GA toolbox |
---|
Reviewing |
Article (
|
visual edit |
history) ·
Article talk (
|
history) ·
Watch
Reviewer: Lazman321 ( talk · contribs) 12:46, 26 May 2021 (UTC)
You have asked me to review one of your good article nominations in return for a review of my good article nomination of
Octogeddon. I will accept your request.
All of the required guidelines from the Manual of Style seem to have been followed. The lead summarizes the key aspects of the article. The layout is standard for a video game. There are no words to watch out for. It is clear that the plot section is fictional and only applies to this game. There are no lists. This article does ✓ Pass this criterion.
The easiest criterion to meet. This article does ✓ Pass this criterion.
All sources are either primary or reliable. All of the primary sources are used properly and are only used in the story and development sections. The only non-primary source that caught my attention was Planet Gameboy, mostly because I had never heard about it before and it does not have an article. Though it isn't listed in the reliable sources for video games list, it is most likely reliable due to it being owned by 4Players, which is considered reliable. This article does ✓ Pass this criterion.
With a copyvio score of 20.0%, this article does ✓ Pass this criterion.
This article does address the main aspects of Bionicle Heroes, including all the platforms that Bionicle Heroes is on, their differences, the development of Bionicle Heroes, and its reception. This article does ✓ Pass this criterion.
Never once does it stray off the intended topic. It always talks about Bionicle Heroes. This article does ✓ Pass this criterion.
All published opinions are clearly marked as such. They are either widespread opinions or attributed opinions. This article does ✓ Pass this criterion.
There has been no content dispute or edit war recently. This article does ✓ Pass this criterion.
All the images are tagged with valid fair-use rationales. This article does ✓ Pass this criterion.
All media is relevant to Bionicle Heroes. This article does ✓ Pass this criterion.
I am placing this review
On hold until problems are dealt with. Good luck.
Lazman321 (
talk)
14:01, 27 May 2021 (UTC)
GA toolbox |
---|
Reviewing |
Article (
|
visual edit |
history) ·
Article talk (
|
history) ·
Watch
Reviewer: Lazman321 ( talk · contribs) 12:46, 26 May 2021 (UTC)
You have asked me to review one of your good article nominations in return for a review of my good article nomination of
Octogeddon. I will accept your request.
All of the required guidelines from the Manual of Style seem to have been followed. The lead summarizes the key aspects of the article. The layout is standard for a video game. There are no words to watch out for. It is clear that the plot section is fictional and only applies to this game. There are no lists. This article does ✓ Pass this criterion.
The easiest criterion to meet. This article does ✓ Pass this criterion.
All sources are either primary or reliable. All of the primary sources are used properly and are only used in the story and development sections. The only non-primary source that caught my attention was Planet Gameboy, mostly because I had never heard about it before and it does not have an article. Though it isn't listed in the reliable sources for video games list, it is most likely reliable due to it being owned by 4Players, which is considered reliable. This article does ✓ Pass this criterion.
With a copyvio score of 20.0%, this article does ✓ Pass this criterion.
This article does address the main aspects of Bionicle Heroes, including all the platforms that Bionicle Heroes is on, their differences, the development of Bionicle Heroes, and its reception. This article does ✓ Pass this criterion.
Never once does it stray off the intended topic. It always talks about Bionicle Heroes. This article does ✓ Pass this criterion.
All published opinions are clearly marked as such. They are either widespread opinions or attributed opinions. This article does ✓ Pass this criterion.
There has been no content dispute or edit war recently. This article does ✓ Pass this criterion.
All the images are tagged with valid fair-use rationales. This article does ✓ Pass this criterion.
All media is relevant to Bionicle Heroes. This article does ✓ Pass this criterion.
I am placing this review
On hold until problems are dealt with. Good luck.
Lazman321 (
talk)
14:01, 27 May 2021 (UTC)