GA toolbox |
---|
Reviewing |
Article (
|
visual edit |
history) ·
Article talk (
|
history) ·
Watch
Reviewer: Mark83 ( talk · contribs) 17:07, 9 January 2022 (UTC)
I'll review over the next few days. Mark83 ( talk) 17:07, 9 January 2022 (UTC)
Ref # | Comments |
---|---|
1 | Company House Data – OK. |
2 | Concerns about WP:SIRS – an article largely based on interview with the owner and/or appears to be based on company marketing info. |
3 | Concerns about WP:SIRS – an article largely based on interview with the owner and/or appears to be based on company marketing info. |
4 | Concerns about WP:SIRS – an article largely based on interview with the owner and/or appears to be based on company marketing info. – The title and intro are hardly unbiased: “Yorkshire is the jewel in the UK's entrepreneurial crown; Throughout 2017, LDC is searching the entrepreneurial heartlands of England, Scotland and Wales as part of its Backing Business Ambition tour, to uncover and showcase Britain's most inspiring and ambitious businesses.” |
5 | OK. |
6 | Standard industry news article – OK. |
7 | Seems a bit more like straight news, but again concerning percentage of the article is direct quotes from the owner. May as well be self published. |
8 | “Source: Boost Drinks” |
9 | Standard industry news article – OK. Majority company quotes though. |
10 | OK. |
11 | “Source: Boost” – Purely marketing. |
12 | Very company marketing-focused. |
13 | Standard industry news article – OK. |
14 | Standard industry news article – OK. |
15 | Very company marketing-focused. ““Boost is a strong challenger brand within its sector and shares similar values to the Club, we are looking forward to working with and supporting Boost on the next phase of its brand growth both in the UK and Internationally.” NPOV? |
16 | Purely marketing – written by the company, copy & paste of 17 |
17 | Purely marketing – written by the company, copy & paste of 16 |
18 | Purely marketing |
19 | Purely marketing |
20 | Purely marketing |
21 | Staff writer, but very company marketing focused. Exactly the same format as those tagged “Source: Boost Drinks” |
22 | Staff writer, but very company marketing focused. Exactly the same format as those tagged “Source: Boost Drinks” |
23 | Source: Boost Drinks |
24 | RS? “Boost has created two great tasting SKUs, using exclusive production techniques to ensure a smooth tasting, quality product.” |
GA toolbox |
---|
Reviewing |
Article (
|
visual edit |
history) ·
Article talk (
|
history) ·
Watch
Reviewer: Mark83 ( talk · contribs) 17:07, 9 January 2022 (UTC)
I'll review over the next few days. Mark83 ( talk) 17:07, 9 January 2022 (UTC)
Ref # | Comments |
---|---|
1 | Company House Data – OK. |
2 | Concerns about WP:SIRS – an article largely based on interview with the owner and/or appears to be based on company marketing info. |
3 | Concerns about WP:SIRS – an article largely based on interview with the owner and/or appears to be based on company marketing info. |
4 | Concerns about WP:SIRS – an article largely based on interview with the owner and/or appears to be based on company marketing info. – The title and intro are hardly unbiased: “Yorkshire is the jewel in the UK's entrepreneurial crown; Throughout 2017, LDC is searching the entrepreneurial heartlands of England, Scotland and Wales as part of its Backing Business Ambition tour, to uncover and showcase Britain's most inspiring and ambitious businesses.” |
5 | OK. |
6 | Standard industry news article – OK. |
7 | Seems a bit more like straight news, but again concerning percentage of the article is direct quotes from the owner. May as well be self published. |
8 | “Source: Boost Drinks” |
9 | Standard industry news article – OK. Majority company quotes though. |
10 | OK. |
11 | “Source: Boost” – Purely marketing. |
12 | Very company marketing-focused. |
13 | Standard industry news article – OK. |
14 | Standard industry news article – OK. |
15 | Very company marketing-focused. ““Boost is a strong challenger brand within its sector and shares similar values to the Club, we are looking forward to working with and supporting Boost on the next phase of its brand growth both in the UK and Internationally.” NPOV? |
16 | Purely marketing – written by the company, copy & paste of 17 |
17 | Purely marketing – written by the company, copy & paste of 16 |
18 | Purely marketing |
19 | Purely marketing |
20 | Purely marketing |
21 | Staff writer, but very company marketing focused. Exactly the same format as those tagged “Source: Boost Drinks” |
22 | Staff writer, but very company marketing focused. Exactly the same format as those tagged “Source: Boost Drinks” |
23 | Source: Boost Drinks |
24 | RS? “Boost has created two great tasting SKUs, using exclusive production techniques to ensure a smooth tasting, quality product.” |