Reference 2 is a dead link; it loops to a blank page on archive.org (which loops blank)
My sense is that English readers are going to be unfamiliar with the concept of fado. It may be useful to include a short explanation in the lede.
An overall read is that the lede might include a summary from Television, modelling and commercial appearances, Personal life and her volunteering. As one gets into the article in depth, a much stronger sense of her notability becomes apparent. So the lede might be expanded a bit.
Reference 30 is a dead link and goes to a blank page on archive.org
Reference 54 goves 'not found'.
Lots of research, lots of checking on archive.org. Good work for a first GA submission!
Can we go over these issues? --
Whiteguru (
talk) 09:50, 5 March 2021 (UTC)reply
Hi
Whiteguru, thanks again for the review and your encouraging words! See my responses below:
Reference 2 is a dead link; it loops to a blank page on archive.org (which loops blank)
I did see the blank page but the page came up after refreshing my browser. I changed the archived version to archive.vn, which hopefully works better. Y
My sense is that English readers are going to be unfamiliar with the concept of fado. It may be useful to include a short explanation in the lede.
Added. Y
An overall read is that the lede might include a summary from Television, modelling and commercial appearances, Personal life and her volunteering. As one gets into the article in depth, a much stronger sense of her notability becomes apparent. So the lede might be expanded a bit.
Expanded lede.
This reads much better, now. Y
Reference 30 is a dead link and goes to a blank page on archive.org
I see that reference 30 goes to her IMDb page, and the link worked fine. I did change the archive to archive.vn since that seems to work better. However, I also checked reference 29 (about the Grand Prix) and that was broken so changed to a different link. Maybe you were referring to that one? (Yes)
Works now with the redirect. Y
Reference 54 gives 'not found'.
Also did not see an issue with that link, not sure why. Of course I can change it if it's unreliable. Is that the last reference in the paragraph, about the Porto hospital concert?
Works now with the redirect. Y
Additional notes: After another copyediting pass I changed a few small things for example removed italization from Clube de Fado since it is the proper name of a venue. Y
Reference 2 is a dead link; it loops to a blank page on archive.org (which loops blank)
My sense is that English readers are going to be unfamiliar with the concept of fado. It may be useful to include a short explanation in the lede.
An overall read is that the lede might include a summary from Television, modelling and commercial appearances, Personal life and her volunteering. As one gets into the article in depth, a much stronger sense of her notability becomes apparent. So the lede might be expanded a bit.
Reference 30 is a dead link and goes to a blank page on archive.org
Reference 54 goves 'not found'.
Lots of research, lots of checking on archive.org. Good work for a first GA submission!
Can we go over these issues? --
Whiteguru (
talk) 09:50, 5 March 2021 (UTC)reply
Hi
Whiteguru, thanks again for the review and your encouraging words! See my responses below:
Reference 2 is a dead link; it loops to a blank page on archive.org (which loops blank)
I did see the blank page but the page came up after refreshing my browser. I changed the archived version to archive.vn, which hopefully works better. Y
My sense is that English readers are going to be unfamiliar with the concept of fado. It may be useful to include a short explanation in the lede.
Added. Y
An overall read is that the lede might include a summary from Television, modelling and commercial appearances, Personal life and her volunteering. As one gets into the article in depth, a much stronger sense of her notability becomes apparent. So the lede might be expanded a bit.
Expanded lede.
This reads much better, now. Y
Reference 30 is a dead link and goes to a blank page on archive.org
I see that reference 30 goes to her IMDb page, and the link worked fine. I did change the archive to archive.vn since that seems to work better. However, I also checked reference 29 (about the Grand Prix) and that was broken so changed to a different link. Maybe you were referring to that one? (Yes)
Works now with the redirect. Y
Reference 54 gives 'not found'.
Also did not see an issue with that link, not sure why. Of course I can change it if it's unreliable. Is that the last reference in the paragraph, about the Porto hospital concert?
Works now with the redirect. Y
Additional notes: After another copyediting pass I changed a few small things for example removed italization from Clube de Fado since it is the proper name of a venue. Y