 | This redirect does not require a rating on Wikipedia's
content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | ||||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||||
@ MoonlightTulsi, Nick.mon, Facquis, Autospark, Braganza, Checco, and Scia Della Cometa: This article is in a terrible state, and not because it was just created. I think it's of the idea of it:Senatori della XVIII legislatura della Repubblica Italiana on the Italian Wikipedia (somethings might have been copy-pasted from there), however it has some important problems. (1) The title of the article is not good: the dash at the end is not good formatting, and also obscure: the article must be moved to another title (I propose List of current members of the Italian Senate or List of members of the Italian Senate (XVIII legislature) or like in Italian Members of the XVIII legislature of Italy and then have also the Deputies in the same article); (2) the article editing somehow got broken: I cannot access the "edit section" from each of the sections for example for some reason; I think it's related to some big mistake in formatting somewhere that broke the wiki code; (3) each party is treated in a different way: for some parties the presidents and vice presidents are listed, for others not, for others some comments have been even left in Italian... I would honestly suggest for article deletion, since I don't even see the purpose of an article like this one. An article like this is also of very difficult maintenance. However I would wait for comments from other editors. If we want to keep it then we need a more general strategy (also for the Chamber of Deputies, and probably using tables instead of plain lists), and we need to decide whether to do it only for the "current" senators or also for each legislature. -- Ritchie92 ( talk) 08:38, 8 January 2020 (UTC)
I think the article is an important one so definitely keep. The other lists in the series are: List of members of the Italian Senate, 1987–1992 List of members of the Italian Senate, 1992–1994 List of members of the Italian Senate, 1994–1996 List of members of the Italian Senate, 1996–2001 List of members of the Italian Senate, 2001–2006 List of members of the Italian Senate, 2006–2008 List of members of the Italian Senate, 2008–2013 List of members of the Italian Senate, 2013–2018, ( MoonlightTulsi) ( talk) 21:07, 08 January 2020
I agree that, if the article is not regularly maintained, it should be deleted. -- Checco ( talk) 09:14, 11 January 2020 (UTC)
|
| This redirect does not require a rating on Wikipedia's
content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | ||||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||||
@ MoonlightTulsi, Nick.mon, Facquis, Autospark, Braganza, Checco, and Scia Della Cometa: This article is in a terrible state, and not because it was just created. I think it's of the idea of it:Senatori della XVIII legislatura della Repubblica Italiana on the Italian Wikipedia (somethings might have been copy-pasted from there), however it has some important problems. (1) The title of the article is not good: the dash at the end is not good formatting, and also obscure: the article must be moved to another title (I propose List of current members of the Italian Senate or List of members of the Italian Senate (XVIII legislature) or like in Italian Members of the XVIII legislature of Italy and then have also the Deputies in the same article); (2) the article editing somehow got broken: I cannot access the "edit section" from each of the sections for example for some reason; I think it's related to some big mistake in formatting somewhere that broke the wiki code; (3) each party is treated in a different way: for some parties the presidents and vice presidents are listed, for others not, for others some comments have been even left in Italian... I would honestly suggest for article deletion, since I don't even see the purpose of an article like this one. An article like this is also of very difficult maintenance. However I would wait for comments from other editors. If we want to keep it then we need a more general strategy (also for the Chamber of Deputies, and probably using tables instead of plain lists), and we need to decide whether to do it only for the "current" senators or also for each legislature. -- Ritchie92 ( talk) 08:38, 8 January 2020 (UTC)
I think the article is an important one so definitely keep. The other lists in the series are: List of members of the Italian Senate, 1987–1992 List of members of the Italian Senate, 1992–1994 List of members of the Italian Senate, 1994–1996 List of members of the Italian Senate, 1996–2001 List of members of the Italian Senate, 2001–2006 List of members of the Italian Senate, 2006–2008 List of members of the Italian Senate, 2008–2013 List of members of the Italian Senate, 2013–2018, ( MoonlightTulsi) ( talk) 21:07, 08 January 2020
I agree that, if the article is not regularly maintained, it should be deleted. -- Checco ( talk) 09:14, 11 January 2020 (UTC)