Looking at the free-use rationale guidelines, it's clear that that template is optional and that a prose rationale is fine. Is there any specific information that is required that is missing from the current FUR on the page?
WesleyDodds (
talk)
06:16, 10 June 2011 (UTC)reply
The chord progression needs en-dash in between the chords
File:PixiesHereComesYourMan.ogg --> Not exactly happy with the FUR. You need to tighten it to reflect what exactly is being discussed that the sound file will assist the reader in understanding.
References: For the magazine references, you need to have more details, volume, issue, issn, location, oublisher etc.
They are not mandatory, but should be added where its available. ISSNs are easily available and I suggest you add them, it helps in locating the resource better. —
Legolas(talk2me)05:55, 10 June 2011 (UTC)reply
This information is not mandatory because the material cited is verifiable using the basic information provided (author, publication date, title, etc.). In the countless Feature Article Candidates and Review discussions I've participated in, it's been clear that this is all that's required for magazine article references.
WesleyDodds (
talk)
06:09, 10 June 2011 (UTC)reply
The reference is the primary source (the record itself), and cite templates aren't required (and they would be at odds with the established citation style of the article).
WesleyDodds (
talk)
04:58, 10 June 2011 (UTC)reply
I formatted two references using {{cite web}} and {{cite journal}}. I would advice you to use the templates, but take your call on it. I also corrected a redirect and there seems to no other issues at present. Passing this. —
Legolas(talk2me)12:28, 10 June 2011 (UTC)reply
Looking at the free-use rationale guidelines, it's clear that that template is optional and that a prose rationale is fine. Is there any specific information that is required that is missing from the current FUR on the page?
WesleyDodds (
talk)
06:16, 10 June 2011 (UTC)reply
The chord progression needs en-dash in between the chords
File:PixiesHereComesYourMan.ogg --> Not exactly happy with the FUR. You need to tighten it to reflect what exactly is being discussed that the sound file will assist the reader in understanding.
References: For the magazine references, you need to have more details, volume, issue, issn, location, oublisher etc.
They are not mandatory, but should be added where its available. ISSNs are easily available and I suggest you add them, it helps in locating the resource better. —
Legolas(talk2me)05:55, 10 June 2011 (UTC)reply
This information is not mandatory because the material cited is verifiable using the basic information provided (author, publication date, title, etc.). In the countless Feature Article Candidates and Review discussions I've participated in, it's been clear that this is all that's required for magazine article references.
WesleyDodds (
talk)
06:09, 10 June 2011 (UTC)reply
The reference is the primary source (the record itself), and cite templates aren't required (and they would be at odds with the established citation style of the article).
WesleyDodds (
talk)
04:58, 10 June 2011 (UTC)reply
I formatted two references using {{cite web}} and {{cite journal}}. I would advice you to use the templates, but take your call on it. I also corrected a redirect and there seems to no other issues at present. Passing this. —
Legolas(talk2me)12:28, 10 June 2011 (UTC)reply