This article is rated Start-class on Wikipedia's
content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | ||||||||
|
I have removed this recently added section . A series of cherry-picked, out of context positive quotes sourced solely to the composer's website are not appropriate on Wikipedia and are particularly inappropriate for a "critical response" section. The references must be to the original work, with full bibliographic information and where possible a link. Most importantly, the section needs to represent a balanced and accurate coverage of the critical response.
One example of why these out-of-context quotes are very misleading. The section stated:
What the NYT actually said in context was:
Hardly a "rave". And no, the opera was not the unqualified success suggested by the review snippets taken from Picker's website. Some reviews were mixed but reasonably positive, while others were quite negative, e.g. "Emmeline' Heavy-handed and Empty" by Marc Shugold of the Rocky Mountain News:
This article is rated Start-class on Wikipedia's
content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | ||||||||
|
I have removed this recently added section . A series of cherry-picked, out of context positive quotes sourced solely to the composer's website are not appropriate on Wikipedia and are particularly inappropriate for a "critical response" section. The references must be to the original work, with full bibliographic information and where possible a link. Most importantly, the section needs to represent a balanced and accurate coverage of the critical response.
One example of why these out-of-context quotes are very misleading. The section stated:
What the NYT actually said in context was:
Hardly a "rave". And no, the opera was not the unqualified success suggested by the review snippets taken from Picker's website. Some reviews were mixed but reasonably positive, while others were quite negative, e.g. "Emmeline' Heavy-handed and Empty" by Marc Shugold of the Rocky Mountain News: