Article (
|
visual edit |
history) ·
Article talk (
|
history) ·
Watch
I will be undertaking this review. This article contains a lot of detail, and covers the full history of the band. Although it has strengths, it has a long way to go before meeting the standards for good article status, and i will effectively quick-fail it. If editor(s) believe they can respond to the issues below in a week, by all means ping me on my talk page and we can-reconsider, or take it to GAR, but my view is that it would be better to deal with the issues over time and re-nominate.
For examples of GAs on long-lived bands, see Hoodoo Gurus, Rage Against the Machine or The Beatles (though for my taste, the RATM article has too many direct quotes of band members).
As a fan of BB, all I can say is keep on improving this article, and I hope it'll come back to GA nominations one day! hamiltonstone ( talk) 04:28, 29 June 2009 (UTC)
A massive removal of content has taken out some very encyclopedic content. It needed better sourcing, but I don't see any indication that search took place. Some other changes were also made, and I don't have time to sort them all out, but here are the two version [1]. ChildofMidnight ( talk) 22:29, 9 August 2009 (UTC)
Article (
|
visual edit |
history) ·
Article talk (
|
history) ·
Watch
I will be undertaking this review. This article contains a lot of detail, and covers the full history of the band. Although it has strengths, it has a long way to go before meeting the standards for good article status, and i will effectively quick-fail it. If editor(s) believe they can respond to the issues below in a week, by all means ping me on my talk page and we can-reconsider, or take it to GAR, but my view is that it would be better to deal with the issues over time and re-nominate.
For examples of GAs on long-lived bands, see Hoodoo Gurus, Rage Against the Machine or The Beatles (though for my taste, the RATM article has too many direct quotes of band members).
As a fan of BB, all I can say is keep on improving this article, and I hope it'll come back to GA nominations one day! hamiltonstone ( talk) 04:28, 29 June 2009 (UTC)
A massive removal of content has taken out some very encyclopedic content. It needed better sourcing, but I don't see any indication that search took place. Some other changes were also made, and I don't have time to sort them all out, but here are the two version [1]. ChildofMidnight ( talk) 22:29, 9 August 2009 (UTC)