![]() | This article is rated Start-class on Wikipedia's
content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | ||||||||||
|
The result of the move request was: moved. —usernamekiran (talk) 22:29, 5 September 2020 (UTC)
Piranhas →
Piranhas, Alagoas – Per
WP:ASTONISH and
WP:PLURALPT clearly if there was a primary topic it would be the animal (which this place appears to be named after) per
WP:PRIMARYREDIRECT. The place in Alagoas gets 282 views but
Piranhas (2019 film) has 1,166,
Piranhas (baseball) has 31,
Piranhas, Goiás has 7,
The Piranhas has 563 and the animal has a staggering 33,656[
[1]]. Google, Images and Books only show results for the animal. There appear to be other places in Brazil called "
Piranhas". See similar cases like
Bones,
Bookends,
Cars,
Cats,
Parachutes and
Pixies which no only does the specific meanings not take precedence, the general meanings do. In the category namespace at
Category:Piranhas where its convention to use the plural and not the singular the animal is at the base name and this article was accidentally
added to it. I would also note that its on
User:Certes/misdirected links#Examples because there were
18 errors. In summary the place in Alagoas is clearly not the primary topic by usage given the film gets over 4x the views and the animal gets over 119x the views in addition to the group getting around double the views (despite the benefit of being at the base name). By long-term significance the animal (which is a level 4 vital article) is clearly the primary topic if anything but its blatantly clear that this place isn't the primary topic. Yes this article has been stable since its creation in 2004 but per
WP:UNCHALLENGED this isn't a strong reason to keep it as is when there's clear evidence that this is vastly inappropriate. Note that even ptwiki redirects
pt:Piranhas to the animal so it would seem odd that the English Wikipedia doesn't. Per
Wikipedia:Naming conventions (geographic names)#Brazil the state disambiguator is correct and
Piranhas, Goiás is also in Brazil as well. Either "Piranhas" should be a
WP:PRIMARYREDIRECT to the animal or it should redirect to
Piranha (disambiguation) per
WP:DABCOMBINE or be a separate DAB page.
Crouch, Swale (
talk)
21:34, 29 August 2020 (UTC)
![]() | This article is rated Start-class on Wikipedia's
content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | ||||||||||
|
The result of the move request was: moved. —usernamekiran (talk) 22:29, 5 September 2020 (UTC)
Piranhas →
Piranhas, Alagoas – Per
WP:ASTONISH and
WP:PLURALPT clearly if there was a primary topic it would be the animal (which this place appears to be named after) per
WP:PRIMARYREDIRECT. The place in Alagoas gets 282 views but
Piranhas (2019 film) has 1,166,
Piranhas (baseball) has 31,
Piranhas, Goiás has 7,
The Piranhas has 563 and the animal has a staggering 33,656[
[1]]. Google, Images and Books only show results for the animal. There appear to be other places in Brazil called "
Piranhas". See similar cases like
Bones,
Bookends,
Cars,
Cats,
Parachutes and
Pixies which no only does the specific meanings not take precedence, the general meanings do. In the category namespace at
Category:Piranhas where its convention to use the plural and not the singular the animal is at the base name and this article was accidentally
added to it. I would also note that its on
User:Certes/misdirected links#Examples because there were
18 errors. In summary the place in Alagoas is clearly not the primary topic by usage given the film gets over 4x the views and the animal gets over 119x the views in addition to the group getting around double the views (despite the benefit of being at the base name). By long-term significance the animal (which is a level 4 vital article) is clearly the primary topic if anything but its blatantly clear that this place isn't the primary topic. Yes this article has been stable since its creation in 2004 but per
WP:UNCHALLENGED this isn't a strong reason to keep it as is when there's clear evidence that this is vastly inappropriate. Note that even ptwiki redirects
pt:Piranhas to the animal so it would seem odd that the English Wikipedia doesn't. Per
Wikipedia:Naming conventions (geographic names)#Brazil the state disambiguator is correct and
Piranhas, Goiás is also in Brazil as well. Either "Piranhas" should be a
WP:PRIMARYREDIRECT to the animal or it should redirect to
Piranha (disambiguation) per
WP:DABCOMBINE or be a separate DAB page.
Crouch, Swale (
talk)
21:34, 29 August 2020 (UTC)