliwell and many other judges have stepped in for Dannii while off, i think you should add them in down there. -- 86.151.199.124 ( talk) 16:38, 9 June 2010 (UTC)
rumors have started circulating around twitter that Danni has quit the show due to australia's got talent clashing with this years The X Factor but no official word from Danni yet? Fatty2k10 ( talk) 21:30, 14 May 2011 (UTC)
Why don't they "need" to be included in this template? Was there a discussion? They've been listed until now, so what's different? I think they should be included. – anemone projectors– 15:54, 7 February 2012 (UTC)
Hi, we don't need to list Caroline as a main presenter because she only presented backstage for the live shows in 2013. -- MSalmon ( talk) 23:16, 15 December 2013 (UTC)
Roman Kemp now has a Wikipedia article so I'm wondering if we should place him in this template, and if so, where? anemone projectors 08:36, 8 July 2016 (UTC)
The contestants template has recently been merged with this one, so I'd like to suggest cutting out all the non-finalists and having the finalists per series under the finalists section, thus removing winners and other contestants. It may also mean the removal of Lucy Benjamin because I wouldn't know where to put her but WP:PERFNAV probably applies to her anyway.
Are there any objections? — ᴀnemone ᴘroᴊecтors 19:05, 29 March 2018 (UTC)
Television: Reality Template‑class | ||||||||||
|
Television: The X Factor Template‑class | ||||||||||
|
Okay, so why can't we keep them all in the template? If they have articles, I don't see why not.
anemone│
projectors
20:22, 25 March 2009 (UTC)
Because half of them havent done anything notable at all. If you take for example American Idol, their list has less people from more contestants. I think that either the list is cut down to those who are actually notable for something, or it should be removed alltogeter. I mean, some of the contestants have achieved notable success without being in the top 2 - eg Chico (number 1 single) whilst others have accomplished very little - I dont think Nikitta Angus to use an example has had much success since leaving the show, and shouldnt really be on this list.
I think finding a suitable criteria for inclussion on this type of list would be useful. I dont have time to come up with one at the moment, but perhaps it could be based on sales figures, as well as any other degree of notability - some contestants have had more success on stage than some have in selling records. ( 90.201.176.86 ( talk) 18:02, 26 March 2009 (UTC))
Yes i think getting rid of all those would be fair. I think there would be an argument for Cassie who apparently has a stage career going, but Daniel DeBourg has done nothing noteworthy post X-Factor - in fact, I think the only reason why he has a page is because he wrote songs before it. Ruth Lorenzo and Laura White may become notable in time, but its too soon to say, so they should also go, though I think someone else will eventully add them back anyway. Eoghan Quigg hasnt done anything notable post competition, but since he was a finalist, I think thats notable enough. ( 90.201.176.86 ( talk) 20:16, 27 March 2009 (UTC))
I removed the link to this "link of songs from British reality contestants" article. Whilst I think a page with strictly X Factor contestants would be acceptable, I dont think the one thats there now really should be here. The list is also incomplete - in fact, the only X Factor content on it is Leona - none of the others are there. —Preceding unsigned comment added by Kyleofark ( talk • contribs) 18:15, 22 May 2009 (UTC)
Geri Halliwell and many other judges have stepped in for Dannii while off, i think you should add them in down there. -- 86.151.199.124 ( talk) 16:38, 9 June 2010 (UTC)
rumors have started circulating around twitter that Danni has quit the show due to australia's got talent clashing with this years The X Factor but no official word from Danni yet? Fatty2k10 ( talk) 21:30, 14 May 2011 (UTC)
Why don't they "need" to be included in this template? Was there a discussion? They've been listed until now, so what's different? I think they should be included. – anemone projectors– 15:54, 7 February 2012 (UTC)
Hi, we don't need to list Caroline as a main presenter because she only presented backstage for the live shows in 2013. -- MSalmon ( talk) 23:16, 15 December 2013 (UTC)
Roman Kemp now has a Wikipedia article so I'm wondering if we should place him in this template, and if so, where? anemone projectors 08:36, 8 July 2016 (UTC)
The contestants template has recently been merged with this one, so I'd like to suggest cutting out all the non-finalists and having the finalists per series under the finalists section, thus removing winners and other contestants. It may also mean the removal of Lucy Benjamin because I wouldn't know where to put her but WP:PERFNAV probably applies to her anyway.
Are there any objections? — ᴀnemone ᴘroᴊecтors 19:05, 29 March 2018 (UTC)