Article (
|
visual edit |
history) ·
Article talk (
|
history) ·
Watch
OK, I'll be stepping though the Good Article criteria in reverse order (I find them easier that way!). I hope to finish this tonight, if not it may take me a couple of days. Here goes:
Images: Pass - One image showing the car, with suitable licensing. However, I would recommend getting a couple of others from Flickr or another source. Perhaps to illustrate one of the engine installations (the guy who took the photograph you have used has pics of one with the Ford engine), or if you're lucky the chassis construction.
Stable: Pass - very few edits in recent history.
Neutral: Pass - no cheerleading or dubious opinions evident. I'm familiar with the problem, but I strongly recommend finding a way to refer to Bruce McLaren as 'McLaren' - it can probably be done without confusing him with the team and avoids the appearance of over-familiarity. (I think we've achieved the equivalent trick in the Brabham BT19 article).
Broad coverage: On hold - covers most things I would expect to see. However...
Factually accurate and verifiable: Pass Appears thoroughly referenced to high quality sources, and content matches what I can find in the sources I have access to.
Well-written: On hold Basically fine, but some minor points I'd like to see cleared up.
Overall: On hold Nothing major, but some minor tweaks. Is a week long enough to address these? Let me know if you need longer. Cheers. Reviewer: 4u1e ( talk) 21:36, 24 June 2010 (UTC)
Article (
|
visual edit |
history) ·
Article talk (
|
history) ·
Watch
OK, I'll be stepping though the Good Article criteria in reverse order (I find them easier that way!). I hope to finish this tonight, if not it may take me a couple of days. Here goes:
Images: Pass - One image showing the car, with suitable licensing. However, I would recommend getting a couple of others from Flickr or another source. Perhaps to illustrate one of the engine installations (the guy who took the photograph you have used has pics of one with the Ford engine), or if you're lucky the chassis construction.
Stable: Pass - very few edits in recent history.
Neutral: Pass - no cheerleading or dubious opinions evident. I'm familiar with the problem, but I strongly recommend finding a way to refer to Bruce McLaren as 'McLaren' - it can probably be done without confusing him with the team and avoids the appearance of over-familiarity. (I think we've achieved the equivalent trick in the Brabham BT19 article).
Broad coverage: On hold - covers most things I would expect to see. However...
Factually accurate and verifiable: Pass Appears thoroughly referenced to high quality sources, and content matches what I can find in the sources I have access to.
Well-written: On hold Basically fine, but some minor points I'd like to see cleared up.
Overall: On hold Nothing major, but some minor tweaks. Is a week long enough to address these? Let me know if you need longer. Cheers. Reviewer: 4u1e ( talk) 21:36, 24 June 2010 (UTC)