![]() | This article is rated Stub-class on Wikipedia's
content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
![]() | This article contains a translation of Kaiserslautern Hauptbahnhof from de.wikipedia. |
The result of the move request was: Move all. EdJohnston ( talk) 01:13, 6 September 2013 (UTC)
{{
requested move/dated}}
– reverting 121 undiscussed controversial moves per WP:COMMONNAME, WP:RS, and see Talk:Berlin Hauptbahnhof, Talk:Zürich Hauptbahnhof. The 14 the template allows represent the first 14, in move order, of 121 undiscussed moves. The RM is to restore all 121. The main issue in previous RMs was whether/how to exclude results like "Berlin's central station" (apostrophe 's small c, small s) from results X Central Station indicating a proper noun or a proper name. When "X's central station" "X's main railway station" are excluded evidence for "Central Station" is thin or non-existent depending on total number of sources. Kaiserslautern Hauptbahnhof is a case in point. The only English print source Fuller's Fans Guide to German Stadiums 2005 has "Out of the three, Frankfurt Main offers a direct connection to Kaiserslautern Hauptbahnhof at least once an hour and a further train with a connection in Mannheim also once an hour." It is also noted that "Haupt" doesn't mean "central", but "head" and is usually translated "Haupt/main Bahn/railway Hof/station" not "central station." Relisted as requested below. Favonian ( talk) 20:16, 27 August 2013 (UTC). In ictu oculi ( talk) 05:11, 20 August 2013 (UTC)
Questions: Why have the above 14 been selected and not the most important (i.e. Category 1) Hauptbahnhöfe as we discussed? Why have you mentioned Talk:Zürich Hauptbahnhof which is not in Germany, but omitted the move discussions that went in favour of "Central Station" at Talk:Nuremberg Central Station and Talk:Leipzig Central Station? -- Bermicourt ( talk) 06:13, 20 August 2013 (UTC)
Done:
Talk:Witten Hauptbahnhof Talk:Trier Hauptbahnhof Talk:Winterthur Hauptbahnhof Talk:St. Pölten Hauptbahnhof Talk:Düsseldorf Hauptbahnhof Talk:Landau (Pfalz) Hauptbahnhof Talk:Ludwigshafen (Rhein) Hauptbahnhof Talk:Mülheim (Ruhr) Hauptbahnhof Talk:Kempten (Allgäu) Hauptbahnhof Talk:Bingen (Rhein) Hauptbahnhof Talk:Frankfurt (Main) Hauptbahnhof underground Talk:Frankfurt (Main) Hauptbahnhof Talk:Homburg (Saar) Hauptbahnhof Talk:Halle (Saale) Hauptbahnhof Talk:Neustadt (Weinstraße) Hauptbahnhof Talk:Offenbach (Main) Hauptbahnhof Talk:Stolberg (Rheinland) Hauptbahnhof Talk:Münster Hauptbahnhof Talk:Mönchengladbach Hauptbahnhof Talk:Köln Hauptbahnhof Talk:Osnabrück Hauptbahnhof Talk:Saarbrücken Hauptbahnhof Talk:Tübingen Hauptbahnhof Talk:Würzburg Hauptbahnhof Talk:Lünen Hauptbahnhof Talk:Lübeck Hauptbahnhof Talk:Döbeln Hauptbahnhof Talk:Gütersloh Hauptbahnhof Talk:Fürth Hauptbahnhof Talk:Wörgl Hauptbahnhof Talk:Wiener Neustadt Hauptbahnhof Talk:Wien Hauptbahnhof Talk:Wels Hauptbahnhof Talk:Villach Hauptbahnhof Talk:Salzburg Hauptbahnhof Talk:Linz Hauptbahnhof Talk:Leoben Hauptbahnhof Talk:Klagenfurt Hauptbahnhof Talk:Innsbruck Hauptbahnhof Talk:Graz Hauptbahnhof Talk:Koblenz Hauptbahnhof Talk:Oldenburg (Oldenburg) Hauptbahnhof Talk:Lindau Hauptbahnhof Talk:Gevelsberg Hauptbahnhof Talk:Neuss Hauptbahnhof Talk:Wanne-Eickel Hauptbahnhof Talk:Wiesbaden Hauptbahnhof Talk:Wittlich Hauptbahnhof Talk:Wolfsburg Hauptbahnhof Talk:Worms Hauptbahnhof Talk:Wuppertal Hauptbahnhof Talk:Zwickau Hauptbahnhof Talk:Stralsund Hauptbahnhof Talk:Remscheid Hauptbahnhof Talk:Schweinfurt Hauptbahnhof Talk:Schwerin Hauptbahnhof Talk:Hagen Hauptbahnhof Talk:Hof Hauptbahnhof Talk:Solingen Hauptbahnhof Stuttgart Hauptbahnhof Sonneberg Hauptbahnhof Talk:Pforzheim Hauptbahnhof Talk:Neustrelitz Hauptbahnhof Talk:Mannheim Hauptbahnhof Talk:Rheydt Hauptbahnhof Talk:Krefeld Hauptbahnhof Talk:Paderborn Hauptbahnhof Talk:Ulm Hauptbahnhof Talk:Ingolstadt Hauptbahnhof Talk:Oberhausen Hauptbahnhof Talk:Speyer Hauptbahnhof Talk:Recklinghausen Hauptbahnhof Talk:Mainz Hauptbahnhof Talk:Passau Hauptbahnhof Talk:Kiel Hauptbahnhof Talk:Gelsenkirchen Hauptbahnhof Talk:Freudenstadt Hauptbahnhof Talk:Hildesheim Hauptbahnhof Talk:Freiburg Hauptbahnhof Talk:Frankenthal Hauptbahnhof Talk:Essen Hauptbahnhof Talk:Heilbronn Hauptbahnhof Talk:Eschweiler Hauptbahnhof Talk:Erfurt Hauptbahnhof Talk:Emden Hauptbahnhof Talk:Magdeburg Hauptbahnhof Talk:Heidelberg Hauptbahnhof Talk:Hanau Hauptbahnhof Talk:Hamburg Hauptbahnhof Talk:Karlsruhe Hauptbahnhof Talk:Eberswalde Hauptbahnhof Talk:Kassel Hauptbahnhof Talk:Dortmund Hauptbahnhof Talk:Duisburg Hauptbahnhof Talk:Dessau Hauptbahnhof Talk:Aachen Hauptbahnhof Talk:Darmstadt Hauptbahnhof Talk:Chemnitz Hauptbahnhof Talk:Castrop-Rauxel Hauptbahnhof Talk:Bremerhaven Hauptbahnhof Talk:Bremen Hauptbahnhof Talk:Braunschweig Hauptbahnhof Talk:Brandenburg Hauptbahnhof Talk:Bottrop Hauptbahnhof
![]() | This article is rated Stub-class on Wikipedia's
content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
![]() | This article contains a translation of Kaiserslautern Hauptbahnhof from de.wikipedia. |
The result of the move request was: Move all. EdJohnston ( talk) 01:13, 6 September 2013 (UTC)
{{
requested move/dated}}
– reverting 121 undiscussed controversial moves per WP:COMMONNAME, WP:RS, and see Talk:Berlin Hauptbahnhof, Talk:Zürich Hauptbahnhof. The 14 the template allows represent the first 14, in move order, of 121 undiscussed moves. The RM is to restore all 121. The main issue in previous RMs was whether/how to exclude results like "Berlin's central station" (apostrophe 's small c, small s) from results X Central Station indicating a proper noun or a proper name. When "X's central station" "X's main railway station" are excluded evidence for "Central Station" is thin or non-existent depending on total number of sources. Kaiserslautern Hauptbahnhof is a case in point. The only English print source Fuller's Fans Guide to German Stadiums 2005 has "Out of the three, Frankfurt Main offers a direct connection to Kaiserslautern Hauptbahnhof at least once an hour and a further train with a connection in Mannheim also once an hour." It is also noted that "Haupt" doesn't mean "central", but "head" and is usually translated "Haupt/main Bahn/railway Hof/station" not "central station." Relisted as requested below. Favonian ( talk) 20:16, 27 August 2013 (UTC). In ictu oculi ( talk) 05:11, 20 August 2013 (UTC)
Questions: Why have the above 14 been selected and not the most important (i.e. Category 1) Hauptbahnhöfe as we discussed? Why have you mentioned Talk:Zürich Hauptbahnhof which is not in Germany, but omitted the move discussions that went in favour of "Central Station" at Talk:Nuremberg Central Station and Talk:Leipzig Central Station? -- Bermicourt ( talk) 06:13, 20 August 2013 (UTC)
Done:
Talk:Witten Hauptbahnhof Talk:Trier Hauptbahnhof Talk:Winterthur Hauptbahnhof Talk:St. Pölten Hauptbahnhof Talk:Düsseldorf Hauptbahnhof Talk:Landau (Pfalz) Hauptbahnhof Talk:Ludwigshafen (Rhein) Hauptbahnhof Talk:Mülheim (Ruhr) Hauptbahnhof Talk:Kempten (Allgäu) Hauptbahnhof Talk:Bingen (Rhein) Hauptbahnhof Talk:Frankfurt (Main) Hauptbahnhof underground Talk:Frankfurt (Main) Hauptbahnhof Talk:Homburg (Saar) Hauptbahnhof Talk:Halle (Saale) Hauptbahnhof Talk:Neustadt (Weinstraße) Hauptbahnhof Talk:Offenbach (Main) Hauptbahnhof Talk:Stolberg (Rheinland) Hauptbahnhof Talk:Münster Hauptbahnhof Talk:Mönchengladbach Hauptbahnhof Talk:Köln Hauptbahnhof Talk:Osnabrück Hauptbahnhof Talk:Saarbrücken Hauptbahnhof Talk:Tübingen Hauptbahnhof Talk:Würzburg Hauptbahnhof Talk:Lünen Hauptbahnhof Talk:Lübeck Hauptbahnhof Talk:Döbeln Hauptbahnhof Talk:Gütersloh Hauptbahnhof Talk:Fürth Hauptbahnhof Talk:Wörgl Hauptbahnhof Talk:Wiener Neustadt Hauptbahnhof Talk:Wien Hauptbahnhof Talk:Wels Hauptbahnhof Talk:Villach Hauptbahnhof Talk:Salzburg Hauptbahnhof Talk:Linz Hauptbahnhof Talk:Leoben Hauptbahnhof Talk:Klagenfurt Hauptbahnhof Talk:Innsbruck Hauptbahnhof Talk:Graz Hauptbahnhof Talk:Koblenz Hauptbahnhof Talk:Oldenburg (Oldenburg) Hauptbahnhof Talk:Lindau Hauptbahnhof Talk:Gevelsberg Hauptbahnhof Talk:Neuss Hauptbahnhof Talk:Wanne-Eickel Hauptbahnhof Talk:Wiesbaden Hauptbahnhof Talk:Wittlich Hauptbahnhof Talk:Wolfsburg Hauptbahnhof Talk:Worms Hauptbahnhof Talk:Wuppertal Hauptbahnhof Talk:Zwickau Hauptbahnhof Talk:Stralsund Hauptbahnhof Talk:Remscheid Hauptbahnhof Talk:Schweinfurt Hauptbahnhof Talk:Schwerin Hauptbahnhof Talk:Hagen Hauptbahnhof Talk:Hof Hauptbahnhof Talk:Solingen Hauptbahnhof Stuttgart Hauptbahnhof Sonneberg Hauptbahnhof Talk:Pforzheim Hauptbahnhof Talk:Neustrelitz Hauptbahnhof Talk:Mannheim Hauptbahnhof Talk:Rheydt Hauptbahnhof Talk:Krefeld Hauptbahnhof Talk:Paderborn Hauptbahnhof Talk:Ulm Hauptbahnhof Talk:Ingolstadt Hauptbahnhof Talk:Oberhausen Hauptbahnhof Talk:Speyer Hauptbahnhof Talk:Recklinghausen Hauptbahnhof Talk:Mainz Hauptbahnhof Talk:Passau Hauptbahnhof Talk:Kiel Hauptbahnhof Talk:Gelsenkirchen Hauptbahnhof Talk:Freudenstadt Hauptbahnhof Talk:Hildesheim Hauptbahnhof Talk:Freiburg Hauptbahnhof Talk:Frankenthal Hauptbahnhof Talk:Essen Hauptbahnhof Talk:Heilbronn Hauptbahnhof Talk:Eschweiler Hauptbahnhof Talk:Erfurt Hauptbahnhof Talk:Emden Hauptbahnhof Talk:Magdeburg Hauptbahnhof Talk:Heidelberg Hauptbahnhof Talk:Hanau Hauptbahnhof Talk:Hamburg Hauptbahnhof Talk:Karlsruhe Hauptbahnhof Talk:Eberswalde Hauptbahnhof Talk:Kassel Hauptbahnhof Talk:Dortmund Hauptbahnhof Talk:Duisburg Hauptbahnhof Talk:Dessau Hauptbahnhof Talk:Aachen Hauptbahnhof Talk:Darmstadt Hauptbahnhof Talk:Chemnitz Hauptbahnhof Talk:Castrop-Rauxel Hauptbahnhof Talk:Bremerhaven Hauptbahnhof Talk:Bremen Hauptbahnhof Talk:Braunschweig Hauptbahnhof Talk:Brandenburg Hauptbahnhof Talk:Bottrop Hauptbahnhof