From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Comments

Hello User:Vegaswikian I believe this book is a notable addition to Wikipedia for the following reasons:

1. Tristram Stuart is already an uncontested article, in which this book is mentioned so in a sense this is simply completing his entry with details about his work.

2. This book by exact title search (see example)

3. The book has been entered in the library of congress (USA)

4. It is entered in a number of public and collegiate libraries as well as the Library Journal which to quote them "In its 133rd year of publication, Library Journal is the oldest and most respected publication covering the library field. Considered to be the “bible” of the library world, LJ is read by over 100,000 library directors, administrators, and staff in public, academic, and special libraries."

  
PA Libraries
  
Champlain College VT
  
San Diego State University
  
Library Thing
  
Encyclopedia.com
  
Florida Atlantic University
  
Stanford University
  
National Library of Austrailia
  
Stevens County Rural Library District, WA
  

5. The book rates notice in Wikipedia and other encyclopedias:

  
Joseph Ritson (other reading)
  
Tristram Stuart
  
New World Encyclopedia
  
Randolph Community College


6. It was on the New York Times - Bestseller list (source) which indicates a broad interest and notability in (USA) society.

I appreciate the attempt to ensure notability, with this additional information I hope you will agree that the article deserves to stay.

Regards,

Armistral

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Comments

Hello User:Vegaswikian I believe this book is a notable addition to Wikipedia for the following reasons:

1. Tristram Stuart is already an uncontested article, in which this book is mentioned so in a sense this is simply completing his entry with details about his work.

2. This book by exact title search (see example)

3. The book has been entered in the library of congress (USA)

4. It is entered in a number of public and collegiate libraries as well as the Library Journal which to quote them "In its 133rd year of publication, Library Journal is the oldest and most respected publication covering the library field. Considered to be the “bible” of the library world, LJ is read by over 100,000 library directors, administrators, and staff in public, academic, and special libraries."

  
PA Libraries
  
Champlain College VT
  
San Diego State University
  
Library Thing
  
Encyclopedia.com
  
Florida Atlantic University
  
Stanford University
  
National Library of Austrailia
  
Stevens County Rural Library District, WA
  

5. The book rates notice in Wikipedia and other encyclopedias:

  
Joseph Ritson (other reading)
  
Tristram Stuart
  
New World Encyclopedia
  
Randolph Community College


6. It was on the New York Times - Bestseller list (source) which indicates a broad interest and notability in (USA) society.

I appreciate the attempt to ensure notability, with this additional information I hope you will agree that the article deserves to stay.

Regards,

Armistral


Videos

Youtube | Vimeo | Bing

Websites

Google | Yahoo | Bing

Encyclopedia

Google | Yahoo | Bing

Facebook