![]() | This article is rated B-class on Wikipedia's
content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | ||||||||||
|
|
|
This page has archives. Sections older than 1000 days may be automatically archived by Lowercase sigmabot III when more than 3 sections are present. |
I give references to some spiral-shaped periodic systems of elements
The French geologist , Alexandre-Émile Béguyer de Chancourtois was the first person to make use of atomic weights to produce a classification of periodicity. He drew the elements as a continuous spiral around a metal cylinder divided into 16 parts. The atomic weight of oxygen was taken as 16 and was used as the standard against which all the other elements were compared. Tellurium was situated at the centre, prompting vis tellurique, or telluric screw. Many thanks to Peter Wothers – and courtesy of the Master and Fellows of St Catharine's College, Cambridge – comes a high quality image of the original 1862 formulation. 1862 Béguyer de Chancourtois' Vis Tellurique
Hinrichs' system is based on the relationship of what he called: "pantogens, with its atoms called panatoms, which explains the numerical relations of atomic weights and gives a simple classification of the elements." This classification system culminated in 1867 in his spiral periodic table, which better clarified the groupings of elements. Hinrichs' classification, while distinctly different from the other periodic tables of this period, "seems to capture many of the primary periodicity relationships seen in the modern periodic table... it is not cluttered by attempts to show secondary kinship relationships." (Scerri) Gustavus Detlef Hinrichs' spiral "Programme of Atomechanics". Programm der Atomechanik oder die Chemie eine Mechanik de Pantome, Augustus Hageboek, Iowa City, IA (1867). 1867 Hinrichs' Programme of Atomechanics
Johnstone Stoney's Spiral, taken from A. E. Garrett's The Periodic Law (page 167, 1909 pub. D. Appleton And Company). The reference is given – page 167 – is: Phil. Mag. [6, 4, pp 411 et seq.; Proc. Roy. Soc., 1888, p115.]
From in The Helicoidal Classification of the Elements, Chemical News vol. 138, 21 June 1929, Fig. XI, p. 392 1928 Janet's "Lemniscate" Formulation
Janet's Helicoidal Classification, essentially his left-step formulation in its spiral version (ref. Charles Janet, La Classification Hélicoïdale des Éléments Chimiques. Beauvais: Imprimerie Départementale de l'Oise. 1928). Information supplied by Philip Stewart 1928 Janet's Helicoidal Classification
A spiral periodic table available as a poster, binder, cup, T-shirt, etc. by Vectoria 2008 Spiral Periodic Table
By Alexander Makeyev – integrated interdisciplinary researcher, inventor, poet – a long pdf document (1093 pages in Russian, here) that contains a new formulation 2011 Makeyev's Periodic Table
Statement: "The orbital periodicity of the elements are the periodic function of their atomic number." By Muzzammil Qureshi. 2021 Discoid Periodic Table of The Elements
Etc. Alex makeyev ( talk) 10:57, 18 August 2022 (UTC)
The "curled ribbon" form in the Gallery section includes visuals of the various atomic radii, determined on a "metallic" basis - presumably because it gives the cleanest trend. Elements that are not metallic at room temperature have had ratios assigned by some other means (curve-fitting?) that reflect this trend.
...Except for the noble gases, which are shown as having similar sizes to the subsequent alkaline metal rather than - as one would expect - the preceding halogen. I can't see any way in which this would make sense. 2A02:6B6E:D0FF:0:DCF8:7A44:3E22:72F6 ( talk) 07:16, 16 January 2023 (UTC)
This article was previously called "Alternative periodic tables". It was today renamed "Types of periodic tables." The contents have been renovated, restructured and expanded. --- Sandbh ( talk) 02:51, 12 June 2023 (UTC)
Dayyan Ahmed Qureshi, I have removed the Discoid table from the article as it does not show periodicity for groups 3 to 12.
In your paper you say:
In fact, transition metal groups differ from each other in terms of electron configuration, oxidation states, complex formation, reactivity, physical properties, and their roles in various applications.
For example:
The problem with the Discoid table is that it crams the lanthanides and actinides into the same arcs as the elements from Lu to Hg, and from from Lr to Cn, resulting in the loss of transition metal group structures.
Sandbh ( talk) Sandbh ( talk) 05:54, 19 August 2023 (UTC)
![]() | This article is rated B-class on Wikipedia's
content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | ||||||||||
|
|
|
This page has archives. Sections older than 1000 days may be automatically archived by Lowercase sigmabot III when more than 3 sections are present. |
I give references to some spiral-shaped periodic systems of elements
The French geologist , Alexandre-Émile Béguyer de Chancourtois was the first person to make use of atomic weights to produce a classification of periodicity. He drew the elements as a continuous spiral around a metal cylinder divided into 16 parts. The atomic weight of oxygen was taken as 16 and was used as the standard against which all the other elements were compared. Tellurium was situated at the centre, prompting vis tellurique, or telluric screw. Many thanks to Peter Wothers – and courtesy of the Master and Fellows of St Catharine's College, Cambridge – comes a high quality image of the original 1862 formulation. 1862 Béguyer de Chancourtois' Vis Tellurique
Hinrichs' system is based on the relationship of what he called: "pantogens, with its atoms called panatoms, which explains the numerical relations of atomic weights and gives a simple classification of the elements." This classification system culminated in 1867 in his spiral periodic table, which better clarified the groupings of elements. Hinrichs' classification, while distinctly different from the other periodic tables of this period, "seems to capture many of the primary periodicity relationships seen in the modern periodic table... it is not cluttered by attempts to show secondary kinship relationships." (Scerri) Gustavus Detlef Hinrichs' spiral "Programme of Atomechanics". Programm der Atomechanik oder die Chemie eine Mechanik de Pantome, Augustus Hageboek, Iowa City, IA (1867). 1867 Hinrichs' Programme of Atomechanics
Johnstone Stoney's Spiral, taken from A. E. Garrett's The Periodic Law (page 167, 1909 pub. D. Appleton And Company). The reference is given – page 167 – is: Phil. Mag. [6, 4, pp 411 et seq.; Proc. Roy. Soc., 1888, p115.]
From in The Helicoidal Classification of the Elements, Chemical News vol. 138, 21 June 1929, Fig. XI, p. 392 1928 Janet's "Lemniscate" Formulation
Janet's Helicoidal Classification, essentially his left-step formulation in its spiral version (ref. Charles Janet, La Classification Hélicoïdale des Éléments Chimiques. Beauvais: Imprimerie Départementale de l'Oise. 1928). Information supplied by Philip Stewart 1928 Janet's Helicoidal Classification
A spiral periodic table available as a poster, binder, cup, T-shirt, etc. by Vectoria 2008 Spiral Periodic Table
By Alexander Makeyev – integrated interdisciplinary researcher, inventor, poet – a long pdf document (1093 pages in Russian, here) that contains a new formulation 2011 Makeyev's Periodic Table
Statement: "The orbital periodicity of the elements are the periodic function of their atomic number." By Muzzammil Qureshi. 2021 Discoid Periodic Table of The Elements
Etc. Alex makeyev ( talk) 10:57, 18 August 2022 (UTC)
The "curled ribbon" form in the Gallery section includes visuals of the various atomic radii, determined on a "metallic" basis - presumably because it gives the cleanest trend. Elements that are not metallic at room temperature have had ratios assigned by some other means (curve-fitting?) that reflect this trend.
...Except for the noble gases, which are shown as having similar sizes to the subsequent alkaline metal rather than - as one would expect - the preceding halogen. I can't see any way in which this would make sense. 2A02:6B6E:D0FF:0:DCF8:7A44:3E22:72F6 ( talk) 07:16, 16 January 2023 (UTC)
This article was previously called "Alternative periodic tables". It was today renamed "Types of periodic tables." The contents have been renovated, restructured and expanded. --- Sandbh ( talk) 02:51, 12 June 2023 (UTC)
Dayyan Ahmed Qureshi, I have removed the Discoid table from the article as it does not show periodicity for groups 3 to 12.
In your paper you say:
In fact, transition metal groups differ from each other in terms of electron configuration, oxidation states, complex formation, reactivity, physical properties, and their roles in various applications.
For example:
The problem with the Discoid table is that it crams the lanthanides and actinides into the same arcs as the elements from Lu to Hg, and from from Lr to Cn, resulting in the loss of transition metal group structures.
Sandbh ( talk) Sandbh ( talk) 05:54, 19 August 2023 (UTC)