![]() | This article was nominated for deletion on 3 June 2014 (UTC). The result of the discussion was merge to Community gardens in Nebraska. |
![]() | This redirect does not require a rating on Wikipedia's
content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | |||||||||||||||||||||||
|
There was a merger proposal here. The page was deleted?
I think that editor ScottHW believes that a list-article about the Omaha ones alone is a worthy topic, and is developing it. From afar, I preferred one list-article about all the community gardens in Nebraska. But, the Omaha ones alone meet Wikipedia-notability standards, as there is plenty of coverage about them, and if one editor wants to develop it that way, I say let 'em go at it.
I see no urgency to this merger proposal after a lot of editor attention has been applied to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dundee Community Garden . Let the interested editors do what they want for a while. Hopefully this Merger proposal will just die after a while. -- do ncr am 13:08, 27 May 2014 (UTC)
Wow... Apparently User:Pigsonthewing unilaterally decided to Merge this article, even though a discussion on that topic had just been started by User:doncram, and then repeated that Merge edit several more times when it was reverted. Poor form User:Pigsonthewing.
The reason an article on Community gardens in Omaha, Nebraska shouldn't be merged into Community gardens in Nebraska is because the community gardening effort in Omaha is entirely unique from the rest of the state. Nebraska is a heavily agricultural state; Omaha is the only incorporated city in the state that approaches "urban" characteristics (and possibly Lincoln, Nebraska). The activities of community gardening, and urban farming, as are on-going in Omaha, are not present through the rest of the state because there are no other urban areas.
Significant cooperation and interaction happens between gardens within Omaha e.g. Tour de Gardens, as referenced in the Dundee Community Garden article. Members of gardens actively work to help others founding new gardening and urban farming projects, fostering an entire community of community gardens... within Omaha. That is the focus of the List article that I started.
Additionally, the list of
Community gardens in Nebraska will be made up almost entirely of
Community gardens in Omaha, Nebraska; it is a mistake to broaden the category when a more narrow one would be more appropriate.
- - -
ScottHW (
talk)
18:00, 27 May 2014 (UTC) - - -
Editor Pigsonthewing has at several locations asked where a discussion is. This is the discussion he was looking for. And he has participated here already. -- do ncr am 15:52, 29 May 2014 (UTC)
A model for this article is List of community gardens in Portland, Oregon. -- do ncr am 13:08, 27 May 2014 (UTC)
![]() | This article was nominated for deletion on 3 June 2014 (UTC). The result of the discussion was merge to Community gardens in Nebraska. |
![]() | This redirect does not require a rating on Wikipedia's
content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | |||||||||||||||||||||||
|
There was a merger proposal here. The page was deleted?
I think that editor ScottHW believes that a list-article about the Omaha ones alone is a worthy topic, and is developing it. From afar, I preferred one list-article about all the community gardens in Nebraska. But, the Omaha ones alone meet Wikipedia-notability standards, as there is plenty of coverage about them, and if one editor wants to develop it that way, I say let 'em go at it.
I see no urgency to this merger proposal after a lot of editor attention has been applied to Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dundee Community Garden . Let the interested editors do what they want for a while. Hopefully this Merger proposal will just die after a while. -- do ncr am 13:08, 27 May 2014 (UTC)
Wow... Apparently User:Pigsonthewing unilaterally decided to Merge this article, even though a discussion on that topic had just been started by User:doncram, and then repeated that Merge edit several more times when it was reverted. Poor form User:Pigsonthewing.
The reason an article on Community gardens in Omaha, Nebraska shouldn't be merged into Community gardens in Nebraska is because the community gardening effort in Omaha is entirely unique from the rest of the state. Nebraska is a heavily agricultural state; Omaha is the only incorporated city in the state that approaches "urban" characteristics (and possibly Lincoln, Nebraska). The activities of community gardening, and urban farming, as are on-going in Omaha, are not present through the rest of the state because there are no other urban areas.
Significant cooperation and interaction happens between gardens within Omaha e.g. Tour de Gardens, as referenced in the Dundee Community Garden article. Members of gardens actively work to help others founding new gardening and urban farming projects, fostering an entire community of community gardens... within Omaha. That is the focus of the List article that I started.
Additionally, the list of
Community gardens in Nebraska will be made up almost entirely of
Community gardens in Omaha, Nebraska; it is a mistake to broaden the category when a more narrow one would be more appropriate.
- - -
ScottHW (
talk)
18:00, 27 May 2014 (UTC) - - -
Editor Pigsonthewing has at several locations asked where a discussion is. This is the discussion he was looking for. And he has participated here already. -- do ncr am 15:52, 29 May 2014 (UTC)
A model for this article is List of community gardens in Portland, Oregon. -- do ncr am 13:08, 27 May 2014 (UTC)