00:4000:40, 18 July 2018diffhist−269
Haplogroup R1a
Undid revision 850791590 by
Travelmite (
talk) I did NOT remove any sourced material; I removed original research and speculation, including statements not stated at all in the Haak study; Haak says R1a originated with Yamna; Semenov is the source saying it originates with Corded Ware; the rest of the content was ORTag: Undo
00:3700:37, 18 July 2018diffhist+772
Gaels
Undid revision 850785866 by
Travelmite (
talk) the PNAS article talks about Irish and Scottish populations, and specifically the earliest speakers of Celtic languages which is Gaelic, and thus obviously includes GaelsTag: Undo
00:3400:34, 18 July 2018diffhist+318
Australo-Melanesian
included references; Australoid, Caucasoid, Mongoloid, Negroid, Capoid, Pygmoid and sub-classifications are still used extensively in population genetics, medicine, forensics and biological anthropology, as they have extensive and valid genetic and physiological support
00:2800:28, 18 July 2018diffhist−11
Australo-Melanesian
look, there are three recent, academic journal articles in this article using Australoid; I can find fifty more for the past 5 years alone; it's a valid term used to refers to populations with shared genetic and physical features: South Indians, Negritos, Andamanese, Papuans, Melanesians and Australian Aboriginese
00:2600:26, 18 July 2018diffhist+53
Australo-Melanesian
→Racial depiction: this is a nonsense source; Coon's categories were not perfect but his very important works are still cited to this day in various studies, and were not "scientific racism", a bogus leftist term; much of his work has also been validated by most recent research; these physical features, such as unique sizes of teeth and brow ridges, are routinely described for these groups in physical anthropology, and mentioned in various modern studies
23:2423:24, 17 July 2018diffhist−1,627
Hungarians
Undid revision 850780188 by
Travelmite (
talk) 1) I made several edits here, so to re-vert the whole t hing is unfounded and lazy 2) I removed a duplicate entry 3) the rest is not sourced material 4) I removed an invalid, outdated, discredited sourceTags: Undoreferences removed
23:2323:23, 17 July 2018diffhist+22
Aboriginal Australians
Undid revision 850779396 by
Travelmite (
talk) I provided an explanation for my edits; you did not provide one when moving them; reference shows relation with south Indians (Veddoid), not Austroasiatic/partially Mongoloid east IndiansTags: UndoNon-autoconfirmed user rapidly reverting edits
23:2123:21, 17 July 2018diffhist−8
Melanesians
Undid revision 850780914 by
Travelmite (
talk) what you entered is not consistent with the source; Austronesian is not the genetic component they are referring to; the Papuan/Negrito/Aborigine component is referred to as Australo-Melanesian; Austronesian is a southeast Asian genetic component not found in Papuans, and only a tiny bit in MelanesiansTag: Undo
23:1923:19, 17 July 2018diffhist−269
Haplogroup R1a
Undid revision 850782312 by
Travelmite (
talk) unxplained re-vert; I did not remove a source here at all, but corrected to reflect what it said; what was stated before was original researchTag: Undo
21:2821:28, 17 July 2018diffhist−45
Hungarians
these other foreign groups were not Magyars; Magyars are those descended from the Magyar(Ugric)-Avar/Turkic-Pannonian/Celtic population of the Carpathian Basin of the 9th to 10th centuries
20:5220:52, 17 July 2018diffhist+5
Hungarians
→Other influences: most European countries did not have a long resident Armenian population, and most in northern Europe and western Europe did not have Roma populations until the past two or three centuries
20:2820:28, 17 July 2018diffhist−269
Haplogroup R1a
→Source of R1a1a1 in Corded Ware culture: removed statements which smack of OR; Haak et al concluded that R1a also originated from Yamna, since Corded Ware originated directly from Yamna, and some R1a samples from Corded Ware could also be placed in the Yamna horizon instead; Semenov concluded it originated in Comb Ware, so I included that study still
20:1420:14, 17 July 2018diffhist+13
Haplogroup R1b
Read Haak et al: R1a was found in some remains of the Yamna culture area, and was found in high frequencies in its direct successors, Poltkava and Sintashta in Central Asia, as well as to a smaller degree in Corded Ware in Europe
20:0620:06, 17 July 2018diffhist−33
Haplogroup R1b
As per Haak and other studies: 1) Sintashta, etc IS a successor culture from Yamna 2) Yamna is the earliest Aryan/IE culture, from which R1b and R1a spread into Europe (as well as eastwards into Central Asia, mostly R1a) in successor IE cultures 3) Bell Beaker and Corded Ware are both successor cultures of Yamna in Europe
19:2819:28, 17 July 2018diffhist−50
Haplogroup R1b
Undid revision 850652791 by
Joshua Jonathan (
talk) Corded Ware was a successor of Yamna, the earliest Aryan/IE culture, that moved west; R1a found in both, but more common in Corded Ware, and in the Maykop cultureTag: Undo
19:1319:13, 17 July 2018diffhist−187
Ainu people
→Origins: results of this study with regards to Ainu and Jomon already mentioned earlier in this section, with better description of findings
00:4000:40, 18 July 2018diffhist−269
Haplogroup R1a
Undid revision 850791590 by
Travelmite (
talk) I did NOT remove any sourced material; I removed original research and speculation, including statements not stated at all in the Haak study; Haak says R1a originated with Yamna; Semenov is the source saying it originates with Corded Ware; the rest of the content was ORTag: Undo
00:3700:37, 18 July 2018diffhist+772
Gaels
Undid revision 850785866 by
Travelmite (
talk) the PNAS article talks about Irish and Scottish populations, and specifically the earliest speakers of Celtic languages which is Gaelic, and thus obviously includes GaelsTag: Undo
00:3400:34, 18 July 2018diffhist+318
Australo-Melanesian
included references; Australoid, Caucasoid, Mongoloid, Negroid, Capoid, Pygmoid and sub-classifications are still used extensively in population genetics, medicine, forensics and biological anthropology, as they have extensive and valid genetic and physiological support
00:2800:28, 18 July 2018diffhist−11
Australo-Melanesian
look, there are three recent, academic journal articles in this article using Australoid; I can find fifty more for the past 5 years alone; it's a valid term used to refers to populations with shared genetic and physical features: South Indians, Negritos, Andamanese, Papuans, Melanesians and Australian Aboriginese
00:2600:26, 18 July 2018diffhist+53
Australo-Melanesian
→Racial depiction: this is a nonsense source; Coon's categories were not perfect but his very important works are still cited to this day in various studies, and were not "scientific racism", a bogus leftist term; much of his work has also been validated by most recent research; these physical features, such as unique sizes of teeth and brow ridges, are routinely described for these groups in physical anthropology, and mentioned in various modern studies
23:2423:24, 17 July 2018diffhist−1,627
Hungarians
Undid revision 850780188 by
Travelmite (
talk) 1) I made several edits here, so to re-vert the whole t hing is unfounded and lazy 2) I removed a duplicate entry 3) the rest is not sourced material 4) I removed an invalid, outdated, discredited sourceTags: Undoreferences removed
23:2323:23, 17 July 2018diffhist+22
Aboriginal Australians
Undid revision 850779396 by
Travelmite (
talk) I provided an explanation for my edits; you did not provide one when moving them; reference shows relation with south Indians (Veddoid), not Austroasiatic/partially Mongoloid east IndiansTags: UndoNon-autoconfirmed user rapidly reverting edits
23:2123:21, 17 July 2018diffhist−8
Melanesians
Undid revision 850780914 by
Travelmite (
talk) what you entered is not consistent with the source; Austronesian is not the genetic component they are referring to; the Papuan/Negrito/Aborigine component is referred to as Australo-Melanesian; Austronesian is a southeast Asian genetic component not found in Papuans, and only a tiny bit in MelanesiansTag: Undo
23:1923:19, 17 July 2018diffhist−269
Haplogroup R1a
Undid revision 850782312 by
Travelmite (
talk) unxplained re-vert; I did not remove a source here at all, but corrected to reflect what it said; what was stated before was original researchTag: Undo
21:2821:28, 17 July 2018diffhist−45
Hungarians
these other foreign groups were not Magyars; Magyars are those descended from the Magyar(Ugric)-Avar/Turkic-Pannonian/Celtic population of the Carpathian Basin of the 9th to 10th centuries
20:5220:52, 17 July 2018diffhist+5
Hungarians
→Other influences: most European countries did not have a long resident Armenian population, and most in northern Europe and western Europe did not have Roma populations until the past two or three centuries
20:2820:28, 17 July 2018diffhist−269
Haplogroup R1a
→Source of R1a1a1 in Corded Ware culture: removed statements which smack of OR; Haak et al concluded that R1a also originated from Yamna, since Corded Ware originated directly from Yamna, and some R1a samples from Corded Ware could also be placed in the Yamna horizon instead; Semenov concluded it originated in Comb Ware, so I included that study still
20:1420:14, 17 July 2018diffhist+13
Haplogroup R1b
Read Haak et al: R1a was found in some remains of the Yamna culture area, and was found in high frequencies in its direct successors, Poltkava and Sintashta in Central Asia, as well as to a smaller degree in Corded Ware in Europe
20:0620:06, 17 July 2018diffhist−33
Haplogroup R1b
As per Haak and other studies: 1) Sintashta, etc IS a successor culture from Yamna 2) Yamna is the earliest Aryan/IE culture, from which R1b and R1a spread into Europe (as well as eastwards into Central Asia, mostly R1a) in successor IE cultures 3) Bell Beaker and Corded Ware are both successor cultures of Yamna in Europe
19:2819:28, 17 July 2018diffhist−50
Haplogroup R1b
Undid revision 850652791 by
Joshua Jonathan (
talk) Corded Ware was a successor of Yamna, the earliest Aryan/IE culture, that moved west; R1a found in both, but more common in Corded Ware, and in the Maykop cultureTag: Undo
19:1319:13, 17 July 2018diffhist−187
Ainu people
→Origins: results of this study with regards to Ainu and Jomon already mentioned earlier in this section, with better description of findings