23:5523:55, 1 March 2024diffhist0
Battle of France
Undid revision 1211300324 by
ThoughtIdRetired (
talk) An unregistered contributor decided to modify the estimate of the infobox a few months ago. What should appear in the infobox is the estimate of the number of soldiers dead from all causes related to the war, i.e killed in action, dead of wounds, missing confirmed dead, etc. (as it is for the French, British, Dutch and Belgians) that is the estimate of 49,000 dead.Tag: Undo
17:0617:06, 11 February 2024diffhist−28
Battle of Pavia
It makes no sense to use two different estimates from the same historian. Using the most recent of these is more appropriate. Also, it's a figure of losses, not just killed or wounded.
23:0823:08, 18 September 2023diffhist−15
Battle of Sidi Brahim
Undid revision 1176019371 by
M.Bitton (
talk) It is not a "French claim". The source is a modern historian, and if we started saying that a figure from a modern British historian is "a British claim", or a figure from a modern German historian is "a German claim", it would never end. Also, it is not like if this figure seemed exaggerated in any way.Tags: UndoReverted
16:0016:00, 10 September 2023diffhist−108
Battle of Augusta
I'm sorry but looking at this order of battle, there are way more than just 17 ships of the line. 13 Dutch warships have more than 46 guns and 10+ Spanish ships. Also, your infobox doesn't correspond to the previous source, Jenkins.
23:5523:55, 1 March 2024diffhist0
Battle of France
Undid revision 1211300324 by
ThoughtIdRetired (
talk) An unregistered contributor decided to modify the estimate of the infobox a few months ago. What should appear in the infobox is the estimate of the number of soldiers dead from all causes related to the war, i.e killed in action, dead of wounds, missing confirmed dead, etc. (as it is for the French, British, Dutch and Belgians) that is the estimate of 49,000 dead.Tag: Undo
17:0617:06, 11 February 2024diffhist−28
Battle of Pavia
It makes no sense to use two different estimates from the same historian. Using the most recent of these is more appropriate. Also, it's a figure of losses, not just killed or wounded.
23:0823:08, 18 September 2023diffhist−15
Battle of Sidi Brahim
Undid revision 1176019371 by
M.Bitton (
talk) It is not a "French claim". The source is a modern historian, and if we started saying that a figure from a modern British historian is "a British claim", or a figure from a modern German historian is "a German claim", it would never end. Also, it is not like if this figure seemed exaggerated in any way.Tags: UndoReverted
16:0016:00, 10 September 2023diffhist−108
Battle of Augusta
I'm sorry but looking at this order of battle, there are way more than just 17 ships of the line. 13 Dutch warships have more than 46 guns and 10+ Spanish ships. Also, your infobox doesn't correspond to the previous source, Jenkins.