From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
(Redirected from Talk:Šulin)

Name

I'm finding it hard to believe that Šulin is the official name although I read the source which appears to give a renamed list from Albanian into Macedonian. I don't know very much Albanian but I take it the information on the article is correct. To my knowledge, Macedonian is an official language in Albania but not with the same status as Albanian, so there must be compulsory education in Albanian in schools just as signs are sure to be bilingual. In addition, even if the Republic of Albania adopted the Macedonian name, it would have had to go through a process of Albanianisation for orthographical reasons, thus Macedonian "Š" is Albanian "Sh" (producing Shulin). So I question whether this article should be at this location and not Diellas. -- Oranges Juicy ( talk) 11:40, 2 February 2015 (UTC) reply

You're right, it should be at Shulin. I can make the move. -- Local hero talk 14:29, 4 February 2015 (UTC) reply
Thanks Local Hero, now the whole situation makes more sense, both here and for Pustec. When you stated some time back that you would be shifting a handful of Albanian settlements to their Macedonian titles based on official recognition, what you actually meant to say was that Albanian itself had changed to adopt the Macedonian names in place of its traditional names (even if those Albanian names continued among the Albanian local communities). The name Shulin is compatible for that language. At the moment we have work to do, Shulin already directs to Shulin District (Taiwan) and I see a Sulin also exists with nothing citing the Albanian settlement. Meanwhile, I will withdraw the move request at Pustec. -- Oranges Juicy ( talk) 13:05, 9 February 2015 (UTC) reply
I've placed a hatnote at Shulin District. I think everything is now taken care of. Thanks. -- Local hero talk 15:19, 9 February 2015 (UTC) reply
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
(Redirected from Talk:Šulin)

Name

I'm finding it hard to believe that Šulin is the official name although I read the source which appears to give a renamed list from Albanian into Macedonian. I don't know very much Albanian but I take it the information on the article is correct. To my knowledge, Macedonian is an official language in Albania but not with the same status as Albanian, so there must be compulsory education in Albanian in schools just as signs are sure to be bilingual. In addition, even if the Republic of Albania adopted the Macedonian name, it would have had to go through a process of Albanianisation for orthographical reasons, thus Macedonian "Š" is Albanian "Sh" (producing Shulin). So I question whether this article should be at this location and not Diellas. -- Oranges Juicy ( talk) 11:40, 2 February 2015 (UTC) reply

You're right, it should be at Shulin. I can make the move. -- Local hero talk 14:29, 4 February 2015 (UTC) reply
Thanks Local Hero, now the whole situation makes more sense, both here and for Pustec. When you stated some time back that you would be shifting a handful of Albanian settlements to their Macedonian titles based on official recognition, what you actually meant to say was that Albanian itself had changed to adopt the Macedonian names in place of its traditional names (even if those Albanian names continued among the Albanian local communities). The name Shulin is compatible for that language. At the moment we have work to do, Shulin already directs to Shulin District (Taiwan) and I see a Sulin also exists with nothing citing the Albanian settlement. Meanwhile, I will withdraw the move request at Pustec. -- Oranges Juicy ( talk) 13:05, 9 February 2015 (UTC) reply
I've placed a hatnote at Shulin District. I think everything is now taken care of. Thanks. -- Local hero talk 15:19, 9 February 2015 (UTC) reply

Videos

Youtube | Vimeo | Bing

Websites

Google | Yahoo | Bing

Encyclopedia

Google | Yahoo | Bing

Facebook