GA toolbox |
---|
Reviewing |
Article (
|
visual edit |
history) ·
Article talk (
|
history) ·
Watch
Reviewer: Thebiguglyalien ( talk · contribs) 22:39, 3 June 2023 (UTC)
I'll begin the review for this article. Expect me to post the initial review some time in the next day or two. Thebiguglyalien ( talk) 22:39, 3 June 2023 (UTC)
in computer science in the same school– Might be better to say "at the same school".
her cousin Catalino Diaz who is also– "who was also"
Elementary students not enrolled in UZ were able to train under the program by Institute of Human Kinetics director Elbert Atilano.– This is a little confusing as it's written.
She had to do part-time work; selling vegetables and fish and washing jeepneys to fund her transportation to a local gymnasium.– This sentence runs on a bit and doesn't need a semicolon.
Diaz first competition– Is this supposed to be possessive?
breaking the Philippine record that she herself set at the 2007 Southeast Asian Games– Why is this the first time this is mentioned?
her performance was praised and considered promising for her age– Praised and considered promising by whom? Just the sports commission chairman?
Come 2012 Olympics,– Grammar
as she recently snatched the gold medal– "snatched" is informal. Also, it should be "had recently" instead of "recently" so we know that it was recent back then as opposed to today.
The same mark is good for 4th place in the 2012 London Olympics.– What does this mean?
Diaz copped a gold medal– "copped" is informal.
and was welcomed as a Hero of the city– Why is Hero capitalized?
by lifting 127 kg in the Clean and Jerk– Why is this italicized in just this one instance?
Diaz's achievements at the 2020 Summer Olympics were remarkable– We don't call things "remarkable" on Wikipedia.
where they have been living in a house– This should be past tense: have -> had
Diaz also fought mental breakdown during her ordeal– "Mental breakdown" is very strong language, likely stronger than is needed here.
On May 20, 2022, Olympic champion Hidilyn Diaz– We don't need to call her "Olympic champion Hidilyn Diaz".
at St. Ignatius Church in the Philippine Military Academy grounds– Should it be "on" the grounds instead of "in" the grounds?
after she clinched the country's first Olympic gold medal– "clinched" is informal.
Diaz first met with Naranjo at the 2017 Asian Indoor and Martial Arts Games.– This should be in chronological order. It's currently the last sentence in the paragraph.
Source spotchecks to ensure that content is accurate and that the text is not a copyright violation:
Mostly covers her life and her accomplishments in a reasonable amount of detail. Only one minor issue:
It aired a rerun on July 31, 2021– A program airing as a rerun is not significant.
Only a few minor wording issues, but I've mentioned those above.
No recent content disputes in the edit history or the talk page.
All images are public domain. Captions are suitable.
GA toolbox |
---|
Reviewing |
Article (
|
visual edit |
history) ·
Article talk (
|
history) ·
Watch
Reviewer: Thebiguglyalien ( talk · contribs) 22:39, 3 June 2023 (UTC)
I'll begin the review for this article. Expect me to post the initial review some time in the next day or two. Thebiguglyalien ( talk) 22:39, 3 June 2023 (UTC)
in computer science in the same school– Might be better to say "at the same school".
her cousin Catalino Diaz who is also– "who was also"
Elementary students not enrolled in UZ were able to train under the program by Institute of Human Kinetics director Elbert Atilano.– This is a little confusing as it's written.
She had to do part-time work; selling vegetables and fish and washing jeepneys to fund her transportation to a local gymnasium.– This sentence runs on a bit and doesn't need a semicolon.
Diaz first competition– Is this supposed to be possessive?
breaking the Philippine record that she herself set at the 2007 Southeast Asian Games– Why is this the first time this is mentioned?
her performance was praised and considered promising for her age– Praised and considered promising by whom? Just the sports commission chairman?
Come 2012 Olympics,– Grammar
as she recently snatched the gold medal– "snatched" is informal. Also, it should be "had recently" instead of "recently" so we know that it was recent back then as opposed to today.
The same mark is good for 4th place in the 2012 London Olympics.– What does this mean?
Diaz copped a gold medal– "copped" is informal.
and was welcomed as a Hero of the city– Why is Hero capitalized?
by lifting 127 kg in the Clean and Jerk– Why is this italicized in just this one instance?
Diaz's achievements at the 2020 Summer Olympics were remarkable– We don't call things "remarkable" on Wikipedia.
where they have been living in a house– This should be past tense: have -> had
Diaz also fought mental breakdown during her ordeal– "Mental breakdown" is very strong language, likely stronger than is needed here.
On May 20, 2022, Olympic champion Hidilyn Diaz– We don't need to call her "Olympic champion Hidilyn Diaz".
at St. Ignatius Church in the Philippine Military Academy grounds– Should it be "on" the grounds instead of "in" the grounds?
after she clinched the country's first Olympic gold medal– "clinched" is informal.
Diaz first met with Naranjo at the 2017 Asian Indoor and Martial Arts Games.– This should be in chronological order. It's currently the last sentence in the paragraph.
Source spotchecks to ensure that content is accurate and that the text is not a copyright violation:
Mostly covers her life and her accomplishments in a reasonable amount of detail. Only one minor issue:
It aired a rerun on July 31, 2021– A program airing as a rerun is not significant.
Only a few minor wording issues, but I've mentioned those above.
No recent content disputes in the edit history or the talk page.
All images are public domain. Captions are suitable.