At the moment the article is going through an edit war
The accuracy of the article is disputed
Both these points while minor, fail the Good Article criteria. I have put this revierw on hold for seven days, to see if this can be resolved.
Jim Sweeney (
talk)
02:49, 26 November 2011 (UTC)reply
The accuracy of the article is NOT disputed. The accuracy of the name of the article is disputed. According to WP:COMMONNAME the name of this article should reflect the reliable references used to edit it, as it did when it was awarded a GA. But those who wish to dispute the guidelines in WP:COMMONNAME and put a consensus of personal opinions higher than relevant references, have taken over this article. It can't be a good article while it is called a battle. --
Rskp (
talk)
04:45, 26 November 2011 (UTC)reply
Without any further discussion the article with 'battle' in the title has been reinstated as a GA article despite an ongoing dispute regarding the name. How can that be?--
Rskp (
talk)
03:11, 27 November 2011 (UTC)reply
At the moment the article is going through an edit war
The accuracy of the article is disputed
Both these points while minor, fail the Good Article criteria. I have put this revierw on hold for seven days, to see if this can be resolved.
Jim Sweeney (
talk)
02:49, 26 November 2011 (UTC)reply
The accuracy of the article is NOT disputed. The accuracy of the name of the article is disputed. According to WP:COMMONNAME the name of this article should reflect the reliable references used to edit it, as it did when it was awarded a GA. But those who wish to dispute the guidelines in WP:COMMONNAME and put a consensus of personal opinions higher than relevant references, have taken over this article. It can't be a good article while it is called a battle. --
Rskp (
talk)
04:45, 26 November 2011 (UTC)reply
Without any further discussion the article with 'battle' in the title has been reinstated as a GA article despite an ongoing dispute regarding the name. How can that be?--
Rskp (
talk)
03:11, 27 November 2011 (UTC)reply