This article is rated B-class on Wikipedia's
content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | |||||||||||
|
I'm editing out the link of the Burzum's guy taxt. It's a racist text about how the aryan race from scandinavia will conquer the world. Right. 200.222.3.3 ( talk) 16:20, 22 January 2008 (UTC)
"The evolutionary record of humanity reaches beyond the shadows of the Polar race, the fog-shapes of the Hyperborean race, the androgynous Lemurian race of giants, the giants of the Atlantic race and the creative man of the Aryan race (see my second book, Germansk mytologi og verdensanskuelse for more details on this).
In our evolutionary-chain, there are seven races; the five mentioned above and two others. Only the seventh is complete and in order to understand and develop the technology, we need to bring the universe to a higher evolutionary level.
The sixth race will be called the solar race and will consist of pure Aryans with a highly developed intelligence and body. All true folk-companions shall join together in Scandinavia; or will be bound to Scandinavia through political and military alliances from their own native countries.
The new Europe will, in other words, be led and run from Scandinavia - the High-fortress of the Aryan tribe. Schools and other educational centers shall be built in a heathen Scandinavia, and kinsmen from all over the world - but foremost from Europe and the USA - will migrate there to learn the thought of Irminsûl."
Hello Dysmorodrepanis ( talk · contribs). I noticed you've recently reworked this article, which it, of course, needed. However, I think more development here needs to be done in a neutral matter. What do you say we work together and put together the best article on the subject on the internet?
First,I recommend that we reformat the article. Generally, I find it to be very helpful to first go through all of the known attestations of the subject matter (in this case the Irminsul and Irmin) and state them up front - I think this is the best way to dispel any nonsense that may be surrounding subjects in these quarters. Then we ought to follow the attestations up them up with whatever theories may surround that particular detail and then, after the sources are listed, whatever theories and speculation may exist around the subject matter. :bloodofox: ( talk) 05:48, 7 June 2008 (UTC)
Thanks! There certainly is a lot of speculation and half-truths surrounding the subject. Creating a solidly referenced and straight-forward article here will help sort some things out and, along the way, maybe we can learn a thing or two. The beauty of Wikipedia!
About the introduction, while the subject hasn't attracted a huge amount of scholarly interest, anyone writing about the Germanic peoples will probably mention the Irminsul. As you know, figures like Jacob Grimm and Eugene Goblet d'Alviella (where most of this information comes from) are certainly very notable figures, so I think that is probably enough alone for us to say something like what we have in the introduction at the moment - it doesn't say there's a huge amount of scholarly work around the subject, just that it is a topic of some scholarly interest.
One thing I really stress in the articles I put work into is primary sources. I like to really dig up the primary sources of a subject and present them before I present the theories surrounding the subject - I find that this is the best way to present things like this. Too often, the primary sources are danced around and subsequently this gives rise to elaboration and half-truths seen through someone else's monocle. So, I think we ought to dig up every primary source regarding the Irminsul and put it in the "Attestations" section in a chronological manner. So, right now, I am trying to dig up all these mentions and then afterwards will flesh all the other sections out.
About Teudt, we have to remain neutral about him - a note mentioning that he provided no evidence to back his claim is probably enough for most people to get the idea. We also need to make sure his work doesn't make its way into anywhere else but the "Extersteine" section (like the rest of the theories) so people know very clearly what is attested and what is conjecture.
This seems to be a problem with the German Wikipedia article on the subject - they've got theories about Völuspá, Yggdrasil, Thor's Oak, and the Sacred tree at Uppsala mixed in with the primary sources, whereas it should really be sectioned off into the "theories" section because, while there is obviously some sort of connection, the connection is not directly attested. :bloodofox: ( talk) 00:33, 10 June 2008 (UTC)
I have some of what was above expanded, it is now below.
Dysmorodrepanis (
talk) 07:30, 10 June 2008 (UTC)
"And subsequently [after the council in Worms, Charlemagne] went for the first time into the Saxon lands, captured the castle of Eresburg, and went on as far as to the Irminsul and destroyed that idol and seized and brought back the gold and silver that he found there. And there was a great drought, so that there was a lack of water at the aforementioned locality, where the Irminsul stood; and when [Charlemagne] wanted to stay two or three days to destroy that idol he had no water, then suddenly due to the generousity of God at mid-day when the whole army was resting [the next bit I'm not 100% sure about] there sprang fourth in a streambed a lot of water that nobody had ever seen there before [i.e. the spring had not been active previously], and the whole army was sufficiently supplied. Then [Charlemagne] went over [to?] the Weser and made a ceasefire/truce [? placitum] with the Saxons and received 12 hostages and returned to Frankish lands."
"And after the council in Worms, Charlemagne decided to wage war upon the Saxons; and he went forthwith and devastated everything with fire and sword, captured the castle of Eresburg, and destroyed the idol that the Saxons call Irminsul. And as he took three days [to destroy the idol] it occurred that due to the constant sunny weather all brooks and springs at the locality dried up and no water was to be had. So that the army would no longer suffer from thirst it happened, due to divine interference as is believed, that one day when everybody was resting at mid-day as usual there sprang from the mountain near which the army camped such a quantity of water into a forest creek's bed that the whole army had sufficient. After the idol was destroyed, the king travelled to the Weser and had 12 hostages delivered to him by the Saxons. Then he returned to the Frankish lands."
Ask veit ek standa / heitir Yggdrasill...
I don't have a lot of time to respond to this at the moment but I haven't forgotten about it. We ought to move the sources you've mentioned into the article though with sourced translations. I'll do it later if nobody beats me to it! :bloodofox: ( talk) 13:26, 12 June 2008 (UTC)
How is it pronounced? Is there a kind of "established English pronunciation"? Could somebody provide IPA-info? 217.236.180.7 ( talk) 15:57, 27 May 2010 (UTC)
"Ir-" is pronounced like "Ear", "-min-" is pronounced like "-mean-", "-sul" is pronounced like tool, but with an S in front of course. 92.196.58.240 ( talk) 21:52, 3 March 2013 (UTC)
"A Germanic god Irmin".
Sorry this is plain wrong, based on Widukind of Corvey's fantasy. Irmin comes from *(e)irmanaz, which is translated great, big, or mighty. Sul is Säule translated as pillar. Irminsul is just the mighty pillar. Irmin is a normal German name, that is known as Herman, or in Latin Arminius. There is also feminine form of this name Irmina, see Irmina of Oeren 92.196.58.240 ( talk) 21:48, 3 March 2013 (UTC)
i was keen to get a short description of what was believed to be the function, the nature of this magical object and somehow i could not find an answer for this in the article. it does tell things in a nice encyclopedical style about the history of research and thinking about the topic from later ages, but really seems not to touch the core of what is an (or the) irminsul for the german pagan tribes who built or worshipped them. the above "rework" discussion is a lot more informative than the article itself (though its discussion form is obvoiously would not make it fit for the article page), but even that discussion did not get me the answer. (what i was lookinf for is something like e.g. in the atticle about Odin you find somewhere that he was a god of something and was believed to have some powers/fields of influence, etc. this kind of simple short description of irminsul is what i miss here.) 89.134.199.32 ( talk) 21:32, 15 February 2020 (UTC).
This article is rated B-class on Wikipedia's
content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | |||||||||||
|
I'm editing out the link of the Burzum's guy taxt. It's a racist text about how the aryan race from scandinavia will conquer the world. Right. 200.222.3.3 ( talk) 16:20, 22 January 2008 (UTC)
"The evolutionary record of humanity reaches beyond the shadows of the Polar race, the fog-shapes of the Hyperborean race, the androgynous Lemurian race of giants, the giants of the Atlantic race and the creative man of the Aryan race (see my second book, Germansk mytologi og verdensanskuelse for more details on this).
In our evolutionary-chain, there are seven races; the five mentioned above and two others. Only the seventh is complete and in order to understand and develop the technology, we need to bring the universe to a higher evolutionary level.
The sixth race will be called the solar race and will consist of pure Aryans with a highly developed intelligence and body. All true folk-companions shall join together in Scandinavia; or will be bound to Scandinavia through political and military alliances from their own native countries.
The new Europe will, in other words, be led and run from Scandinavia - the High-fortress of the Aryan tribe. Schools and other educational centers shall be built in a heathen Scandinavia, and kinsmen from all over the world - but foremost from Europe and the USA - will migrate there to learn the thought of Irminsûl."
Hello Dysmorodrepanis ( talk · contribs). I noticed you've recently reworked this article, which it, of course, needed. However, I think more development here needs to be done in a neutral matter. What do you say we work together and put together the best article on the subject on the internet?
First,I recommend that we reformat the article. Generally, I find it to be very helpful to first go through all of the known attestations of the subject matter (in this case the Irminsul and Irmin) and state them up front - I think this is the best way to dispel any nonsense that may be surrounding subjects in these quarters. Then we ought to follow the attestations up them up with whatever theories may surround that particular detail and then, after the sources are listed, whatever theories and speculation may exist around the subject matter. :bloodofox: ( talk) 05:48, 7 June 2008 (UTC)
Thanks! There certainly is a lot of speculation and half-truths surrounding the subject. Creating a solidly referenced and straight-forward article here will help sort some things out and, along the way, maybe we can learn a thing or two. The beauty of Wikipedia!
About the introduction, while the subject hasn't attracted a huge amount of scholarly interest, anyone writing about the Germanic peoples will probably mention the Irminsul. As you know, figures like Jacob Grimm and Eugene Goblet d'Alviella (where most of this information comes from) are certainly very notable figures, so I think that is probably enough alone for us to say something like what we have in the introduction at the moment - it doesn't say there's a huge amount of scholarly work around the subject, just that it is a topic of some scholarly interest.
One thing I really stress in the articles I put work into is primary sources. I like to really dig up the primary sources of a subject and present them before I present the theories surrounding the subject - I find that this is the best way to present things like this. Too often, the primary sources are danced around and subsequently this gives rise to elaboration and half-truths seen through someone else's monocle. So, I think we ought to dig up every primary source regarding the Irminsul and put it in the "Attestations" section in a chronological manner. So, right now, I am trying to dig up all these mentions and then afterwards will flesh all the other sections out.
About Teudt, we have to remain neutral about him - a note mentioning that he provided no evidence to back his claim is probably enough for most people to get the idea. We also need to make sure his work doesn't make its way into anywhere else but the "Extersteine" section (like the rest of the theories) so people know very clearly what is attested and what is conjecture.
This seems to be a problem with the German Wikipedia article on the subject - they've got theories about Völuspá, Yggdrasil, Thor's Oak, and the Sacred tree at Uppsala mixed in with the primary sources, whereas it should really be sectioned off into the "theories" section because, while there is obviously some sort of connection, the connection is not directly attested. :bloodofox: ( talk) 00:33, 10 June 2008 (UTC)
I have some of what was above expanded, it is now below.
Dysmorodrepanis (
talk) 07:30, 10 June 2008 (UTC)
"And subsequently [after the council in Worms, Charlemagne] went for the first time into the Saxon lands, captured the castle of Eresburg, and went on as far as to the Irminsul and destroyed that idol and seized and brought back the gold and silver that he found there. And there was a great drought, so that there was a lack of water at the aforementioned locality, where the Irminsul stood; and when [Charlemagne] wanted to stay two or three days to destroy that idol he had no water, then suddenly due to the generousity of God at mid-day when the whole army was resting [the next bit I'm not 100% sure about] there sprang fourth in a streambed a lot of water that nobody had ever seen there before [i.e. the spring had not been active previously], and the whole army was sufficiently supplied. Then [Charlemagne] went over [to?] the Weser and made a ceasefire/truce [? placitum] with the Saxons and received 12 hostages and returned to Frankish lands."
"And after the council in Worms, Charlemagne decided to wage war upon the Saxons; and he went forthwith and devastated everything with fire and sword, captured the castle of Eresburg, and destroyed the idol that the Saxons call Irminsul. And as he took three days [to destroy the idol] it occurred that due to the constant sunny weather all brooks and springs at the locality dried up and no water was to be had. So that the army would no longer suffer from thirst it happened, due to divine interference as is believed, that one day when everybody was resting at mid-day as usual there sprang from the mountain near which the army camped such a quantity of water into a forest creek's bed that the whole army had sufficient. After the idol was destroyed, the king travelled to the Weser and had 12 hostages delivered to him by the Saxons. Then he returned to the Frankish lands."
Ask veit ek standa / heitir Yggdrasill...
I don't have a lot of time to respond to this at the moment but I haven't forgotten about it. We ought to move the sources you've mentioned into the article though with sourced translations. I'll do it later if nobody beats me to it! :bloodofox: ( talk) 13:26, 12 June 2008 (UTC)
How is it pronounced? Is there a kind of "established English pronunciation"? Could somebody provide IPA-info? 217.236.180.7 ( talk) 15:57, 27 May 2010 (UTC)
"Ir-" is pronounced like "Ear", "-min-" is pronounced like "-mean-", "-sul" is pronounced like tool, but with an S in front of course. 92.196.58.240 ( talk) 21:52, 3 March 2013 (UTC)
"A Germanic god Irmin".
Sorry this is plain wrong, based on Widukind of Corvey's fantasy. Irmin comes from *(e)irmanaz, which is translated great, big, or mighty. Sul is Säule translated as pillar. Irminsul is just the mighty pillar. Irmin is a normal German name, that is known as Herman, or in Latin Arminius. There is also feminine form of this name Irmina, see Irmina of Oeren 92.196.58.240 ( talk) 21:48, 3 March 2013 (UTC)
i was keen to get a short description of what was believed to be the function, the nature of this magical object and somehow i could not find an answer for this in the article. it does tell things in a nice encyclopedical style about the history of research and thinking about the topic from later ages, but really seems not to touch the core of what is an (or the) irminsul for the german pagan tribes who built or worshipped them. the above "rework" discussion is a lot more informative than the article itself (though its discussion form is obvoiously would not make it fit for the article page), but even that discussion did not get me the answer. (what i was lookinf for is something like e.g. in the atticle about Odin you find somewhere that he was a god of something and was believed to have some powers/fields of influence, etc. this kind of simple short description of irminsul is what i miss here.) 89.134.199.32 ( talk) 21:32, 15 February 2020 (UTC).