07:0707:07, 14 June 2021diffhist+252
June 2013 Egyptian protests
Undid revision 1028470449 by
Jacksonblack11 (
talk) It's common knowledge by now that Tamarod was anything but a grassroots movement. Hopefully the linked source makes that obvious for you now. If you have more to say, we can discuss in the talk page.
04:5904:59, 14 June 2021diffhist−491
Abdel Fattah el-Sisi
A more balanced view of the events following the coup as described in the lede. The previous format was completely one-sided and inaccurate especially in how it claims the crackdown followed attacks on security forces when the reverse is true.Tag: Visual edit: Switched
04:2804:28, 14 June 2021diffhist+130
m
June 2013 Egyptian protests
Undid revision 1024115294 by
Jacksonblack11 (
talk) if anything it's you claims which are ''Bold claims that have no source verifying the information''. The sources are provided in the references following the claims of exaggerated crowd sizes.Tags: UndoReverted
01:2201:22, 6 July 2019diffhist+863
June 2013 Egyptian protests
reverted changes based on personal opinions in preference to those supported by references. If you disagree, I started a discussion on the talk page. let's sort it out there.
14:4614:46, 30 June 2019diffhist+86
June 2013 Egyptian protests
Undid revision 904141960 by
212.15.176.139 (
talk) I actually think your rephrasing makes things worse because it once again includes the illogical 32 million, even if disputing it, in the lede. The only way the 1 million figure is to be removed, for accuracy, is if the 32 million number is removed as well and replaced with large.Tag: Undo
14:3014:30, 29 June 2019diffhist+886
June 2013 Egyptian protests
Undid revision 903626359 by
141.138.43.3 (
talk) the sources linked clearly show where the information is from. If the Egyptian military numbers is to be noted in the lede, then so should the critical examination by experts. As for 'widely believed' that is not a legitimate talking point without evidence.Tag: Undo
06:5806:58, 12 October 2018diffhist+887
June 2013 Egyptian protests
Undid revision 861494322 by
82.4.219.229 (
talk) What do you mean that it was proved by most? Like who for example? I'm aware that many international organisations reported 'millions' against Morsi protesting but none went as far high as the illogical 30 million.Tag: Undo
06:5006:50, 19 June 2018diffhist+436
Mohamed Morsi
added more context to Morsi's constitutional decree and the point that the draft constitution was hastily finalised and not hastily written after the decree. The constitution had been in the works since the selection of the second assembly in June. Also provided additional references
20:2220:22, 11 June 2018diffhist−3,345
Muslim Brotherhood
Undid revision 845430001 by
יניב הורון (
talk) you think I'd be going through all this without reading the sources? I have read the sources and hence I removed the content that wasn't supported or were supported by unreliable sources. How about you show me where it mentions the two particular issues I brought up?Tag: Undo
10 June 2018
22:0522:05, 10 June 2018diffhist−3,345
Muslim Brotherhood
Undid revision 845292045 by
יניב הורון (
talk) as I said, most the content I removed is referenced from clearly biased and unreliable sources or the listed references don't support them at all. For example, where does it say the MB is 'far-right' or that Qutb is 'anti-Semitic thinker of Islamic supremacism' from the sources listed?Tag: Undo
02:4802:48, 10 June 2018diffhist−3,345
Muslim Brotherhood
removed content that had biased and unreliable sourcing regarding the strategy of the MB and also removed other claims that were unsupported by their references.
9 June 2018
21:4821:48, 9 June 2018diffhist−2,291
Muslim Brotherhood
Undid revision 845154413 by
יניב הורון (
talk) two editors agree that the sources for that content are clearly biased and unreliable therefore not warranting such a contentious mention in the lead. How about you make your arguments in the talk page if you disagree?Tag: Undo
00:5200:52, 9 June 2018diffhist−2,202
Muslim Brotherhood
Removed the Muslim Brotherhood seats in parliaments of several countries from the Infobox. The political parties that make up the legislatures of many Islamic countries as previously listed in the Infobox are not directly linked to the mother Muslim Brotherhood organisation in Egypt. In many cases they are just inspired by the MB as is the case with Ennahda in Tunisia and Al-Islah in Yemen. Listing them as before suggests an organic link which is quite misleading.
8 June 2018
21:5521:55, 8 June 2018diffhist−1,720
Muslim Brotherhood
Undid revision 844989419 by
יניב הורון (
talk) We have a third opinion who agrees the sources for the claims are clearly unreliable. If you have objections, then make your arguments in the talk page.Tag: Undo
07:2207:22, 8 June 2018diffhist−1,720
Muslim Brotherhood
removed a line in the lead claiming that the MB was in its early years 'financed and supported by Nazi Germany' which had unreliable and biased sourcing as per the talk page discussion
06:1506:15, 7 June 2018diffhist−1,720
Muslim Brotherhood
Undid revision 844761565 by
יניב הורון (
talk) the sources referenced for this claim are more like propaganda pieces than a fair assessment of the MB's history. Also, the Al-Araby quote if from a Mufti who is used to making outlandish and unfounded remarks.Tag: Undo
00:0800:08, 7 June 2018diffhist−1,720
Muslim Brotherhood
removed a line in the lead claiming that the MB was in its early years 'financed and supported by Nazi Germany' which had dubious sourcing.
07:0707:07, 14 June 2021diffhist+252
June 2013 Egyptian protests
Undid revision 1028470449 by
Jacksonblack11 (
talk) It's common knowledge by now that Tamarod was anything but a grassroots movement. Hopefully the linked source makes that obvious for you now. If you have more to say, we can discuss in the talk page.
04:5904:59, 14 June 2021diffhist−491
Abdel Fattah el-Sisi
A more balanced view of the events following the coup as described in the lede. The previous format was completely one-sided and inaccurate especially in how it claims the crackdown followed attacks on security forces when the reverse is true.Tag: Visual edit: Switched
04:2804:28, 14 June 2021diffhist+130
m
June 2013 Egyptian protests
Undid revision 1024115294 by
Jacksonblack11 (
talk) if anything it's you claims which are ''Bold claims that have no source verifying the information''. The sources are provided in the references following the claims of exaggerated crowd sizes.Tags: UndoReverted
01:2201:22, 6 July 2019diffhist+863
June 2013 Egyptian protests
reverted changes based on personal opinions in preference to those supported by references. If you disagree, I started a discussion on the talk page. let's sort it out there.
14:4614:46, 30 June 2019diffhist+86
June 2013 Egyptian protests
Undid revision 904141960 by
212.15.176.139 (
talk) I actually think your rephrasing makes things worse because it once again includes the illogical 32 million, even if disputing it, in the lede. The only way the 1 million figure is to be removed, for accuracy, is if the 32 million number is removed as well and replaced with large.Tag: Undo
14:3014:30, 29 June 2019diffhist+886
June 2013 Egyptian protests
Undid revision 903626359 by
141.138.43.3 (
talk) the sources linked clearly show where the information is from. If the Egyptian military numbers is to be noted in the lede, then so should the critical examination by experts. As for 'widely believed' that is not a legitimate talking point without evidence.Tag: Undo
06:5806:58, 12 October 2018diffhist+887
June 2013 Egyptian protests
Undid revision 861494322 by
82.4.219.229 (
talk) What do you mean that it was proved by most? Like who for example? I'm aware that many international organisations reported 'millions' against Morsi protesting but none went as far high as the illogical 30 million.Tag: Undo
06:5006:50, 19 June 2018diffhist+436
Mohamed Morsi
added more context to Morsi's constitutional decree and the point that the draft constitution was hastily finalised and not hastily written after the decree. The constitution had been in the works since the selection of the second assembly in June. Also provided additional references
20:2220:22, 11 June 2018diffhist−3,345
Muslim Brotherhood
Undid revision 845430001 by
יניב הורון (
talk) you think I'd be going through all this without reading the sources? I have read the sources and hence I removed the content that wasn't supported or were supported by unreliable sources. How about you show me where it mentions the two particular issues I brought up?Tag: Undo
10 June 2018
22:0522:05, 10 June 2018diffhist−3,345
Muslim Brotherhood
Undid revision 845292045 by
יניב הורון (
talk) as I said, most the content I removed is referenced from clearly biased and unreliable sources or the listed references don't support them at all. For example, where does it say the MB is 'far-right' or that Qutb is 'anti-Semitic thinker of Islamic supremacism' from the sources listed?Tag: Undo
02:4802:48, 10 June 2018diffhist−3,345
Muslim Brotherhood
removed content that had biased and unreliable sourcing regarding the strategy of the MB and also removed other claims that were unsupported by their references.
9 June 2018
21:4821:48, 9 June 2018diffhist−2,291
Muslim Brotherhood
Undid revision 845154413 by
יניב הורון (
talk) two editors agree that the sources for that content are clearly biased and unreliable therefore not warranting such a contentious mention in the lead. How about you make your arguments in the talk page if you disagree?Tag: Undo
00:5200:52, 9 June 2018diffhist−2,202
Muslim Brotherhood
Removed the Muslim Brotherhood seats in parliaments of several countries from the Infobox. The political parties that make up the legislatures of many Islamic countries as previously listed in the Infobox are not directly linked to the mother Muslim Brotherhood organisation in Egypt. In many cases they are just inspired by the MB as is the case with Ennahda in Tunisia and Al-Islah in Yemen. Listing them as before suggests an organic link which is quite misleading.
8 June 2018
21:5521:55, 8 June 2018diffhist−1,720
Muslim Brotherhood
Undid revision 844989419 by
יניב הורון (
talk) We have a third opinion who agrees the sources for the claims are clearly unreliable. If you have objections, then make your arguments in the talk page.Tag: Undo
07:2207:22, 8 June 2018diffhist−1,720
Muslim Brotherhood
removed a line in the lead claiming that the MB was in its early years 'financed and supported by Nazi Germany' which had unreliable and biased sourcing as per the talk page discussion
06:1506:15, 7 June 2018diffhist−1,720
Muslim Brotherhood
Undid revision 844761565 by
יניב הורון (
talk) the sources referenced for this claim are more like propaganda pieces than a fair assessment of the MB's history. Also, the Al-Araby quote if from a Mufti who is used to making outlandish and unfounded remarks.Tag: Undo
00:0800:08, 7 June 2018diffhist−1,720
Muslim Brotherhood
removed a line in the lead claiming that the MB was in its early years 'financed and supported by Nazi Germany' which had dubious sourcing.